Lesson 10 of 10 · 20 min
Suasion, permits, provision and regulation, and evaluating them
Explain suasion, tradable permits, direct state provision and regulation, compare them with taxes and subsidies, and evaluate strategies against efficiency, equity, cost, innovation and unintended consequences in an extended response.
What you will be able to do
- Explain how suasion, tradable permits, direct state provision and regulation correct market failure.
- Calculate how trading permits lowers the total cost of meeting a cap.
- Evaluate a strategy against criteria: effectiveness, efficiency, equity, cost, innovation, and intended and unintended consequences.
- Plan an extended response to unseen stimulus that analyses a market failure and evaluates a correction.
Taxes, subsidies and price controls work through prices. Governments have other tools: they can persuade, set a limit and let firms trade it, supply the good themselves, or make rules. Choosing among them is where economics meets judgement, and it is what extended responses ask you to do.
| Method | How it works | Market failure it suits | Australian example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Suasion | Persuading people or firms to change behaviour through information, advertising and appeals, without compulsion | Demerit and merit goods, information failures | Quit smoking campaigns; the SunSmart "Slip! Slop! Slap!" campaign from 1981; health warnings on alcohol |
| Tradable permits | A cap on total emissions (or catch) shared out as permits that firms can buy and sell | Negative production externalities; the commons | The Safeguard Mechanism: since 1 July 2023, large emitters' baselines fall 4.9% a year to 2029–30, and facilities below their baseline earn tradable Safeguard Mechanism Credits |
| Direct state provision | Government produces or funds the good itself and pays with taxes | Public goods (missing markets); merit goods | National defence; the ABC; public schools and hospitals; National Immunisation Program vaccines; national parks |
| Regulation | Laws that require, limit or ban: standards, quotas, licences, bans | Externalities, demerit goods, information failures, market power | Tobacco plain packaging from 1 December 2012; vehicle emission standards; dealer warranties on used cars; catch limits in fisheries |
Why tradable permits? A regulation that tells every firm to cut emissions by the same amount ignores the fact that some firms can cut cheaply and others only at great cost. With tradable permits the government sets the total (the cap), and the market decides who cuts. Firms that can cut cheaply cut more and sell their spare permits; firms for which cutting is expensive buy permits instead. The cap is met at the lowest total cost, and the permit price gives every firm a lasting incentive to find cheaper ways to cut: an opportunity for innovation (dynamic efficiency).
Worked example
How trading permits cuts the cost of a cap
Two illustrative firms each emit 50 tonnes of a pollutant a year. Firm A can cut emissions at $20 a tonne; firm B at $50 a tonne (each cost is the same for every tonne, up to 50 tonnes). The government caps total emissions at 60 tonnes and gives each firm 30 permits (one permit allows one tonne).
(a) Calculate the total cost of meeting the cap if permits cannot be traded. (b) Permits can be traded at $35 each. Explain what the firms do and calculate the total cost of abatement. (c) Show that both firms are better off.
Step 1: Without trading
Each firm must cut tonnes. A: . B: . Total $1400.
Step 2: What trading does
A can cut a tonne for $20 and sell the permit for $35, so it cuts all 40 tonnes the cap requires and sells its 20 spare permits to B. B pays $35 a permit instead of cutting at $50, so it buys 20 permits and cuts nothing. Emissions: A 10 + B 50 = 60 tonnes, still the cap.
Step 3: Total cost of abatement
Only A cuts: . Society saves .
The permit payments () are a transfer from B to A, not a cost to society.
Step 4: Each firm's position
A: $800 of abatement − $700 from selling permits = $100, down from $400. B: $700 for permits, down from $1000.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) $1400. (b) A cuts 40 tonnes and sells 20 permits to B; abatement costs $800. (c) A's net cost falls to $100 and B's to $700.
Method
Without trade, each firm cuts its own share.
With trade, the cheapest abater cuts most and sells its spare permits.
Payments for permits are transfers; only abatement is a cost to society.
Watch out for
Counting the permit payments as a cost to society.
Tighten the cap and let the firms trade. Who cuts, who buys, and what happens to the total cost of abatement?
A government wants to be certain that a region's emissions fall to a set level by 2030, but does not know how costly cuts will be for firms. Which measure best guarantees the level?
Note
A deposit-refund scheme
Queensland's Containers for Change has paid a 10-cent refund for each eligible drink container returned since 1 November 2018, funded by drink manufacturers. It acts like a tax on containers that are thrown away and a subsidy for those returned, so the litter externality is corrected through a price, and the refund gives people (and charities that collect containers) an incentive to clean up.
Key idea
Criteria for evaluating a strategy
- Effectiveness: does it move the outcome towards or the social goal? How far, how certainly, how fast?
- Efficiency: does it reach the goal at the lowest cost to society? Does it leave its own welfare loss?
- Equity: who bears the cost? Is the burden regressive (heavier on low-income households)?
- Cost to government: revenue raised (taxes, sold permits) or spent (subsidies, provision), and the cost of monitoring and enforcement.
- Innovation: does it reward finding cheaper or cleaner ways (dynamic efficiency)?
- Unintended consequences: black markets, evasion, firms relocating, shortages, dependence on subsidies.
- Short run and long run: elasticities rise over time, so effects often grow.
The tension between individual and social costs. Every correction shifts costs between people. A carbon price lowers the social cost of climate change but raises electricity prices for every household now; a tobacco excise lowers health costs for society but falls hardest on low-income smokers who do not quit; a fishing quota protects the future stock but cuts the income of fishers today. A strong evaluation names whose costs rise, whose fall, and whether the measure (or a second measure, such as a rebate to low-income households) handles that trade-off.
