Lesson 6 of 10 · 14 min

Boom and bust, and resources that cannot move

Explain how the excesses of booms and busts lead to suboptimal and socially undesirable outcomes, and how geographical and occupational immobility of factors of production misallocates resources.

What you will be able to do

  • Explain how a boom can over-allocate resources to booming industries, inflate asset prices and create shortages.
  • Explain how a bust leaves resources idle, so the economy produces inside its PPC.
  • Distinguish geographical and occupational immobility of factors of production, and explain how each misallocates resources.

So far market failure has been about single markets. But the whole economy can also allocate resources badly, over and over, as it swings from boom to bust. And within the economy, the price mechanism assumes resources can move to where they are wanted. Workers, machines and land often cannot.

The economic cycle. Growth swings above and below its long-run trend.

The excesses of a boom. When spending grows faster than the economy's capacity, price signals become distorted. Optimism and easy credit draw too many resources into whatever is booming: houses in a property boom, mines and mining towns in a resources boom, shares in a speculative bubble. Asset prices rise faster than the incomes or earnings that justify them. Firms that cannot find workers bid wages up, and other industries are starved of labour and capital. Inflation rises, eating into the real incomes of people on fixed incomes.

The excesses of a bust. When the boom turns, the over-investment is exposed. Building stops, half-finished projects are abandoned, firms close and workers lose their jobs. Labour and capital sit idle: the economy produces inside its production possibility curve, and the output lost is gone for good. Unemployment falls hardest on the young, the less skilled and particular regions, and long spells out of work erode skills, so some of the damage outlasts the downturn.

In a bust, resources are unemployed: the economy produces at a point such as A, inside its PPC. This is productive inefficiency on the scale of the whole economy.

Note

Australian booms and busts

  • The early 1990s recession. A late-1980s boom in commercial property and lending, fed by easy credit after financial deregulation, was followed by recession. Real GDP fell 0.4% in 1990–91 and grew only 0.4% in 1991–92, and unemployment stayed high for years afterwards.
  • The resources boom of the 2000s and early 2010s. High iron ore and coal prices pulled workers, capital and housing investment into mining regions of Western Australia and Queensland. When prices and investment fell after 2012, some mining towns were left with empty houses whose prices and rents had collapsed.
  • 2020. COVID-19 restrictions cut real GDP by 6.8% in the June quarter 2020, and the unemployment rate rose from 5.1% in February 2020 to 7.4% in June 2020. This bust came from a shock rather than from a boom's excesses.

(GDP: ABS, Australian System of National Accounts and National Accounts; unemployment: ABS Labour Force, seasonally adjusted, via RBA table H5.)

Sort each outcome: is it an excess typical of a boom or of a bust?

Key idea

Why boom and bust is a market failure

Prices guide resources well when they reflect real, lasting scarcity. In a boom they reflect over-optimism and cheap credit, so resources go to uses that later turn out to be worth much less (allocative inefficiency). In a bust, willing workers and working machines are not used at all (productive inefficiency). The swings also fall unevenly on people and regions, which is why the outcome is judged socially undesirable as well as suboptimal.

Immobility of factors of production. The price mechanism works by moving resources: when demand for one good falls and another rises, workers, capital and land are meant to move from the first to the second. When they cannot, resources stay stuck in low-value uses, or idle, while other industries go short.

Geographical immobility

Resources cannot easily move place. A worker in a town whose main employer has closed may not be able to move to a city with jobs because of the cost of housing there, a partner's job, children's schooling, family ties or not knowing about the jobs. Capital such as a factory or a mine is fixed in place.

Occupational immobility

Resources cannot easily change use. A car assembly worker cannot become a nurse or software developer without years of retraining. Specialised machinery cannot be turned to another product. Licensing and qualifications (needed to be an electrician or a teacher) slow the move further.

An Australian case. Toyota stopped building cars at Altona, Victoria, on 3 October 2017, and Holden's Elizabeth plant in Adelaide built its last car on 20 October 2017, ending mass car manufacturing in Australia (Ford had stopped in October 2016). Thousands of workers in the plants and their suppliers had skills specific to car making, often in suburbs where few similar jobs existed. Some found work quickly; others faced long spells of unemployment or took lower-paid work while employers elsewhere reported shortages of skilled tradespeople. Both kinds of immobility were at work, and governments funded retraining and job-search programs to help.

Worked example

How immobile labour misallocates resources

  • Complex familiar

Explain how the closure of the car assembly plants at Altona (Toyota, 3 October 2017) and Elizabeth (Holden, 20 October 2017) could have led to a misallocation of resources, referring to two types of immobility. Suggest one measure that would reduce the misallocation. (5 marks)

5 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Say what the price signal was telling resources to do.

  2. Name each type of immobility and the barrier in this case.

  3. Say what happened to the resources: idle, under-used, shortages elsewhere.

  4. Match a measure to the barrier.

Watch out for

  • Describing the closure without saying why resources could not move.

Classify each barrier as geographical or occupational immobility.

Exam tip

Link the cause to the misallocation

Name the type of immobility, describe the barrier in the case, and then say what happens to resources: "Because the retrenched workers could not easily retrain, labour stayed unemployed in Elizabeth while manufacturing firms elsewhere could not fill vacancies, so resources were not allocated to their most valued uses."

Summary

  • Booms over-allocate resources to booming sectors, inflate asset prices and cause shortages and inflation; busts leave labour and capital idle, inside the PPC.

  • Both are suboptimal (inefficient) and socially undesirable (their costs fall unevenly).

  • Geographical immobility: resources cannot move place. Occupational immobility: they cannot change use.

  • Immobile factors stay in low-value uses or idle while other industries go short: a misallocation of resources.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 6 of 100% read

Save your progress with a free account