Lesson 3 of 10 · 18 min
Negative externalities of production and consumption
Separate private from social costs, draw the negative production and negative consumption externality diagrams, and find and calculate the welfare loss from over-production.
What you will be able to do
- Define an externality and identify the third party.
- Draw a negative production externality with MPC, MSC and MPB = MSB, and mark , and the welfare loss.
- Draw a negative consumption externality with MPB, MSB and MPC = MSC, and mark the same features.
- Calculate the welfare loss triangle from the external cost and the two quantities.
A coal-fired power station pays for coal, labour, machinery and maintenance. It does not pay for the carbon dioxide and fine particles it releases, yet those emissions impose real costs on people who never bought its electricity: higher health costs downwind, and a share of the damage from a changing climate.
When a cost or benefit falls on someone outside the transaction, and nobody pays or is paid for it, it is an externality. The person affected is a third party.
Definition
Private and social costs and benefits
Marginal private cost (MPC): the cost to the producer of one more unit. It is the supply curve. Marginal private benefit (MPB): the benefit to the buyer of one more unit. It is the demand curve. Marginal social cost (MSC) and marginal social benefit (MSB): the full cost and benefit to society, including third parties.
The market only "sees" private costs and benefits, so it settles where MPB = MPC: the market quantity . Society is best off where MSB = MSC: the socially optimal quantity . An externality drives a wedge between them.
There are four cases: a cost or a benefit, arising from production or from consumption. This lesson takes the two negative ones, one at a time.
Key idea
Case 1: a negative externality of production
Producing the good imposes a cost on third parties: a factory's pollution, a mine's dust, a power station's emissions. The cost side is affected, so MSC lies above MPC by the external cost per unit. On the benefit side nothing is external, so the demand curve is MPB = MSB.
Negative production externality: the market over-produces () and charges too low a price. The shaded triangle is the welfare loss.
Reading the diagram. Producers expand output to , where the private benefit of the last unit just covers its private cost. But each unit beyond costs society more (MSC) than it is worth to buyers (MSB). Adding up that excess cost over every unit from to gives the shaded welfare loss triangle: the net value society loses through over-production. The market price is also too low, because it does not include the external cost.
Drawing a negative production externality
Axes
Price (or costs and benefits) up the side, quantity along the bottom.
Demand
A downward-sloping curve labelled MPB = MSB.
Private cost
An upward-sloping supply curve labelled MPC.
Social cost
A second curve above MPC, labelled MSC. The vertical gap is the external cost per unit.
Equilibria
Mark where MPB meets MPC, and where MSB meets MSC, with dashed lines to both axes (, ).
Welfare loss
Shade the triangle bounded by MSC, MSB and the vertical line at , pointing towards the optimum. Label it.
Start with the private market, then add the external cost. Make it bigger: what happens to the gap between and , and to the welfare loss?
A paper mill releases waste into a river, and a downstream fishing business loses income as a result. On an externality diagram for paper, which statement is correct?
Worked example
The welfare loss from a power station's emissions
In an illustrative regional electricity market, quantity is in thousand megawatt hours (MWh) a year and price in dollars per MWh. Demand is and the generators' supply is . Burning coal causes an external cost of $30 per MWh, the same at every level of output.
(a) Find the market quantity and price. (b) Find the socially optimal quantity and price. (c) Calculate the welfare loss.
Step 1: Market outcome (MPB = MPC)
. Price: .
Step 2: Social cost curve
.
Step 3: Social optimum (MSB = MSC)
There is no external benefit, so MSB = MPB. . Price: .
At the value of the last unit to buyers equals its full cost to society.
Step 4: Welfare loss triangle
Base thousand MWh; height the external cost per MWh. Area .
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) 500 thousand MWh at $70. (b) 350 thousand MWh at $85. (c) About $2.25 million a year.
Method
Market: solve MPB = MPC.
Social: MSC = MPC + external cost; solve MSB = MSC.
Welfare loss external cost when the external cost is constant.
Watch out for
Forgetting that is in thousands: the loss is $2.25 million, not $2250.
Using the price gap as the height: the height is the vertical gap between MSC and MPB at , the full $30.
Key idea
Case 2: a negative externality of consumption
Using the good imposes a cost on third parties: second-hand smoke, drink-driving accidents, traffic congestion and emissions from driving. Now the benefit side is affected: the benefit to society of one more unit is the buyer's benefit less the cost to others, so MSB lies below MPB. On the cost side nothing is external, so supply is MPC = MSC.
Negative consumption externality: consumers over-consume (). The shaded triangle is the welfare loss.
The result is the same in kind as Case 1: the market goes beyond , and every unit from to costs more to produce (MSC) than it is worth to society (MSB). Only the curve that moves is different. Goods like this, which people over-consume when left to the market, are often called demerit goods: tobacco, alcohol, gambling.
Here the social benefit curve moves, not the cost curve. Change the external cost and compare the welfare loss with the power station.
Driving into a city centre causes congestion and pollution with an external cost of $4 per trip, the same for every trip. The market has 800 trips a day; the socially optimal number is 600. Calculate the daily welfare loss.
Common mistake
Which curve moves?
Ask two questions. Where does the externality arise, in making or in using the good? That decides cost side (MSC) or benefit side (MSB). Is it a cost or a benefit to third parties? That decides above or below. Pollution from a factory: production, cost, so MSC above MPC. Second-hand smoke: consumption, cost, so MSB below MPB.
Exam tip
What the marker wants on a diagram
Every curve labelled (MPC, MSC, MPB = MSB), both quantities marked ( and ), the triangle shaded and named "welfare loss", and a sentence that refers to it: "The shaded area shows the welfare loss from over-producing units."
Summary
An externality is a cost or benefit to a third party outside the transaction. MSC = MPC + external cost; MSB = MPB + external benefit.
The market produces where MPB = MPC (); society is best off where MSB = MSC ().
Negative production externality: MSC above MPC. Negative consumption externality: MSB below MPB. Both give over-production, .
The welfare loss is the triangle between the social curves from to . With a constant external cost : .
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.