QCAA Legal Studies IA1, IA2 and IA3 Explained (2025 Syllabus)

IA1 is an exam on governance, IA2 an inquiry report on law reform and IA3 an analytical essay on human rights. What each ISMG rewards, and the alternatives QCAA says cannot reach the top band.

Jackson Wright22 min read
Three paper cards, an exam sheet with a clock, a report with coral section tabs and an essay page, beside a coral line that leads to a level balance scale.
On this page

Two recommendations from the same Legal Studies inquiry report. First: "The government should run an awareness campaign so residents understand how their doorbell cameras affect the neighbours." Second: "Parliament should amend section 14 of the Neighbourhood Surveillance Act 2021 (Qld) to require a visible notice and a 30-day deletion period for footage of public footpaths." Both propose a change, but only the second is a legal alternative. QCAA's 2025 Legal Studies subject report is blunt about the first kind: alternatives that are "educational, social or administrative cannot be matched to higher performance levels". The Act is invented, like every case and statute in this guide's examples. The rule is real.

This guide is for students starting Year 12 Legal Studies in 2027, and it covers all three internal assessments (IAs) under the current syllabus, Legal Studies 2025 v1.3. For each one it sets out the conditions, the marks and what the top band asks for. It also lists the mistakes QCAA's 2025 subject report named. Your IA1 exam is likely to be the first one you sit, in Unit 3.

Units 3 and 4 are studied as a pair in Year 12, and each of the four summative assessments is worth 25% of your subject result. Your school writes the three internal instruments, has them endorsed by QCAA and marks them against the instrument-specific marking guides (ISMGs) printed in the syllabus. QCAA sets and marks the external exam.

AssessmentTask and conditions
IA1
Examination — combination response
Short responses on Unit 3 Topic 1, Governance in Australia, then one extended response to unseen stimulus. Supervised: 15 minutes planning, 120 minutes working, no word length
IA2
Investigation — inquiry report
Research a current legal issue where Australian or Queensland law needs reform (Unit 3 Topic 2). Up to 2000 words, about 15 hours of class time plus your own time
IA3
Investigation — analytical essay
Research a contemporary international human rights issue and Australia's legal response to it (Unit 4 Topics 1 and 2). Up to 2000 words, about 15 hours of class time plus your own time
EA
Examination — combination response
Short responses and an extended response to unseen stimulus on Unit 4 Topics 1 and 3. Set and marked by QCAA: 15 minutes planning, 120 minutes working
75of your 100 marks come from the three IAs
15of IA1's 25 marks sit on one extended response
12of 25 marks in IA2 and IA3 are Analysing and Evaluating

Legal Studies is one of several humanities subjects that call an assignment an "investigation", and their marking guides are not interchangeable. The humanities investigation guide sets Legal Studies beside Modern History, Ancient History and Study of Religion. This article stays inside Legal Studies.

Five terms the Legal Studies ISMGs assume you know

Every Analysing and Evaluating descriptor in Legal Studies uses a handful of terms with fixed meanings. The syllabus defines them on page 7, and QCAA's 2025 subject report keeps returning to them. These are QCAA's definitions, quoted.

Nature and scope of a legal issue

"the characteristics or elements of the legal issue, e.g. its origins and development, how it affects those involved and/or society as a whole, what law relates to the issue and the extent of the issue and its impact, including who is affected by it"

What the marker wants: the law that applies, named by section or case, and who it affects and how widely. Background history alone is not nature and scope.

Viewpoints and their consequences

A viewpoint is "attitudes, opinions or perspectives about a legal issue". A consequence is the "impact/s of the viewpoint examined".

What the marker wants: two viewpoints, each tied to legal information and each followed by what happens to a group of people if that view is right.

"legal options that are presented to address or respond to the viewpoints and associated consequences examined in the analysis of the legal issue". The syllabus gives examples: new legislation, amending existing legislation, changing a legal process such as court or police procedure, and establishing a new regulatory authority.

What the marker wants: two options that change the law, each answering something your analysis found.

