Lesson 1 of 10 · 20 min

Molecular shapes from VSEPR theory

Count the bonding and lone pairs on a central atom, then use VSEPR theory to name the shape and bond angle of linear, bent, trigonal planar, tetrahedral and pyramidal molecules.

What you will be able to do

  • Explain why electron-pair regions around a central atom spread as far apart as possible.
  • Determine the shape and bond angle of a molecule from its Lewis structure: linear, bent, trigonal planar, tetrahedral or pyramidal.
  • Explain why lone pairs make bond angles smaller.
  • Represent a molecule's shape in 2D and 3D, and state limitations of VSEPR theory.

Carbon dioxide and water both have three atoms, yet a COX2\ce{CO2} molecule is a straight line and an HX2O\ce{H2O} molecule is bent. That one difference is why water is a liquid that dissolves salt and carbon dioxide is a gas that does not. To explain the properties of a molecular substance, you first need its shape.

You already know how to draw a Lewis structure, showing every valence electron as a bonding pair or a lone pair. The Lewis structure tells you what is bonded to what. Valence shell electron pair repulsion (VSEPR) theory turns it into a 3D shape.

The Lewis structure of ammonia, NHX3\ce{NH3}. Nitrogen has three bonding pairs and one lone pair: four electron-pair regions.

Key idea

VSEPR theory

The regions of electron density around a central atom all carry negative charge, so they repel each other. They arrange themselves as far apart as possible, and that arrangement fixes where the bonded atoms sit.

A region is a lone pair or a bond. A double or triple bond counts as one region, because all its electrons lie between the same two atoms.

Interactive

Build a shape

Change the bonding and lone pairs on the central atom. Turn the molecule to see it in 3D, and watch what lone pairs do to the bond angles.

Two, three or four regions have only one best arrangement each: a line (180°), a flat triangle (120°) or a tetrahedron (109.5°). That is the electron-pair arrangement.

The shape of the molecule is named from where the atoms are, not the lone pairs. Lone pairs are invisible to the name but they still take up space, so the same arrangement can give different shapes.

The five shapes in the syllabus. Count the regions on the central atom, then read across. With lone pairs, VSEPR only predicts "a little under" the ideal angle; 107° and 104.5° are the measured angles of NHX3\ce{NH3} and HX2O\ce{H2O}, and other molecules of the same shape differ by a few degrees.
Regions on central atomBonding regionsLone pairsArrangement of regionsShapeBond angleExamples
220linearlinear180°COX2\ce{CO2}, HCN\ce{HCN}, BeClX2\ce{BeCl2}
330trigonal planartrigonal planar120°BFX3\ce{BF3}, CHX2O\ce{CH2O}, SOX3\ce{SO3}
321trigonal planarbentjust under 120° (about 119° in SOX2\ce{SO2})SOX2\ce{SO2}
440tetrahedraltetrahedral109.5°CHX4\ce{CH4}, CClX4\ce{CCl4}, NHX4X+\ce{NH4+}
431tetrahedralpyramidalunder 109.5° (about 107° in NHX3\ce{NH3})NHX3\ce{NH3}, NFX3\ce{NF3}, PClX3\ce{PCl3}, HX3OX+\ce{H3O+}
422tetrahedralbentfurther under 109.5° (about 104.5° in HX2O\ce{H2O})HX2O\ce{H2O}, OFX2\ce{OF2}, HX2S\ce{H2S}

Predicting a shape

  1. Draw the Lewis structure

    Find the central atom (usually the one that forms the most bonds, never H) and place every valence electron.

  2. Count the regions on the central atom

    Count bonded atoms (each single, double or triple bond is one region) and lone pairs.

  3. Arrange the regions

    2 regions linear, 3 trigonal planar, 4 tetrahedral.

  4. Name the shape from the atoms

    Ignore the lone pairs when you name the shape, but remember they push the bonds closer together.

  5. State the bond angle

    180°, 120° or 109.5° with no lone pairs; about 107° with one lone pair on four regions; about 104.5° with two.

Worked example

Shape and bond angle of ammonia, NHX3\ce{NH3}

  • Simple familiar
  • Technology free

Use VSEPR theory to determine the shape of an ammonia molecule, NHX3\ce{NH3}, and its H–N–H bond angle.

Lewis structure of NHX3\ce{NH3}.

5 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Draw the Lewis structure and count bonding regions and lone pairs on the central atom.

  2. Arrange the regions: 2 linear, 3 trigonal planar, 4 tetrahedral.

  3. Name the shape from the atoms only.

  4. Reduce the angle for each lone pair.

Watch out for

  • Calling ammonia tetrahedral: that is the arrangement of the electron pairs, not the shape.

  • Calling it trigonal planar by forgetting the lone pair.

Sulfur is in the same group as oxygen. Hydrogen sulfide, HX2S\ce{H2S}, has two S–H bonds and two lone pairs on the sulfur atom. Name its shape.

Why are the angles in ammonia and water smaller than 109.5°? A lone pair is held by only one nucleus, so it sits closer to the central atom and spreads out more widely than a bonding pair, which is shared between two nuclei. Lone pairs therefore repel more strongly:

lone pair–lone pair>lone pair–bonding pair>bonding pair–bonding pair\text{lone pair–lone pair} > \text{lone pair–bonding pair} > \text{bonding pair–bonding pair}

Each lone pair squeezes the bonds a little closer: 109.5° in CHX4\ce{CH4}, about 107° in NHX3\ce{NH3} (one lone pair) and about 104.5° in HX2O\ce{H2O} (two).

