Lesson 6 of 10 · 18 min
Finding resistance from a V–I graph
Analyse data from the resistance practical, find resistance from the gradient of a V–I graph, and estimate its uncertainty from the steepest and shallowest lines.
What you will be able to do
- Set up a circuit to measure the potential difference across, and the current through, a resistor.
- Plot V against I and find the resistance from the gradient of the line of best fit.
- Estimate the uncertainty in the gradient from the steepest and shallowest lines through the error bars.
- Calculate percentage uncertainty and percentage error, and judge whether a result agrees with a stated value.
One pair of readings gives you one value of , carrying all the random error of that single measurement. A series of readings on a graph is better. The line of best fit averages out random errors, shows up any reading that doesn't fit, and lets you check that the resistor really is ohmic. This is the analysis behind the resistance practical, and the kind of data question that turns up in exams.
The circuit for the practical. The rheostat changes the current; the voltmeter measures the potential difference across alone.
Method
Build the circuit
Connect the resistor, ammeter, rheostat and switch in series with the supply, and the voltmeter in parallel across the resistor only.
Take the first reading
Set the rheostat for a small current, close the switch, and record V and I with their uncertainties.
Take at least five readings
Adjust the rheostat to spread the currents across the range. Open the switch between readings so the resistor stays at room temperature.
Plot the graph
Plot V on the vertical axis against I on the horizontal axis, with error bars.
Draw three lines
Draw the line of best fit, then the steepest and shallowest straight lines that still pass through every error bar.
Find R and its uncertainty
The gradient of the line of best fit is R. Half the difference between the steepest and shallowest gradients is its uncertainty.
Ohm's law in the form has the same shape as . Plot up the side and along the bottom and the gradient is . For an ohmic resistor the points lie close to a straight line through the origin.
Use two points on the line, far apart, to find the gradient, . A line that misses the origin by a lot suggests a systematic error, such as a meter that doesn't read zero when there is no current.
Five readings for a resistor labelled 47 Ω. The least-squares line has a gradient of 47.5 Ω, the best estimate of the resistance. Drag one point well away from the line and watch how much the gradient changes.
Every reading has an uncertainty. Here the voltmeter reads to ±0.1 V, so each point gets an error bar 0.1 V above and below it; the ammeter's uncertainty is small enough to ignore. Any straight line that passes through all the error bars is consistent with the data. The steepest and shallowest such lines give the largest and smallest resistances the data can support.
Worked example
Resistance and its uncertainty from a V–I graph
A student measured the potential difference across a resistor labelled 47 Ω at five currents. Each voltage reading is uncertain by ±0.1 V. The graph shows the data with error bars, the line of best fit, and the steepest and shallowest lines through the error bars. Determine the resistance with its absolute and percentage uncertainty, and decide whether the result agrees with the labelled value.
Step 1: Gradient of the line of best fit
Two points far apart on the line are and :
On a graph of V against I, the gradient is , the resistance.
Step 2: Gradient of the steepest line
It runs from to : .
Step 3: Gradient of the shallowest line
It runs from to : .
Step 4: Absolute uncertainty
Step 5: Percentage uncertainty
Step 6: Compare with the label
The labelled 47 Ω lies inside to , so the result agrees with it. The percentage error is .
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(rounded, ), a percentage uncertainty of 5.3%. The labelled 47 Ω lies within this range, so the measurement agrees with it.
Method
Gradient of the line of best fit from two far-apart points on the line.
Gradients of the steepest and shallowest lines through all the error bars.
Uncertainty is half their difference; percentage uncertainty is that over the best value.
Agreement means the accepted value lies within the uncertainty range.
Watch out for
Calculating the gradient from two data points instead of two points on the line.
Quoting the full spread, 5 Ω, as the uncertainty instead of half of it.
Key idea
Uncertainty in a gradient
Quote the result as , with the uncertainty to one or two significant figures and the value rounded to the same decimal place. The percentage uncertainty is .
The line of best fit on a graph of potential difference (vertical axis) against current (horizontal axis) passes through (0, 0) and (0.25 A, 5.5 V). What is the resistance?
For a resistor, the steepest line through the error bars has a gradient of 105 Ω and the shallowest has a gradient of 95 Ω. What is the absolute uncertainty in the resistance?
To judge accuracy, compare your result with an accepted value, such as the value printed on the resistor:
For the example above, . The labelled 47 Ω lies inside the range , so the result agrees with it within its uncertainty. Resistors have their own tolerance too: a gold band means the true value is within 5% of the label.
A student measures a resistance of 104 Ω for a resistor labelled 100 Ω. What is the percentage error?
Common mistake
Check the axes, use the line
Check the axes before you use a gradient. If current is on the vertical axis, the gradient is , so take the reciprocal. And read your two points off the line, not from two data points: the line averages all your readings; two data points don't.
Exam tip
Show the rise and run
Show the two points you used, with units: . Quote with a unit. When asked whether a result agrees with an accepted value, check whether the accepted value lies inside your uncertainty range, not just how close it is to your best value.
Uncertainty from repeated readings
When you repeat a reading several times, take the mean as your value and use the formula and data book's half-range as its uncertainty:
For currents of 0.32 A, 0.35 A, 0.33 A and 0.34 A, the mean is 0.335 A and the uncertainty is . So , a percentage uncertainty of about 4.5%.
Summary
Plot (vertical) against (horizontal): the gradient of the line of best fit is .
Calculate the gradient from two points on the line that are far apart.
The uncertainty in the gradient is half the difference between the steepest and shallowest lines that pass through all the error bars.
Percentage uncertainty ; percentage error compares your value with an accepted value.
A result agrees with an accepted value when the accepted value lies within its uncertainty range.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.