"the reasoning used to justify the recommendation made in response to a legal issue", chosen from three: "just and/or equitable outcomes", "relevant elements of the rule of law", and "balancing the protection of individual rights with the protection of society".

What the marker wants: a named criterion, applied to your specific recommendation with a reason, more than once.

Implications

"effects or consequences that may result from the recommendation. These do not need to be legal."

What the marker wants: what happens after your recommendation is adopted, including costs and side effects, discussed rather than listed.

The same page defines legal principles as "guiding intentions that underlie the legal system", with the rule of law, equity and fairness, the presumption of innocence and the right to a fair trial as examples. The Comprehending criterion in each IA asks you to explain concepts, principles and processes, so name the principle you are relying on rather than leaving the marker to infer it.

IA1: the combination response exam

IA1 is a supervised exam on Unit 3 Topic 1, Governance in Australia. It has two parts. Six to eight short response questions are worth 10 marks, and in these you explain, describe, or create, label and annotate diagrams or graphs. One extended response to unseen stimulus is worth 15 marks, and it ends with a recommendation. The stimulus fits on one A3 page, holds at least four different items, such as political cartoons, law journal excerpts, newspaper reports and legislation, and no single item runs past 250 words.

  • Comprehending10 marks
  • Analysing8 marks
  • Evaluating7 marks

The short responses earn Comprehending marks only. QCAA told schools that analysing and evaluating "are not assessed in short response items", and markers judge your short answers together rather than one at a time. The Comprehending descriptors are written about "Australian and Queensland governance", so an answer that covers both levels gives the marker more to match. Setting the bicameral federal parliament against Queensland's unicameral one is a good example. The top band also asks for "precise use of legal terminology".

The extended response carries the Analysing and Evaluating marks. The top Analysing band wants "discerning use of evidence from the stimulus to support the analysis", so quote or cite the stimulus items by number as you go. The top Evaluating band reads, in full:

Use the 15 minutes of planning time to build the evaluation before you write. In 2025 it was the IA1 criterion QCAA most often marked down.

  1. Name the issue the question gives you

    QCAA tells schools to identify the legal issue in the question, because "Students are assessed on their ability to analyse and evaluate, not their ability to determine a legal issue from the stimulus." Underline it and do not drift to a neighbouring issue.

  2. Sort the stimulus into two viewpoints

    Write two viewpoints at the top of your planning page. Under each, list the stimulus items that support it and one consequence for a group of people.

  3. Find two legal alternatives

    QCAA asks schools to design stimulus that lets you find legal alternatives in it. Check each one changes the law: new or amended legislation, a change to a legal process, a new regulatory authority or, for a governance issue, a constitutional change by referendum.

  4. Choose the recommendation and two legal criteria

    The recommendation must answer the question and line up with one or both alternatives. Pick the criteria now so you can use them throughout the justification, not only at the end.

The 2025 syllabus asks for a recommendation where the 2019 syllabus asked for a decision, so old past papers that say "make a decision" are practising a slightly different task. Our guide to QCAA subject reports and past papers explains how to use old papers anyway.

IA2: the inquiry report on law reform

IA2 is the first research task of Year 12. The syllabus asks you to "select an area of law that requires reform, change, or a new legislative instrument" in the Australian or Queensland jurisdiction. You analyse it "referring to legislation and/or case law", draw on current primary and secondary sources, and make "a relevant recommendation that focuses on depth rather than breadth". It is an individual task of up to 2000 words, with about 15 hours of class time.

  • Analysing6 marks
  • Evaluating6 marks
  • Comprehending5 marks
  • Selecting4 marks
  • Creating a response4 marks

Choose an issue that still needs reform

Topic choice is where an inquiry report is won or lost before you write a word. QCAA's 2026 endorsement report warns schools off "legal issues and topics that have already been reformed", naming youth crime and coercive control as areas that "have been reformed recently and may not currently meet the task specifications". If your school lets you choose, check the Queensland and federal legislation registers for an amending Act passed in the last two years before you commit. Then look for a current law reform commission or parliamentary inquiry on the issue, because one gives you viewpoints and alternatives to work from.

