Lesson 4 of 10 · 18 min
Positive externalities, and all four diagrams compared
Draw the positive production and positive consumption externality diagrams, explain under-production and the welfare gain forgone, then compare all four externality cases side by side.
What you will be able to do
- Draw a positive production externality with MPC, MSC below it and MPB = MSB.
- Draw a positive consumption externality with MPB, MSB above it and MPC = MSC.
- Explain why the market under-produces, and mark and calculate the welfare gain forgone.
- Tell all four externality cases apart from a description, and link them to merit and demerit goods.
Externalities are not always harmful. A beekeeper keeps bees for honey, but the bees also pollinate the almond and apple orchards next door, raising the growers' crops for free. When you are vaccinated against measles, you are protected, and so is the baby too young to be vaccinated who sits near you on the bus.
In both cases a third party gains a benefit that nobody pays for. The people making the decision count only their own benefit, so they choose too little of the activity.
Key idea
Case 3: a positive externality of production
Producing the good benefits third parties: pollination from beekeeping, a firm that trains apprentices who later work for other firms, research whose ideas others can copy. The benefit to society means the social cost of producing is lower than the private cost, so MSC lies below MPC by the external benefit per unit. Demand is MPB = MSB.
Positive production externality: the market under-produces (). The shaded triangle is the potential welfare gain the market forgoes.
Reading the diagram. Each unit between and is worth more to society (MSB) than it costs society to make (MSC), but the producer, comparing only its private cost with the price, stops at . The shaded triangle is the net benefit society would gain by producing those extra units: the welfare gain forgone, which is also a welfare loss compared with the optimum. It points from towards , to the right.
Increase the external benefit. Which way does the social cost curve move, and what happens to the gap between and ?
Key idea
Case 4: a positive externality of consumption
Using the good benefits third parties: vaccination (herd immunity), education (a more productive, better-informed community that commits less crime), public transport use (less congestion for drivers). The benefit to society of one more unit is greater than the buyer's own benefit, so MSB lies above MPB. Supply is MPC = MSC.
Positive consumption externality: consumers under-consume (). The shaded triangle is the welfare gain forgone.
Goods like education and vaccination, which society judges people would under-consume if left to the market, are called merit goods. Governments provide them directly or subsidise them: Medicare-funded vaccines under the National Immunisation Program, public schools, and subsidised places in TAFE and university.
Worked example
The welfare gain forgone when too few people are vaccinated
In an illustrative city, 70 000 people a year buy a flu vaccination at the market price. Each vaccination protects other people as well, an external benefit estimated at $50 per dose at every level of vaccination. The socially optimal number is 90 000 a year.
(a) Identify the type of externality and sketch the diagram. (b) Calculate the welfare gain the market forgoes. (c) The government pays a subsidy equal to the external benefit. What is its cost if vaccinations rise to the optimum?
Step 1: Identify the externality
The benefit to others comes from consuming the vaccine: a positive consumption externality. MSB lies $50 above MPB; supply is MPC = MSC.
Step 2: Sketch
Draw MPC = MSC rising, MPB falling, and MSB parallel above MPB. Mark where MPB meets MPC and where MSB meets MSC. Shade the triangle between MSB and MPC from to .
Step 3: Welfare gain forgone
a year.
Step 4: Cost of the subsidy
The subsidy is paid on every dose at the new quantity: a year.
The subsidy cost is far larger than the welfare gain because most of it is a transfer to people who would have been vaccinated anyway, not a cost to society as a whole.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Positive consumption externality. (b) $500 000 a year. (c) $4.5 million a year.
Method
Identify where the externality arises and whether it is a cost or a benefit.
Welfare gain forgone .
Subsidy cost the quantity after the subsidy.
Watch out for
Paying the subsidy only on the 20 000 extra doses: a per-unit subsidy is paid on every dose.
Here the social benefit curve sits above demand. Compare the shaded triangle with the one for over-consumption of cigarettes.
| Case | Arises from | Third parties bear a | Curves | Market outcome | Typical correction | Example |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Negative production | Producing | Cost | MSC above MPC; MPB = MSB | Over-production, | Pigouvian tax, regulation, tradable permits | Power station emissions |
| Negative consumption | Consuming | Cost | MSB below MPB; MPC = MSC | Over-consumption, | Excise tax, regulation, suasion | Second-hand smoke |
| Positive production | Producing | Benefit | MSC below MPC; MPB = MSB | Under-production, | Subsidy to producers, direct provision | Bees pollinating orchards |
| Positive consumption | Consuming | Benefit | MSB above MPB; MPC = MSC | Under-consumption, | Subsidy, free provision, suasion | Vaccination |
Classify each situation as one of the four kinds of externality.
On a positive consumption externality diagram, where is the welfare loss triangle?
Common mistake
"Positive" does not mean "no problem"
A positive externality is still a market failure: too little is produced, and society misses out on the gain shown by the triangle. Answers that say "it is positive, so the market is fine" lose the analysis marks.
Summary
Positive production externality: MSC below MPC. Positive consumption externality: MSB above MPB. Both give under-production, .
The triangle between and is the welfare gain forgone: for a constant external benefit .
Production externalities move the cost curve; consumption externalities move the benefit curve. Costs to others make social above private cost or below private benefit.
Merit goods are under-consumed (often positive externalities); demerit goods are over-consumed (often negative externalities).
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.