Here are two judgments about the same source. The source is invented for this example: a 1932 report from a district party secretary to Moscow saying the grain quota has been met. The first judgment says: "Source 4 is reliable because it is a primary source written at the time." The second says: "Source 4 is useful for showing what Moscow was being told in 1932, because its author was the official answerable for the quota. For the same reason it is a weak guide to how much grain the villages actually gave up, since reporting a shortfall could have cost him his post." Only the second makes two judgments, one about usefulness and one about reliability, and reasons both from who wrote the source and why. Evaluating was the criterion QCAA marked down most often in every Modern History IA in 2025.
The four Modern History assessments in Units 3 and 4
General Modern History on the 2025 syllabus has three internal assessments and one external exam. Each is worth 25% of your subject result. The 2025 syllabus applies to every student finishing Year 12 in 2026 or later, so if you start Unit 3 in Term 1 2027, this is your structure. The current version is v1.4, from March 2026.
| Assessment and unit | Length |
|---|---|
| IA1 Examination: an essay in response to historical sources, Unit 3 | 120 minutes, plus 15 minutes planning |
| IA2 Investigation: an independent source investigation, Unit 3 | Up to 2000 words |
| IA3 Investigation: a historical essay based on research, Unit 4 | Up to 2000 words |
| External exam: short responses to historical sources, Unit 4 Topic 2 | 120 minutes, plus 15 minutes planning |
Unit 3 is national experiences, such as Australia since 1901, the Soviet Union from the 1920s to 1945, or India since 1947. Unit 4 is international experiences, such as the search for collective peace and security since 1815, or the Cold War and its aftermath. Your school picks the topics and the aspect of each topic you study in depth. IA1 and IA2 come from your two Unit 3 topics. Unit 4 has two topic slots: for Topic 1 your school chooses from a list of 13, and that topic is assessed in IA3. Topic 2 is one of two topics QCAA nominates, and it is assessed in the external exam.
Check the structure of your other subjects on the QCAA subjects hub, and see how four 25% pieces combine on the subject result calculator.
When each IA falls in 2027
Your school sets the exact due dates, and your assessment schedule is the one that counts. QCAA's Senior Education Profile calendar sets the deadlines schools work back from.
- Term 1
Your first Unit 3 topic and the IA1 exam. Schools must enter IA1 provisional marks by Tuesday 13 April 2027, early in Term 2, so expect the exam in Term 1.
- Terms 1 and 2
Your second Unit 3 topic and the independent source investigation. Schools that opt in to QCAA's second confirmation event enter IA2 marks by Tuesday 8 June 2027. Every other school submits them with IA3 on Tuesday 17 August 2027.
- Terms 2 and 3
Unit 4 Topic 1 and the historical essay based on research. IA3 provisional marks are due by Tuesday 17 August 2027.
- 25 Oct to 16 Nov
The external assessment block. Unit 4 Topic 2 is examined, and QCAA sets the day of the Modern History paper.
For how a single task runs from task sheet to submission, see the internal assessment timeline.
What changed from the 2019 syllabus
Many of the exemplars, notes and past tasks still in circulation were written for the 2019 syllabus. QCAA's 2025 Modern History subject report lists the differences. Several of them change how you should write.
IA1: the essay in response to historical sources
IA1 is a supervised exam on one of your Unit 3 topics. You write an essay that answers an unseen question, using evidence from a stimulus of 9 to 12 sources. Six or seven of them are seen sources, handed out one week before the exam. Three to five are unseen, and you meet them in the exam. Every source comes with a context statement, which can tell you about the author, when the source was produced and the circumstances it was produced in.
- Comprehending5 marks
- Analysing5 marks
- Evaluating5 marks
- Synthesising5 marks
- Communicating5 marks
You get 15 minutes of planning time and 120 minutes of working time. You cannot take notes into the exam, and your teacher gives you a clean copy of the whole stimulus at the start.
Use the week with the seen sources
Your teacher is not allowed to help you interrogate the seen sources, so that week is yours. You can't carry notes in, but you can walk in already knowing what each seen source is good for. For each one, work out:
- who made it, when, for whom and why, using the context statement as well as the excerpt
- whose perspective it carries, and whose it leaves out
- what questions it could help answer, and what it could not tell you
- which other seen sources agree with it, and which contradict it.