Examine viewpoints, not stakeholders

The 2025 subject report asks markers to keep the "emphasis" on "examining different viewpoints about the legal issue rather than describing stakeholder perspectives", with viewpoints "analysed through the interpretation of legal information". Here is the difference, using the invented Act from the opening.

Describes stakeholders

Privacy groups are unhappy with the Neighbourhood Surveillance Act. Residents like their cameras because they feel safer, and police also use the footage in investigations.

Examines a viewpoint

Privacy advocates argue that section 14, which permits recording "any area visible from the resident's property", allows the continuous capture of people who never consented. In Marsh v Delaney, an invented District Court decision, a neighbour recorded daily for two years had no remedy because the recording was lawful under section 14. The consequence is that a passer-by's privacy depends on where a neighbour points a lens, not on any legal standard.

The second version names the provision, uses a decision as evidence, and ends on a consequence for an identifiable group. That is what one dot point of the 5–6 mark Analysing descriptor asks for: "interpretation of legal information to perceptively examine different relevant viewpoints and their consequences". Write the opposing viewpoint the same way. Here that is residents and police relying on footage as evidence, and the consequence if recording were restricted.

Tie each alternative to a statute

For IA2, QCAA says legal alternatives must be "connected to a specific legislative instrument (e.g. an Act, Bill, or statutory provision) requiring reform". An option that keeps the law as it is "would match the lower performance level descriptor in the 1–2 mark range". In the example, two legal alternatives would be amending section 14 to require notice and a deletion period, or amending the Act to give the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) power to order a resident to reposition a camera or delete footage. A council awareness campaign, or more funding for police to review footage, would not count, however sensible it sounds.

Creating a response is the one criterion about the report form itself. Its top band asks that "features of a report genre are consistently demonstrated". Your task sheet sets those features, so build your headings from it before you draft.

IA3: the analytical essay on human rights

IA3 moves from domestic law reform to "a relevant contemporary international human rights issue and Australia's response to it". The syllabus gives two kinds of response as examples: "filing a declaration of intervention in the International Court of Justice", and "creating/amending legislation regarding sanctions, travel bans, trade restrictions". The conditions match IA2: up to 2000 words, about 15 hours of class time, individual. The criteria and the 5, 4, 6, 6, 4 mark split are identical, so most IA2 feedback carries into IA3. The exception is Creating a response, which switches from report features to analytical essay features.

The change from argumentative to analytical shows most in the thesis. QCAA's 2026 endorsement report praised IA3 tasks that avoided "argumentative wording such as 'to what extent'" and "predetermined positions". Your thesis still makes a claim, but it is a claim about how Australia's legal response works, which the essay then examines and proves. It is not a side picked at the start. In the invented example below, Vellmar is a fictional country and the Supply Chain Transparency Act 2023 (Cth) a fictional statute.

Argumentative (old genre)

Australia's response to forced labour in Vellmar is completely inadequate, and this essay will argue that Australia must ban every Vellmarese import immediately.

Analytical

Australia's legal response to forced labour in Vellmar's cotton industry rests on company reporting under the Supply Chain Transparency Act 2023 (Cth), which makes disclosure, rather than enforcement, the main legal lever. This essay examines that response from the viewpoints of workers' rights advocates and Australian importers, and recommends attaching penalties to false or missing reports.

Two IA3 rules catch people out. First, alternatives must be within Australia's power to enact. The 2025 subject report says an alternative "that proposes introducing or changing a piece of international law is not a relevant legal alternative as it is not within Australia's jurisdiction". Amending an Australian Act is in scope. Calling for a treaty to be rewritten is not. Second, the focus is Australia's legal response, so the report says tasks "should no longer focus on Australians in international law scenarios or in foreign countries".

What the top Evaluating band asks for

Evaluating is worth 6 marks in both investigations, and the IA2 and IA3 descriptors differ by a single plural. This is the full IA2 ladder from the syllabus.

