Lesson 1 of 10 · 14 min
Efficiency, market signals and good outcomes
Describe allocative, productive and dynamic efficiency, explain how prices act as market signals and incentives, and compare an optimal outcome with a socially desirable one.
What you will be able to do
- Explain how prices act as market signals and create incentives.
- Describe allocative, productive and dynamic efficiency, and give an example of each.
- Compare an optimal (efficient) outcome with a socially desirable one, and say why they can differ.
- Define market failure.
In a drought, the price of hay in south-east Queensland climbs. Nobody orders anyone to do anything, yet within weeks hay is trucked in from Victoria and South Australia, graziers sell stock they cannot feed, and some farmers plant fodder crops where they would have grown wheat. The higher price did the work.
This topic is about when that system works well, and when it does not. First you need a precise idea of what "working well" means.
Definition
Market signals and incentives
Market signals are changes in prices and profits that tell buyers and sellers where resources are scarce or plentiful. A rising price signals scarcity; a falling price signals a glut.
Incentives are the rewards and penalties that change behaviour. A higher price is an incentive for sellers to supply more and for buyers to use less; a tax or a fine is an incentive to do less of something.
Signals and incentives are how the price mechanism answers the three economic questions from Unit 1: what and how much to produce, how to produce it, and for whom. When they work, they steer resources to where they are most valued. Economists judge how well with three kinds of efficiency.
| Kind | The question it answers | What it looks like | Australian example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Allocative efficiency | Are we producing the right goods in the right amounts? | Resources go to the uses society values most: output where marginal social benefit equals marginal social cost | When the price of lithium rose, Western Australian miners opened new mines: resources moved to what buyers valued more |
| Productive efficiency | Are we producing at the lowest cost? | Each good is made at the lowest cost per unit the technology allows, with nothing wasted; a point on the PPC | A competitive grain farmer who uses the cheapest mix of land, machinery and labour to grow a tonne of wheat |
| Dynamic efficiency | Are we improving over time? | Firms innovate, invest and adopt better technology, so costs fall and products improve | Online banking and tap-and-pay cut the cost of a transaction and changed what banks offer |
At the competitive equilibrium, when demand and supply reflect every benefit and cost, the total gain from trade (consumer plus producer surplus) is as large as it can be. That is allocative efficiency.
Why is the equilibrium allocatively efficient? Each point on the demand curve shows what one more unit is worth to a buyer; each point on the supply curve shows what it costs to make. To the left of , a unit is worth more than it costs, so producing it adds to society's welfare. To the right, it costs more than it is worth. Producing exactly gets every unit worth making and none that isn't.
That reasoning has a condition hidden in it: the demand and supply curves must include every benefit and cost. When they leave some out, the market quantity is wrong. That is where this topic is heading.
A supermarket chain installs self-service checkouts and automated warehouses, so it handles the same sales with fewer staff hours per item. Which kind of efficiency has improved most directly?
Worked example
Which kind of efficiency?
For each change, identify the kind of efficiency that improves most directly, and justify your answer.
- A Queensland cattle station uses GPS-tracked water points, so it raises the same herd with fewer staff and less fuel.
- After the price of avocados rises and the price of sugar falls, some North Queensland growers replace cane with avocado orchards.
- A bank spends several years developing an app that lets customers approve a home loan in a day instead of weeks.
Step 1: Recall what each kind measures
Allocative: producing the goods society values most. Productive: producing at the lowest cost per unit. Dynamic: improving products and methods over time.
Step 2: Change 1
The same output (the herd) with fewer resources (staff, fuel) is a lower cost per unit: productive efficiency.
Step 3: Change 2
Resources (land, labour) move from a good whose price has fallen to one whose price has risen, following the price signal to a more valued use: allocative efficiency.
The price rise is a market signal that buyers now value avocados more relative to sugar; resources moving in response raise the value of what is produced.
Step 4: Change 3
Investment in a new product and process that pays off over time is dynamic efficiency. (Once it works, it also lowers the cost of each loan, a gain in productive efficiency.)
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
1 productive efficiency, 2 allocative efficiency, 3 dynamic efficiency.
Method
Same output, fewer resources: productive.
Resources moving to goods buyers value more: allocative.
Innovation and investment over time: dynamic.
Watch out for
Calling any improvement "productive". Ask what changed: the cost, the mix of goods, or the methods over time.
Common mistake
Efficiency is not the same as fairness
An efficient market can still leave some people without things they need. Efficiency asks whether resources are used well given who has the income to spend; it says nothing about whether that distribution of income is fair. That is the difference between an optimal and a socially desirable outcome.
Optimal outcome
The efficient outcome: resources are allocated so that total welfare (the sum of benefits less costs to everyone) is as large as possible. It is allocatively and productively efficient. Economists can measure how close a market comes to it, so it is a positive idea: about what is.
Socially desirable outcome
The outcome society judges best, weighing efficiency against equity (fairness), security, the environment and other values. Different people judge differently, so it is a normative idea: about what ought to be. It may accept some loss of efficiency to make outcomes fairer.
An example. A free market in rental housing may let dwellings to whoever will pay most, which can be efficient. But if rents rise so far that low-income workers cannot live near their jobs, many Australians would judge the outcome undesirable and support rent assistance or social housing, even at some cost in efficiency. Whether to do so is a value judgement; how much efficiency it costs is economics.
Sort each statement: is it about an optimal outcome or a socially desirable one?
Key idea
Market failure
Market failure happens when the price mechanism, left to itself, allocates resources inefficiently: it produces too much of a good, too little, or none at all. Because the outcome is not allocatively efficient, society could be made better off by changing it. The rest of this topic is about its causes and the ways governments modify markets to correct it.
Exam tip
Define, then apply
When a question uses an efficiency term, define it in one sentence and then apply it to the case: "Productive efficiency means producing at the lowest cost per unit. By automating its warehouses, the chain…" A definition with no application earns little; an application with no definition can miss the comprehending mark.
Summary
Prices are market signals of scarcity, and they create incentives that move resources.
Allocative efficiency: the right goods in the right amounts (MSB = MSC). Productive efficiency: lowest cost per unit. Dynamic efficiency: improving over time through innovation and investment.
A competitive equilibrium is allocatively efficient only when demand and supply include every benefit and cost.
An optimal outcome maximises total welfare (positive); a socially desirable one also weighs equity and other values (normative).
Market failure is an inefficient allocation by the price mechanism: too much, too little or none of a good.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.