Then practise on likely questions. QCAA's report praised IA1 questions narrowed to a specific person, group, timeframe or idea. Its example is a senior member of the Chinese Communist Party, rather than the whole party. So expect "To what extent did collectivisation between 1929 and 1933 achieve Stalin's aims for Soviet agriculture?" rather than "Assess the Soviet Union under Stalin". That invented example question is the one used through the rest of this section.
Comprehending and Analysing: terms in context, features of evidence
The top band of Comprehending (4–5) asks for "thorough and mostly accurate use of terms in historical context", an "informed understanding of concepts related to the unseen question" and a "detailed explanation of issues related to the unseen question". QCAA's report says markers look for terms, plural, each linked to a specific time or place. Writing "kulaks" is using a term. Writing that the 1930 campaign to "liquidate the kulaks as a class" let officials label any peasant who resisted as a kulak places it in context.
Analysing at 5 asks for "discerning selection and detailed examination of features of evidence from historical sources". The syllabus lists features of evidence as origin, motive, audience, perspectives, historical context, and explicit and implicit meanings. The step down to 4 is "effective examination", and the step to 2 is "identification of features of evidence from historical sources". Saying a source is a government statistic identifies its origin. Asking why a government publishing figures in 1933 might count what it collected rather than what was grown examines it. QCAA's report adds that the upper band draws on a range of sources: primary and secondary, written and visual, and sources with different perspectives.
Evaluating: judgments, plural
The IA1 top band asks for "discerning and well-reasoned judgments about the usefulness and/or reliability of evidence from historical sources in the stimulus". Two words in that descriptor matter. In IA1, unlike IA2 and IA3, every band says "and/or", so the top band does not strictly require both usefulness and reliability, though the strongest judgments often weigh both. And "judgments" means more than one. The 2025 report is explicit: "At the upper and mid performance levels, judgments (plural) about the usefulness and/or reliability of evidence from sources are required."
The syllabus defines the two terms differently. Usefulness is about how relevant the evidence is to the question you are answering. Reliability is about how far the evidence can be trusted for that question. A source can be useful without being reliable, like the district report in the opening example: it is excellent evidence of what officials claimed and poor evidence of what happened.
Superficial
"Source 6 is a cartoon from an émigré newspaper in Paris, so it is biased against Stalin and not reliable."
Discerning and well-reasoned
"Source 6 was drawn in 1930 for Russian émigrés in Paris who wanted the regime to fail, so it is not reliable as a record of conditions on the collective farms. It is useful for this question in another way: by showing peasants herded into a collective at gunpoint, it captures what opponents abroad believed collectivisation was, and that belief is consistent with Source 3's account of forced entry."
The sources are invented for this example. The second judgment does three things the first does not. It reasons from the source's origin and audience, it says what the source is still useful for, and it checks the claim against another source. That last move is optional on the 2025 ISMG, but the syllabus still lists corroboration and contradiction as things that affect usefulness and reliability.
Synthesising: argue with the sources, not through them
The top band (5) asks for a "sophisticated historical argument that skilfully combines evidence from a range of historical sources to justify decisions". In the syllabus, a decision is a main point within your historical argument. QCAA's report spells out what makes an argument sophisticated:
Basic
"Source 2 shows that grain collections rose after collectivisation. Source 5 shows that livestock numbers fell. Source 7 says peasants resisted. Therefore collectivisation partly achieved its aims."
Sophisticated
"Collectivisation achieved the aim Stalin cared most about, control of grain, at the cost of the aim it was sold on, a more productive countryside. Sources 2 and 8 agree that state grain collections rose between 1929 and 1931. Their agreement carries weight because they come from different sides: a Moscow statistical digest and a foreign diplomat's report with no stake in the regime's success. Source 5's livestock figures do not contradict them; they explain how the grain was got. Peasants slaughtered their animals rather than hand them over, so the state gained grain while the farms lost the animals that pulled the ploughs."
The source numbers are invented, and the argument is a model of the shape, not a set answer. It is multilayered, because it separates two aims and judges each one. It corroborates, and says why that corroboration counts. And it reconciles evidence that looked contradictory instead of listing it.