  1. 5–6

    perceptive · informed · discerning

    "perceptive legal alternatives presented from the analysis leading to an informed recommendation" · "synthesis of information to justify the recommendation through the discerning use of legal criteria" · "discussion of considered implications of the recommendation"

  2. 3–4

    effective · relevant

    "effective legal alternatives presented from the analysis leading to an effective recommendation" · "synthesis of information to justify the recommendation through the effective use of legal criteria" · "discussion of relevant implication/s of the recommendation"

  3. 1–2

    some · identification

    "alternative/s presented and/or recommendation made" · "some justification of the recommendation" · "identification of implication/s of the alternative/s or recommendation"

The difference between the 1–2 band and the 3–4 band is not cleverness. It is whether the alternatives come "from the analysis" and whether the justification uses legal criteria at all. Above that, QCAA's report spells out what "discerning" means in practice. For IA2, legal criteria "must be applied more than once across the response". For IA3, discerning use "requires more than a mention in the conclusion. It must be used throughout the justification." Implications should be "discussed fluently (more than a brief sentence or list)".

Amending section 14 is recommended because it balances the protection of individual rights with the protection of society: residents keep the footage that helps police investigate offences, while a 30-day deletion period limits how long a passer-by's movements are held. It also better reflects the rule of law, because a notice requirement is clear to every resident in advance and enforceable through an existing offence provision, whereas QCAT orders would bind only the residents a neighbour complains about, and only after the footage has been taken. One implication is a compliance cost for residents with existing systems, which a 12-month transition period would reduce.

Why this scores: two named legal criteria, each with a reason specific to this alternative, and the rule of law argument also says why the recommendation beats the second alternative. The implication is discussed with a response to it, not listed. Compare QCAA's warning that "simply stating that the recommendation will lead to fairness or equity will only align with the lower performance levels."

Where QCAA lowered schools' marks in 2025

After schools mark an IA, QCAA's confirmation process checks a sample of each school's responses against the ISMG and adjusts marks it disagrees with. The 2025 subject report shows, criterion by criterion, the percentage of schools whose confirmed marks came out lower than their provisional marks. The figures below are percentages of schools, not of individual responses, rounded to one decimal place: IA1 Evaluating's 13.9 is 45 of the 323 schools confirmed for IA1. Those students were the last on the 2019 syllabus, but the ISMG criteria are the same five.

Criterion (% of schools marked down)IA1IA2IA3
Comprehending3.71.60.3
Selecting—0.91.6
Analysing5.97.83.1
Evaluating13.97.15.9
Creating a response—0.30.9

In every IA, Analysing and Evaluating were the two criteria most often marked down. In IA1, Evaluating was lowered at more than twice as many schools as either of the other two criteria. IA1 Selecting and Creating a response show a dash because the exam does not assess them. This is about schools' marking rather than students' writing, but it tells you where a mark you are given is least secure: the evaluation, where the rules about legal alternatives and criteria are strictest.

The mistakes QCAA's 2025 subject report names

The 2025 Legal Studies subject report lists what to strengthen under the 2025 syllabus. These are the points that apply to your own writing, in its words where it is specific.

  • Alternatives that are not legal. For IA1, "education programs, awareness campaigns, social media initiatives and increased funding are not legal in nature". For IA2, alternatives that are "educational, social or administrative cannot be matched to higher performance levels".
  • Alternatives that change nothing. An IA2 option that keeps things the same drops the Evaluating criterion to the 1–2 mark range.
  • Criteria named once. Legal criteria used only in the conclusion, or only once, will not reach the top band. Saying the recommendation is "fair" or "equitable" without a reason stays in the lower levels.
  • Implications as a list. QCAA wants implications "discussed fluently (more than a brief sentence or list)". Naming effects is the 1–2 band's "identification".
  • Stakeholders instead of viewpoints. Describing who cares about an issue is not examining a viewpoint through legal information.
  • Out-of-jurisdiction fixes. In IA3, proposing a change to international law is not something Australia can enact, so it is not a relevant legal alternative.
  • One kind of source. In IA3 Selecting, upper-band marks went to responses that did not lean on one type of source, such as news articles. They drew on "a range of reliable and relevant sources (e.g. law journals, judges' comments, case decisions)".
  • A decision instead of a recommendation. In IA1 the top band needs an "informed" recommendation that answers the question and aligns with "one or both legal alternatives presented".