Price-based measures
Taxes, subsidies, tradable permits, deposit-refund schemes.
- Let each firm or household choose how to respond, so cuts happen where they are cheapest.
- Give an ongoing incentive to innovate.
- Raise revenue (taxes, auctioned permits) or cost it (subsidies).
- Hard to set at exactly the right level: the external cost must be estimated.
Command and control
Regulation, bans, standards, quotas, direct provision.
- Certain and simple to understand: the quantity or standard is fixed.
- Ignore differences in cost between firms, so the same result costs more.
- Little reward for doing better than the standard.
- Need inspection and enforcement; may be the only option when harm is severe (bans on toxic chemicals).
A large increase in the excise on cigarettes is intended to cut smoking. Which of these is an unintended consequence it could have? Select all that apply.
Planning an extended response to stimulus
Read the question's verbs and the issue
Analyse asks for causes, effects and relationships; evaluate asks for criteria and a judgement. Underline the market failure and the measures named.
Sort the sources
In planning time, note what each source shows (with its date) and whether it supports, challenges or qualifies a measure.
Explain the failure with a diagram
Name the cause, draw the right diagram (for example a negative production externality), label it fully and refer to it.
Analyse the measure
Show how it moves the market (a tax shifts MPC up; a cap fixes ), with data from the sources.
Evaluate against criteria
Effectiveness, efficiency, equity, cost, innovation, unintended consequences, short and long run, each backed by evidence.
Judge
Conclude which measure, or combination, best achieves an optimal or socially desirable outcome, and why.
Worked example
Evaluate a carbon tax against a cap-and-trade scheme
Use the sources to evaluate whether a carbon tax or a cap-and-trade scheme is the better way to correct the market failure from greenhouse gas emissions in Australian electricity generation. Include a diagram. (12 marks)
Source 1. Australia's Climate Change Act 2022 legislates a target of cutting emissions to 43% below 2005 levels by 2030, and net zero by 2050.
Source 2. Australia's carbon pricing mechanism charged large emitters a fixed price of $23 per tonne of carbon dioxide-equivalent from 1 July 2012; it was repealed with effect from 1 July 2014.
Source 3. Under the Safeguard Mechanism, reformed from 1 July 2023, each large facility has an emissions baseline that falls by 4.9% a year to 2029–30. Facilities below their baseline earn Safeguard Mechanism Credits they can sell to facilities above theirs.
Source 4 (illustrative). The cost of cutting a tonne of emissions ranges from under $20 for some generators to over $100 for others.
Step 1: Explain the market failure (comprehending)
Emissions are a negative production externality: MSC lies above MPC by the external cost of the emissions. Generators produce , where MPB = MPC, more than the optimum , and the welfare loss is the triangle between MSC and MPB from to .
Step 2: Draw and refer to the diagram
A labelled negative production externality: MPB = MSB, MPC, MSC above it, , , the welfare loss shaded. Show a tax equal to the external cost moving MPC up to MSC, and say a cap would fix at directly.
Step 3: Analyse the tax
A tax per tonne sets the price of emitting (Source 2: $23 a tonne), so generators cut where it costs less than the tax. It gives certainty of price and raises revenue that could fund rebates for low-income households. But the government cannot be sure how far emissions will fall, because it does not know abatement costs, and Source 2 shows such a tax can be politically fragile.
Step 4: Analyse cap and trade
A cap fixes the quantity, matching a legislated target (Source 1). Trading means the cheapest cuts are made first: with costs from under $20 to over $100 a tonne (Source 4), this greatly lowers the total cost. Source 3 shows Australia has used a declining-baseline version since 2023. The permit price is uncertain, which makes investment planning harder, and monitoring each facility is costly.
Step 5: Weigh against criteria
Effectiveness: the cap guarantees the target; the tax does not. Efficiency: both use prices, so both find cheap cuts; trading is essential when costs vary widely. Equity: both raise electricity prices, a regressive burden unless revenue is returned. Innovation: both reward cheaper abatement. Unintended consequences: both risk "carbon leakage" if production moves overseas.
Step 6: Judge
Because the government's goal is a fixed quantity by a fixed date (Source 1) and abatement costs differ widely (Source 4), a cap-and-trade scheme is the better choice, ideally with a price floor and ceiling to limit price swings and some revenue used to offset the burden on low-income households.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
A cap-and-trade scheme is better suited to a legislated quantity target and to wide differences in abatement cost, while a tax gives price certainty and revenue. Recommend cap-and-trade with protections for low-income households.
Method
Explain the failure with a labelled diagram.
Analyse each measure with evidence from the sources.
Weigh both against stated criteria.
Make and justify a judgement.
Watch out for
Describing both measures without comparing them or reaching a judgement.
Quoting a source without saying what it shows about the measure.
Exam tip
Earn the evaluating marks
The QCAA criteria reward a justified judgement. "Both measures have strengths and weaknesses" is not a judgement. "A cap-and-trade scheme is the better choice here, because the government's goal is a fixed emissions level by 2030 and Source 2 shows abatement costs differ widely between firms" is.
Summary
Suasion persuades; tradable permits cap the total and let trading find the cheapest cuts; direct provision supplies public and merit goods; regulation requires, limits or bans.
Price-based measures are flexible and reward innovation; command-and-control is certain but costlier for the same result.
A tax fixes the price of a harm and lets the quantity adjust; a cap fixes the quantity and lets the price adjust.
Evaluate against effectiveness, efficiency, equity, cost, innovation and unintended consequences, short and long run, and say whose costs rise and fall.
End every evaluation with a justified judgement backed by the stimulus.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.