Communicating: the features, and naming your sources
The top band (4–5) asks that your response "conveys ideas related to the unseen question clearly and purposefully", that "all features of an essay in response to historical sources are consistently applied", and that it has "minimal errors in spelling, grammar and punctuation". The features are set by the syllabus: an introduction that sets the context and includes a hypothesis and an outline of your argument, body paragraphs with topic sentences, a conclusion that draws the argument together, and ethical scholarship.
In IA1, ethical scholarship means naming the source you are using, by its number, author, title or a mix of these, such as "(Source 4, district report)". QCAA says a recognised referencing system is acceptable in the exam but not required. Write the hypothesis as a sentence your marker can underline, because a hypothesis left implied is a missing feature.
IA2: the independent source investigation
For IA2 you choose an area of a Unit 3 topic and aspect you studied in class, as long as it was not assessed in IA1. In practice, that usually means your second Unit 3 topic. You devise your own questions, find 4–6 sources yourself, interrogate them, and argue from them. The task is individual, is designed to take about 15 hours of class time plus your own time, and has a limit of 2000 words.
| Section | Suggested words |
|---|---|
| Key inquiry question and sub-questions | 150 |
| Interrogation of evidence | 1200 |
| Critical summary | 650 |
The interrogation may be written in bullet points, but the critical summary must be in paragraphs. All five criteria are worth 5 marks: Devising and Conducting, Analysing, Evaluating, Synthesising and Communicating. Most of Analysing and Evaluating is earned in the interrogation. Synthesising is earned in the critical summary.
Devising and Conducting: a question your sources can settle
The top band (4–5) asks for the "development and application of a nuanced key inquiry question and relevant sub-questions", a "discerning selection of relevant evidence from primary and secondary historical sources" and "acknowledgment of different perspectives in the evidence from historical sources". That last descriptor is new in the 2025 syllabus. The middle band accepts "acknowledgment of perspectives"; the top band wants different perspectives, and shows how they differ.
Descriptive
"What happened during the Partition of India?"
Nuanced, with sub-questions
"To what extent did the decision to withhold the Radcliffe boundary award until 17 August 1947 shape the scale of the violence in Punjab?"
- Why did the Viceroy's administration delay publishing the award until after independence?
- How did not knowing where the boundary would fall affect people in Punjab in August 1947?
- What evidence suggests violence was already being organised before the award was published?
- How have historians interpreted responsibility for the violence?
This invented example sits in India since 1947, one of the 13 Unit 3 topics. That topic opens when the Indian Independence Act became law on 18 July 1947, so the question starts after that date. Earlier riots, such as those in Lahore that spring, belong in the investigation only as labelled context. The key inquiry question applies a historical concept, cause and effect, to one decision and one region. The third sub-question is built to test the hypothesis rather than confirm it. QCAA's report describes applying the key inquiry question as showing how your evidence helped answer it, challenged how you had framed it, led you to revise it, or opened new lines of investigation. For a closer look at writing the question itself, and how the history investigations compare with Legal Studies and Study of Religion, see the humanities investigation, criterion by criterion.
Choosing 4–6 sources nobody gave you
The sources must be ones you have not studied or been given in class, and they must include both primary and secondary sources. Primary sources were created during the time you are investigating. Secondary sources are accounts created afterwards, often interpreting primary ones. QCAA's 2026 endorsement report praised task sheets that classify sources only as primary and secondary, rather than "ancient and modern" or "primary, secondary and tertiary".
A strong set covers more than one perspective and more than one type of source. For the Partition question, that might mean an official report from August 1947, a refugee's oral history recorded decades later, a newspaper photograph from that month, a political leader's broadcast after independence and two historians who disagree about responsibility. The syllabus lists ways perspectives differ, including nationality, religious belief, political ideology, social class, gender and the historian's own method. Pick sources so that at least two of those differences are in play.