When a draft comes back, check this list before anything else. Most of these are fixable in an afternoon, and our guide to moving a draft up one mark band shows how to work from the descriptor rather than the comment.

Selecting is worth 4 marks in each investigation, and its top band includes "consistent and accurate documentation of legal information in the form of a reference list and citations". The syllabus asks for "a recognised system of referencing". Your school chooses which system, and our referencing and sources guide covers in-text citations and reference lists in detail. In-text citations and the reference list do not count towards your 2000 words, as the QCAA word count rules explain.

QCAA holds schools to this standard in their own exam questions. Its report tells them to write "Mabo v Queensland (No. 2) (1992) 175 CLR 1; [1992] HCA 23 rather than 'the Mabo case'". Use the same form in your response. Read that citation left to right.

  • Mabo v Queensland (No. 2) is the case name, in italics.
  • (1992) 175 CLR 1 is the year, then volume 175 of the Commonwealth Law Reports, starting at page 1.
  • [1992] HCA 23 is the medium neutral citation: the 23rd High Court of Australia judgment of 1992.

Legislation follows the pattern the syllabus uses throughout: short title, year, then jurisdiction, as in Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) or Youth Justice Act 1992 (Qld). Cite the section you rely on, not just the Act. Your primary sources for both are free online: Queensland Acts on the Queensland legislation site, Commonwealth Acts on the Federal Register of Legislation, and judgments on AustLII.

The qualifiers that separate the bands

Within a criterion, the cognitive verb rarely changes between bands. The adjective does. In Legal Studies, Analysing climbs from "superficial" to "effective" to "perceptive", Selecting from "narrow" to "satisfactory" to "discerning", and implications from "identification" to "relevant" to "considered". IA1's Evaluating descriptor says "insightful" where the investigations say "perceptive". To know what each qualifier asks for, read what QCAA's cognitive verbs actually ask for alongside the full list of QCAA cognitive verbs. Then test yourself with the cognitive verbs quiz before your first task sheet arrives.

Your school sets the dates, so put them in your calendar the day you get them. The instruments follow the unit order, so the sequence is predictable.

  1. Before Term 1

    Read pages 7 and 8 of the syllabus: the key terminology and the definition of the analytical essay. Learn the three legal criteria by heart. Start a list of law reform issues you see in the news.

  2. Unit 3 Topic 1

    IA1. Practise extended responses to stimulus under the 15 plus 120 minute conditions, and plan two viewpoints, two legal alternatives and two criteria every time.

  3. Unit 3 Topic 2

    IA2. Check your issue has not just been reformed, find the provision you would amend, and get your draft in by the checkpoint date. Your teacher can give feedback on one draft, so make it a complete one.

  4. Unit 4

    IA3. Pick an issue different from your IA2 topic, confirm Australia has a legal response you can examine, and write an analytical thesis, not an argumentative one.

  5. Term 4

    The external exam on Unit 4 Topics 1 and 3. QCAA's Senior Education Profile calendar has the 2027 block running from Monday 25 October to Tuesday 16 November.

Sources

Assessment specifications, ISMG descriptors and terminology are quoted from QCAA's Legal Studies 2025 v1.3 General senior syllabus (January 2026). Report findings and confirmation figures come from the Legal Studies subject report: 2025 cohort (January 2026). Endorsement advice comes from Subject report: Endorsement, Legal Studies — 2026 cohort (June 2026). All are © State of Queensland (QCAA) 2026, licensed under CC BY 4.0; see the QCAA copyright notice. The syllabus and reports are on QCAA's Legal Studies syllabus page. The Neighbourhood Surveillance Act 2021 (Qld), Marsh v Delaney, Vellmar and the Supply Chain Transparency Act 2023 (Cth) are invented for illustration. Your task sheet and teacher are the final word on your own assessment.

