Lesson 5 of 10 · 15 min
Public goods, free riders and missing markets
Classify goods by rivalry and excludability, explain why markets fail to provide public goods and how the free rider problem arises, and tell complete from partial market failure.
What you will be able to do
- Classify public, private, merit and demerit goods, and common resources, by rivalry and excludability.
- Explain the free rider problem and why it stops private firms supplying public goods.
- Distinguish complete market failure (a missing market) from partial market failure, with examples.
No business sells street lighting to the people who walk under it. It isn't that nobody values it: almost everyone does. The trouble is that once a street light is on, the business cannot stop anyone using it, and my using it doesn't leave less light for you. So nobody needs to pay, and a business that cannot get paid will not supply it.
Definition
Rivalry and excludability
A good is rival when one person's use leaves less for others (a sandwich, a seat on a flight). It is non-rival when one more user costs nothing and takes nothing from others (a radio broadcast, national defence).
A good is excludable when people who do not pay can be stopped from using it (a cinema ticket). It is non-excludable when they cannot, or only at great cost (fresh air, a fireworks display over the river).
| Rivalry | Excludable | Non-excludable |
|---|---|---|
| Rival | Private goods: a sandwich, a phone, a haircut | Common resources: fish in the open ocean, groundwater, a crowded public beach in peak season |
| Non-rival | Club goods: a streaming subscription, a toll road when it is not congested | Public goods: national defence, street lighting, fresh air, lighthouses |
Definition
Public and private goods
A public good is non-rival and non-excludable: national security, street lighting, fresh air, flood levees, public health information. A private good is rival and excludable: whoever buys it uses it, and others cannot. The market supplies private goods well; it does not supply public goods.
The free rider problem. Because a public good is non-excludable, each person can enjoy it whether or not they pay. If it were funded by voluntary contributions, each person has an incentive to contribute little or nothing and let others pay: to free ride. People also have no reason to reveal how much they really value it. So the revenue a private firm could collect falls far short of the good's value to society, and too little is provided, or none at all.
Worked example
Why nobody sells street lighting
A street of 60 households has no lighting. A light would cost $1800 a year to install and run. Each household values it at $40 a year.
(a) Is providing the light allocatively efficient? (b) Explain why no single household pays for it. (c) The residents try voluntary contributions; half of them contribute $40 each and the rest free ride. Is the light provided? (d) Explain how the council solves the problem.
Step 1: Compare total benefit with cost
Total value a year, more than the $1800 cost. Providing it adds $600 a year of net benefit: it is efficient.
Step 2: One household's view
A household that paid $1800 alone would get only $40 of benefit. Nobody pays, so the market supplies nothing.
Step 3: Voluntary contributions
, short of $1800. The light is not provided. Each free rider expected to enjoy the light without paying, because it is non-excludable.
Step 4: The council's solution
The council provides the light and funds it from compulsory rates: $30 per household covers the $1800, and each household gains $40 − $30 = $10 a year.
Compulsory payment removes the option to free ride.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Yes: benefit $2400 > cost $1800. (b) Each household's own benefit ($40) is far below the cost. (c) No: $1200 < $1800. (d) Provide it from rates of $30 per household.
Method
Efficient if total benefit to everyone exceeds cost.
Non-excludable: each person's incentive is to free ride.
Tax-funded provision makes everyone pay their share.
Watch out for
Concluding that because no-one buys the light, nobody wants it. The free rider problem hides the true demand.
Sort each good by rivalry and excludability. Then try funding a street light by voluntary contributions and see what free riding does.
Governments solve the free rider problem by providing public goods themselves and paying for them with taxation, which everyone must pay. In Australia the Commonwealth funds national defence and border protection, state and local governments fund street lighting, flood mitigation and public health campaigns, and taxpayers fund national broadcasters such as the ABC.
Common mistake
Provided by government is not the same as public good
Public hospitals and public schools are funded by government, but they are rival (a hospital bed used by one patient cannot be used by another) and excludable (entry can be controlled). They are merit goods, provided because society judges people would under-consume them, not public goods.
Definition
Merit and demerit goods
Merit goods are goods society judges people under-consume when left to the market, often because of positive externalities or because people underestimate their benefits: education, vaccination, national parks, school dental care. Demerit goods are over-consumed, often because of negative externalities or because people underestimate the harm: tobacco, alcohol, gambling, illicit drugs. Calling a good merit or demerit involves a value judgement.
Classify each good.
Key idea
Complete and partial market failure
Complete market failure is a missing market: there is demand for the good, but the market supplies none of it at all. Pure public goods are the classic case: no private firm sells national defence or clean air.
Partial market failure is a market that exists and works, but produces the wrong quantity or charges the wrong price: too much electricity from polluting sources, too few vaccinations, too high a price from a firm with market power.
Complete (missing market)
- No market forms; output is zero without intervention.
- Causes: non-excludability and the free rider problem; some environmental goods with no owner.
- Examples: national defence, street lighting, clean air, a city's flood levee.
- Usual remedy: direct provision funded by taxes.
Partial
- A market forms, but , or the price is wrong.
- Causes: externalities, market power, asymmetric information, immobile resources, merit and demerit goods.
- Examples: coal-fired electricity, education, supermarkets, used cars.
- Usual remedies: taxes, subsidies, regulation, permits, information.
Which is an example of complete market failure?
Summary
Rival and excludable goods are private; non-rival and non-excludable goods are public; rival but non-excludable goods are common resources.
The free rider problem: people can use a public good without paying, so voluntary payment falls short and firms will not supply it.
Governments provide public goods and fund them with taxes; they provide or subsidise merit goods, and tax or restrict demerit goods.
Complete market failure is a missing market (public goods). Partial market failure is the wrong quantity or price (externalities, market power, information problems).
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.