Evaluating: the criterion QCAA lowered most
In IA2, the top two bands require judgments about usefulness and reliability, not one or the other. The descriptors step down like this:
- 5
discerning and well-reasoned
"discerning and well-reasoned judgments about the usefulness and reliability of evidence from historical sources"
- 4
effective
"effective judgments about the usefulness and reliability of evidence from historical sources"
- 3
adequate
"adequate judgments about the usefulness and/or reliability of evidence from historical sources"
- 2
superficial
"superficial judgments about the usefulness and/or reliability of evidence from historical sources"
- 1
irrelevant or inaccurate
"irrelevant or inaccurate judgments about the usefulness and/or reliability of evidence from historical sources"
A judgment becomes discerning when it is tied to your questions. "This oral history is useful" is a judgment. "This oral history is useful for sub-question 3, because it dates an attack on the speaker's street to the days before the award was published" is a judgment about this investigation. Here is how that can look in a bullet-point interrogation.
Source 3: oral history recorded in 2007 with a man who was 14 when his family fled Lahore in 1947.
- Origin and purpose: recorded 60 years later for a project collecting survivors' memories. His aim is to bear witness, not to argue about blame.
- Explicit meaning: his street was attacked "before anyone knew where the line would be". Implicit meaning: families in his neighbourhood expected violence and had already begun preparing to leave.
- Usefulness: directly relevant to sub-question 3, because it places organised violence in Lahore before the award was published, which challenges the idea that withholding the award alone caused it.
- Reliability: sixty years of memory can blur dates, but the sequence he gives matches Source 1, a police report from the same city in early August 1947. His account of who started the attack reflects his own community's perspective, so I use it for timing, not for blame.
Why this scores: both judgments are tied to a sub-question, both are reasoned from features of the source, and the reliability judgment says which part of the evidence can be trusted and which cannot. The sources and their details are invented for illustration.
The critical summary is where Synthesising is marked
Synthesising at 5 asks for a "sophisticated historical argument that skilfully combines evidence from historical sources". The middle band is a "basic historical argument that combines evidence from historical sources". QCAA's report sets out what the critical summary is for:
Two rules follow. The argument has to answer the key inquiry question, not summarise the sources one at a time. And it has to be built from the same sources you interrogated: the 2026 endorsement report praised task sheets that direct students to base the argument on "the evidence from the same historical sources that were used in the interrogation of evidence section". A new source introduced in the last paragraph cannot carry the argument.
Recaps the sources
"Source 1 shows violence in Lahore in early August. Source 2 shows the award was published after independence. Source 3 remembers attacks before the announcement. Overall, the delay was one cause of the violence."
Combines them into an argument
"Withholding the award did not start the violence in Punjab, but it shaped how far the violence spread. Sources 1 and 3 independently place organised attacks in Lahore in the days before the award was published, so the conflict was already under way. Source 2 shows that the award was published two days after independence, which left millions in Punjab not knowing which country they would be living in as the violence spread. Read together, the evidence makes the delay a cause of the scale of the violence, not of its outbreak."
The second version makes a claim no single source states. It uses agreement between two independent sources to settle one point, and a third source to explain the next. That is what combining evidence means.
Communicating: referencing and the word count
The top band (4–5) asks that "all features of an independent source investigation are consistently applied". For IA2, those features include a recognised referencing system and a reference list. QCAA's report sets a strict standard: "all the ideas included in the response that originate from others, whether in the form of direct quotes or paraphrasing, must be referenced." A paraphrased historian without a citation costs you here, whatever the argument is worth.
On length, direct quotes count towards the 2000 words unless they are cited for authentication. QCAA's example is a quote presented alongside your interrogation of that source. Your task sheet will say how your school applies this. The referencing guide covers citation formats, and the QCAA word count rules cover what else counts.
IA3: the historical essay based on research
IA3 is a research essay on an area of the Unit 4 topic and aspect you studied in class, but not the one examined in the external exam. In 2026 and 2027, the external exam topic is either mass migrations since 1848, with the aspect of migration from Asia to Australia from the 1960s to the 1990s, or the Cold War and its aftermath, with the aspect of reasons for the end of the Soviet Union. So IA3 comes from your other Unit 4 topic, Topic 1. The essay is individual, is designed to take about 15 hours of class time plus your own time, and is up to 2000 words long, counting the key inquiry question and direct quotes.
- Synthesising5 marks
- Devising and Conducting4 marks
- Comprehending4 marks
- Analysing4 marks
- Evaluating4 marks
- Communicating4 marks
Unlike IA2, there is no fixed number of sources and no separate interrogation section. The evaluation and analysis happen inside the paragraphs of the essay.
