Lesson 9 of 10 · 20 min
Taxes, subsidies and price controls
Explain and calculate the effects of indirect and Pigouvian taxes, subsidies, price ceilings and price floors on price, quantity, government budgets and welfare, and their intended and unintended consequences.
What you will be able to do
- Distinguish direct and indirect taxes, and explain how a Pigouvian tax corrects a negative externality.
- Calculate the new equilibrium, tax revenue, the burden on buyers and sellers, and the welfare loss of a per-unit tax from linear curves.
- Explain how a subsidy corrects a positive externality, and calculate its cost to the government.
- Calculate the shortage from a binding price ceiling and the surplus from a binding price floor, and explain their unintended consequences.
Once you can see a market failure on a diagram, you can see what a correction has to do: move the quantity from to . Taxes, subsidies and price controls are the main tools that act through prices. Each also has costs and side effects, and the calculations here let you measure some of them.
Definition
Direct and indirect taxes
A direct tax is levied on income or wealth and paid by the person or firm that earns it: personal income tax, company tax. It raises revenue for public and merit goods and can redistribute income, improving equity.
An indirect tax is levied on spending on goods and services and collected from sellers: excise on fuel, tobacco and alcohol, and the GST. A per-unit indirect tax adds a fixed amount to the cost of each unit, so it shifts the supply curve up (left) by the tax.
Key idea
The Pigouvian tax
A Pigouvian tax (after the economist Arthur Pigou) is a per-unit tax equal to the external cost per unit at the socially optimal quantity. It makes producers (or consumers) pay the full social cost, so the private cost curve moves up onto the social one, and the market settles at . The externality is internalised.
A Pigouvian tax equal to the external cost moves the private cost curve onto MSC. The market now produces the socially optimal quantity.
Worked example
The Pigouvian tax when the external cost grows with output
A factory's output harms a river. Demand is , the private cost is , and the external cost per unit rises with output: it is dollars per unit.
(a) Find the market and socially optimal quantities. (b) Find the per-unit Pigouvian tax and show that it brings the market to the optimum. (c) A minister proposes a tax equal to the external cost at the current output instead. What would happen?
Step 1: Market quantity
.
Step 2: Social optimum
. .
Step 3: The Pigouvian tax
External cost at : per unit. With the tax, , and .
The tax must equal the external cost of the last unit at the optimum, not at the market quantity.
Step 4: The wrong tax
External cost at : . Then , below : the tax over-corrects and creates a new welfare loss.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) , . (b) $22.50 per unit, which gives . (c) A $30 tax cuts output to 80, below the optimum.
Method
MSC = MPC + external cost; solve MSB = MSC for .
Tax = external cost per unit at .
Check: MPC + tax = MPB gives .
Watch out for
Setting the tax at the external cost at the market quantity, which over-corrects when the external cost rises with output.
A tax in numbers. Take a market with demand and supply (price in dollars, quantity in units a week). Setting gives and . Now a tax of $3 a unit is put on sellers.
Worked example
A $3 tax on a market with linear curves
Demand is and supply is , with in dollars and in units a week. A tax of $3 per unit is imposed on sellers.
(a) Find the equilibrium before the tax. (b) Find the price buyers pay, the price sellers keep and the quantity after the tax. (c) Calculate the tax revenue and the share of the tax paid by buyers. (d) Calculate the welfare loss.
Step 1: Before the tax
, .
Step 2: Write supply in terms of the buyers' price
Sellers keep of each unit, so .
The tax drives a wedge between what buyers pay and what sellers keep; supply responds to what sellers keep.
Step 3: After the tax
. Sellers keep . Quantity: units.
Step 4: Revenue and incidence
Revenue a week. Buyers pay of the $3: .
Step 5: Welfare loss
a week.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) $10, 100 units. (b) Buyers $11.75, sellers $8.75, 82.5 units. (c) $247.50 a week; buyers pay about 58%. (d) $26.25 a week.
Method
Replace with in the supply equation and solve again.
Revenue .
Buyers' share .
Welfare loss .
Watch out for
Computing revenue on the old quantity: overstates it.
Adding the tax to demand instead of supply, or subtracting it from the wrong price.
The example's market with a $3 tax. Change the tax and watch revenue, quantity and the welfare loss. Notice who pays more of it.
Who bears the tax? In the example buyers pay $1.75 more and sellers keep $1.25 less: buyers bear of the tax. The side whose behaviour responds less to price (the less elastic side) bears more. Demand for cigarettes and petrol is price inelastic, which is why excise on them raises a lot of revenue but cuts consumption by less.
Note
Australian indirect taxes, dated
- Tobacco excise rose by an extra 5% a year, on top of indexation, on 1 September 2023, 2024 and 2025 (2023–24 Budget), to discourage smoking.