Questions about this topic? Ask students taking the same subject in the QCE study group.

Frequently asked questions

What are the three internal assessments in QCAA Legal Studies?

Under the Legal Studies 2025 syllabus, IA1 is an Examination — combination response on Unit 3 Topic 1, Governance in Australia. IA2 is an Investigation — inquiry report on a legal issue that needs reform, and IA3 is an Investigation — analytical essay on an international human rights issue and Australia's legal response to it. Each is worth 25%, and the external exam is the other 25%.

How many words is the Legal Studies inquiry report?

The IA2 inquiry report and the IA3 analytical essay are both written responses of up to 2000 words, developed over about 15 hours of class time plus your own time. In-text citations and the reference list do not count towards the limit. The IA1 exam has no word length; QCAA sets it by time instead, with 15 minutes of planning and 120 minutes of working time.

Is Legal Studies IA3 an argumentative essay?

Not any more. IA3 was an argumentative essay under the 2019 syllabus, and QCAA's 2025 subject report confirms the genre changed to an analytical essay in the 2025 syllabus. The essay examines and proves a thesis about Australia's legal response to an international human rights issue, and ends in a justified recommendation. QCAA's 2026 endorsement advice steers schools away from argumentative wording such as 'to what extent'.

What counts as a legal alternative in Legal Studies?

A legal alternative is a legal option that responds to the viewpoints and consequences in your analysis, such as new or amended legislation, a change to a legal process, or a new regulatory authority. QCAA says education programs, awareness campaigns, social media initiatives and increased funding are not legal in nature. In IA2, keeping the law the same scores in the 1–2 mark range, and in IA3 the alternative must be within Australia's jurisdiction.

What are the legal criteria in Legal Studies?

The 2025 syllabus lists three legal criteria for justifying a recommendation: just and/or equitable outcomes, relevant elements of the rule of law, and balancing the protection of individual rights with the protection of society. QCAA's 2025 subject report says they must be applied more than once and throughout the justification, not mentioned only in the conclusion.

Can I use the same topic for Legal Studies IA2 and IA3?

No. The syllabus requires teachers to ensure individual students do not choose the same topical issue for IA2 in Unit 3 and IA3 in Unit 4. The two tasks also have different focuses: IA2 is a law reform issue in Australian or Queensland law, and IA3 is a contemporary international human rights issue and Australia's legal response to it.

Back to all articles

Read next

Three paper pages on a desk beside a pen and a calculator: a supply and demand diagram with demand lines shifted right in coral, a line graph that dips then turns up in coral, and an essay page, joined by a thin coral line

QCAA Economics IAs Explained: IA1, IA2 and IA3 (2025 Syllabus)

The trade exam, the 2000-word research report and the analytical essay exam are 75 of your 100 marks, and Analysing and Evaluating are 15 of every 25. What the top band asks for, worked through with invented figures that add up.

Jackson Wright6 November 2026
Three paper pages side by side: a line chart rising across three points to a coral dot, nested rings with one coral ring, and a bell curve of small circles whose first three are coral, joined by a thin coral line

QCAA Health IAs Explained: IA1, IA2 and IA3 (2025 Syllabus)

The action research report, the extended response exam and the investigation are 75 of your 100 marks, on the same four criteria. What the top band asks for, worked through with invented towns, programs and data.

Jackson Wright6 November 2026
A flat lay of three business report pages: a SWOT grid with one coral square, a bar chart whose bars step down then turn up in coral, and a decision matrix with one coral tick, joined by a thin coral line

QCAA Business IAs Explained: IA1, IA2 and IA3 (2025 Syllabus)

The exam, the 2000-word business report and the 2000-word feasibility report are 75 of your 100 marks, and all three use the same five criteria. What the top band asks for, worked through with invented businesses and real numbers.

Jackson Wright6 November 2026