The question at the top, the hypothesis in the introduction
The syllabus sets these features for a historical essay based on research:
- a key inquiry question, included at the beginning of the response
- an introduction that sets the context and includes the hypothesis and an outline of the argument
- body paragraphs with topic sentences
- a conclusion that draws together the main ideas and the argument
- ethical scholarship: a recognised referencing system and a reference list.
Sub-questions are not one of them. QCAA's 2026 endorsement report tells schools not to list sub-questions as an IA3 task feature, so you can use them to plan, but you aren't marked on them. Devising and Conducting at 3–4 asks for the "development and application of a nuanced key inquiry question", a "discerning selection of relevant evidence from primary and secondary historical sources" and "acknowledgment of different perspectives in the evidence from historical sources". Here is an invented example on the search for collective peace and security since 1815, one of the Unit 4 Topic 1 options:
The question names a body, a crisis, a time frame and a competing explanation. The hypothesis takes a side that the evidence could prove wrong. Both are easy for a marker to find, which is part of what Communicating rewards.
Synthesising, 5 marks: decisions that justify the argument
Synthesising is the only 5-mark criterion in IA3. The top band asks for a "sophisticated historical argument that skilfully combines evidence from historical sources to justify decisions". The middle band asks for a "basic historical argument that combines evidence from historical sources to support decisions". QCAA's report tells teachers to separate the two by asking whether the argument shows intellectual complexity or just covers the core points of the question.
Basic: decisions supported
Three body paragraphs: the League had no army, the United States was not a member, and Britain and France were selfish. Each is supported with evidence, and the conclusion says all three mattered.
Sophisticated: decisions justified
"The League's structure and its members' self-interest are not rival causes, because one made room for the other. The rule that most decisions needed unanimity, and the lack of a force of its own, meant nothing could happen unless the great powers chose to act. The evidence shows they chose not to. Their reluctance could therefore pass as procedure, and the structure is the reason the self-interest proved decisive."
The first version lists causes and supports each one. The second weighs them against each other and justifies why one depends on the other. Treat that summary as invented; in your essay, each step needs its own sourced evidence.
Evaluating inside an essay
Evaluating was the most-lowered criterion in IA3 in 2025, and in an essay it is easy to leave out, because there is no section labelled "evaluation". The top band (4) is the same as IA2's: "discerning and well-reasoned judgments about the usefulness and reliability of evidence from historical sources". Put the judgment in the paragraph where the source does its work, and let it change how far you rely on the source.
The Lytton Report of 1932 rejected Japan's claim that Manchukuo was the product of a genuine independence movement. It is useful for this question because it shows that the League had, by the end of 1932, the findings it needed to act, so the failure that followed cannot be blamed on missing information. Its reliability as an impartial account is strengthened by a commission drawn from five powers, including the United States and Germany, but it was also written to be accepted by the Assembly, which helps explain why it acknowledged Japanese interests in Manchuria alongside its criticism.
Why this scores: one judgment of usefulness and one of reliability, each reasoned from the source's origin and purpose, and each tied to the key inquiry question. The paragraph is an invented model, and a real essay would cite the report and the historians it draws on.
What QCAA's 2025 and 2026 reports say
QCAA's Modern History subject report: 2025 cohort, published in January 2026, reviewed the last cohort assessed under the 2019 syllabus: 5,450 students who finished Units 3 and 4. Its criterion names are the old ones. "Creating and communicating" is now Communicating, and IA2 had no Synthesising criterion. The other names carry over. When QCAA checked schools' marks through confirmation, Evaluating was the criterion lowered most often in every IA.
| IA | Schools' marks agreed | Evaluating lowered |
|---|---|---|
| IA1 source essay | 89.91% | 7.12% |
| IA2 source investigation | 84.87% | 13.35% |
| IA3 research essay | 79.53% | 16.32% |
No other criterion in any IA was lowered for more than 2.67% of schools (9 of 337). The figures are from the 2019 syllabus, and the 2025 Evaluating criterion is worded differently. But the skill is the same, so treat these figures as a warning about where marks are hardest to hold. The report's advice, and the June 2026 endorsement report for the current syllabus, point to the same mistakes.