- Fuel excise was halved from 44.2 to 22.1 cents a litre from 30 March to 28 September 2022 to ease the cost of living, then returned to the full, indexed rate.
- The carbon pricing mechanism charged large emitters a fixed $23 a tonne of carbon dioxide-equivalent from 1 July 2012; it was repealed from 1 July 2014.
After a $0.50 per litre tax, 40 million litres of a fuel are sold a week (before the tax it was 42 million). Calculate the weekly tax revenue, in millions of dollars.
Key idea
Subsidies
A subsidy is a payment from the government per unit produced or consumed. A per-unit subsidy to producers shifts supply down (right): buyers pay less, sellers receive more, and quantity rises. Sized to equal the external benefit at , it corrects a positive externality, moving the market from up to . Its cost to the government is the subsidy per unit times the new quantity: . In a market without an externality, a subsidy pushes output beyond the efficient level and creates a welfare loss of its own.
Definition
Price ceilings and price floors
A price ceiling is a legal maximum price. It only binds when set below equilibrium; then quantity demanded exceeds quantity supplied, a shortage: . Examples: rent control, caps on some energy prices.
A price floor is a legal minimum price. It only binds when set above equilibrium; then quantity supplied exceeds quantity demanded, a surplus: . Examples: a minimum wage (the surplus of labour is unemployment), agricultural price support.
A binding price ceiling causes a shortage. Only the smaller quantity, what sellers supply, is traded, so there is a welfare loss.
In the market , (equilibrium $10, 100 units), the government sets a price ceiling of $8. Calculate the shortage.
Worked example
A price floor with the government buying the surplus
In an illustrative grain market, demand is and supply , with in dollars per tonne and in thousand tonnes. To support farm incomes, the government sets a price floor of $250 per tonne and buys any grain that does not sell.
(a) Find the equilibrium. (b) Calculate the surplus at the floor. (c) Calculate the cost to the government of buying it. (d) Give two unintended consequences.
Step 1: Equilibrium
, thousand tonnes.
Step 2: Is the floor binding?
$250 is above $200, so yes.
Step 3: Quantities at the floor
; . Surplus thousand tonnes.
Step 4: Cost to the government
.
Step 5: Unintended consequences
A growing stockpile that must be stored and later sold below cost (as with Australia's wool stockpile after 1991); farmers keep producing more than buyers want, so land and labour stay in grain when they are more valued elsewhere; consumers pay $250 instead of $200.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) $200 per tonne, 500 thousand tonnes. (b) 300 thousand tonnes. (c) $75 million. (d) For example a costly stockpile, and resources kept in an over-supplied industry.
Method
Check the floor is above .
Surplus at the floor.
Cost floor price surplus.
Watch out for
Using the change in quantity supplied (200) as the surplus: the surplus is at the floor.
Lower the ceiling: the shortage grows and fewer dwellings are let. Who gains and who loses?
| Measure | Intended | Possible unintended consequences |
|---|---|---|
| Pigouvian or excise tax | Less of a harmful activity; revenue for public spending | Illicit trade and tax evasion when the tax is high; a heavier burden on low-income households (indirect taxes are regressive); little change in use when demand is very inelastic |
| Subsidy | More of a beneficial activity; lower prices for consumers | Cost to taxpayers; firms may capture part of it as higher prices; hard to remove once people depend on it |
| Price ceiling (rent control) | Affordable prices for buyers or tenants | Shortages, queues and waiting lists; black markets; landlords spend less on maintenance or leave the market; fewer new dwellings built |
| Price floor (minimum wage, price support) | Higher incomes for workers or farmers | Unemployment or unsold surpluses; a costly stockpile if the government buys the surplus; resources kept in an industry that would otherwise shrink |
History
The wool stockpile
From 1974 Australia's wool reserve price scheme set a floor price for wool and bought wool that did not sell above it. When the floor was raised in the late 1980s and demand fell, the stockpile grew so large that the scheme was abandoned in February 1991, and the stockpile took around a decade to sell. A price floor kept resources in wool growing long after the market signalled they were wanted elsewhere.
Common mistake
Binding or not?
Check the side of equilibrium first. A ceiling above equilibrium, or a floor below it, changes nothing: the market clears at as before, and the shortage or surplus is zero.
Summary
A per-unit tax shifts supply up by the tax: buyers pay more, sellers keep less, quantity falls. Revenue ; welfare loss in a market without externalities.
A Pigouvian tax equal to the external cost at internalises a negative externality; a subsidy equal to the external benefit corrects a positive one.
The less elastic side of the market bears more of a tax.
A binding ceiling (below ) causes a shortage ; a binding floor (above ) a surplus .
Every measure has unintended consequences: black markets, regressive burdens, budget costs, stockpiles, unemployment.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.