- One judgment where the band needs several. Mid and upper bands need judgments, plural, and in IA2 and IA3 the top two bands need usefulness and reliability.
- Analysis not tied to your questions. QCAA says features of evidence are discerning "when they are clearly linked with one or more of the historical questions included in the response".
- A critical summary that recaps. It must build an argument from the same 4–6 sources you interrogated.
- Perspectives left out. The 2025 Devising and Conducting criterion now asks you to acknowledge different perspectives in your evidence.
- Uncited paraphrase. Every idea from someone else needs a reference, quoted or not.
- Terms dropped in without context. Comprehending looks for terms placed in historical context, linked to a specific time or place.
- A key inquiry question missing from the top of IA3. It is a feature marked in Communicating, and it counts towards your words.
- Old exemplars. A word count on IA1 or a rationale in IA2 comes from the 2019 syllabus, and sub-questions listed as an IA3 requirement go beyond the current one.
QCAA's first report on the 2025 syllabus, for the 2026 cohort, should follow the same January pattern. Read it in Term 1. Our guide to QCAA subject reports shows where to find it and how to use it.
How the IAs prepare you for the external exam
The external exam is short responses on your Unit 4 Topic 2. QCAA provides evidence from up to 12 historical sources, each with its own context statement, and you answer in paragraphs, with 15 minutes of planning and 120 minutes of working time. It assesses syllabus objectives 2 to 6: comprehending, analysing, evaluating, synthesising and communicating. Objective 1, devising questions and conducting research, is not assessed, since QCAA sets the questions. QCAA's 2026 exam put both topics in one question and stimulus book, one in each half; 2027 uses the same two topics, so expect the same layout, and check you are in the half for your topic.
IA1 is the closest rehearsal. It uses the same planning time and the same context statements, and it asks you to judge sources you have just met. The 2025 exam, the last on the 2019 syllabus, asked students to evaluate the usefulness of three sources for a stated question. It also asked them to synthesise four sources into an argument, with a judgment about how far two or more of them corroborated it. QCAA's 2025 report, discussing an alternative-sequence sample, praised answers that drew on everything a source offers, "such as the title, reference details, context statement and/or footnotes".
The habits that hold Evaluating in your IAs are the ones the exam pays for. Judge usefulness and reliability separately, tie each judgment to the question, and reason from origin, purpose and perspective. When the exam is closer, our guide to preparing for QCAA external exams covers the final weeks.
Check your Modern History draft with ISMGenius
Your teacher can give feedback on one draft of each investigation, so the most useful time to test it is before that draft goes in. If you are not sure how the draft rules work, start with why drafts matter before submission.
If the descriptor words themselves are the problem, reading your ISMG for the marks you are leaving behind and what QCAA's cognitive verbs ask for are the fastest fixes. To see what a mark out of 25 means for your result, read what your ISMG mark means. Feedback stays within the academic integrity rules.
Sources
Assessment conditions, task features, mark allocations and ISMG wording are from QCAA's Modern History 2025 v1.4 General senior syllabus (March 2026). Confirmation figures and quoted advice are from the Modern History subject report: 2025 cohort (January 2026) and the Subject report: Endorsement, Modern History 2026 cohort (June 2026). The external exam format is from QCAA's key senior subject changes for external assessment in 2026. Sample-task details are from QCAA's IA1 to IA3 sample assessment instruments on the Modern History subject page. The 2027 dates are from QCAA's Senior Education Profile calendar; memo 027/26 explains how opt-in confirmation worked in 2026. The syllabus, reports and memo are © State of Queensland (QCAA) 2026, and the sample instruments © State of Queensland (QCAA) 2025, all licensed under CC BY 4.0; see the QCAA copyright notice. The example questions, sources, judgments and arguments in this guide are original illustrations, not QCAA material.
Recommended
- the humanities investigation in History, Legal Studies and Study of Religion
- the Ancient History IAs, where sources are ancient and modern
- the three Legal Studies IAs under the 2025 syllabus
- referencing and using sources in QCAA assessment
- what counts towards a QCAA word limit
- which QCAA syllabus applies and how to use it
- how to move a draft up one mark band
- test yourself on the cognitive verbs in your task sheet
- work out your subject result from your IA marks