Which list puts the H–X–H bond angles of CHX4\ce{CH4}, NHX3\ce{NH3} and HX2O\ce{H2O} in order from largest to smallest?

Choose one answer

Multiple bonds are where students most often miscount. In carbon dioxide, O=C=O\ce{O=C=O}, the carbon has two double bonds and no lone pairs. That is two regions, not four, so the molecule is linear. In methanal, CHX2O\ce{CH2O}, the carbon has two single bonds and one double bond: three regions, trigonal planar.

Worked example

Shapes of COX2\ce{CO2}, HCN\ce{HCN} and CHX2O\ce{CH2O}

  • Complex familiar
  • Technology free

Determine the shape and bond angle of each molecule.

(a) carbon dioxide, O=C=O\ce{O=C=O} (b) hydrogen cyanide, H−C≡N\ce{H-C#N} (c) methanal, CHX2O\ce{CH2O}, in which carbon is bonded to two H atoms and double bonded to O

Lewis structures. None of the carbon atoms has a lone pair.

5 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Count a double or triple bond as one region.

  2. Only lone pairs on the central atom affect the shape.

  3. Then apply the usual rules: 2 regions linear, 3 trigonal planar.

Watch out for

  • Counting each bond in a double bond separately and calling COX2\ce{CO2} tetrahedral or bent.

  • Thinking the lone pairs on the O atoms of COX2\ce{CO2} bend it. Lone pairs on outer atoms do not change the shape around the central atom.

Interactive

Check your predictions

Predict each shape and angle before you select it, then turn the molecule to check. Notice that NHX4X+\ce{NH4+} is tetrahedral and HX3OX+\ce{H3O+} is pyramidal.

Common mistake

Naming the arrangement instead of the shape

NHX3\ce{NH3} is not tetrahedral and HX2O\ce{H2O} is not tetrahedral or linear. Their four regions are arranged tetrahedrally, but the shape describes the atoms only: pyramidal and bent. Write both if it helps: "four regions, tetrahedral arrangement, so a pyramidal shape".

Quick check

2 marks

Methanol is CHX3OH\ce{CH3OH}. The carbon has four single bonds; the oxygen has two single bonds (to C and to H) and two lone pairs. What is the shape around the oxygen atom, and what is the C–O–H bond angle?

Part (a).

Shape around the oxygen atom

1 mark
Part (b).

Approximate C–O–H bond angle

1 mark
in circ

Showing shape on paper. A Lewis structure is a 2D map of electrons, not a picture of the shape: water is often drawn with its H atoms at 180° even though the molecule is bent. To show three dimensions on flat paper, chemists use wedge-and-dash drawings: a plain line is a bond in the plane of the page, a solid wedge comes towards you, and a dashed line points away.

Wedge-and-dash drawings: methane (tetrahedral, 109.5°), ammonia (pyramidal, about 107°) and water (bent, about 104.5°). Lone pairs are drawn as lobes.

History

How chemists came to draw shapes

Chemists have long needed to show molecules in three dimensions. In the 1860s August Hofmann built molecular models from coloured croquet balls, and in 1874 van 't Hoff and Le Bel proposed that carbon's four bonds point to the corners of a tetrahedron. Gilbert Lewis introduced electron dot structures in 1916. VSEPR theory itself began with Nevil Sidgwick and Herbert Powell in 1940 and was developed by Ronald Gillespie and Ronald Nyholm in 1957.

Today chemists use ball-and-stick models (bond angles easy to see), space-filling models (the real relative sizes of atoms), wedge-and-dash drawings, and computer modelling that rotates a molecule on screen. Each model shows some features and hides others, which is why chemists choose the one that suits their purpose.

Limitations of VSEPR theory

VSEPR is a simple model, and it is very good at predicting the shapes of small molecules. But:

  • It predicts angles only roughly. It says a lone pair makes angles "a little less than 109.5°", but it cannot calculate 107° for NHX3\ce{NH3} or 104.5° for HX2O\ce{H2O}; those are measured values.
  • It fails for some molecules. It gets the shapes of HX2S\ce{H2S} (bent) and PHX3\ce{PH3} (pyramidal) right, and by analogy with HX2O\ce{H2O} and NHX3\ce{NH3} you would expect angles near 104.5° and 107°. The measured angles are about 92° and 93.5°, close to 90°.
  • It describes shape, not bonding. It does not explain why bonds form, how strong they are, or where electrons in delocalised (resonance) structures really are.
  • It needs a clear central atom. For larger molecules you apply it atom by atom, and it says little about how the parts twist relative to one another.
  • It does not work for most transition metal compounds, whose d electrons do not behave as simple repelling pairs.

Exam tip

Show the reasoning chain

For "determine the shape and bond angle", markers look for: the number of bonding regions and lone pairs on the central atom, the arrangement they adopt to minimise repulsion, the shape named from the atoms, and the angle. A bare "pyramidal, 107°" may earn only part of the marks.

Summary

  • Electron-pair regions on a central atom repel and spread as far apart as possible (VSEPR). A double or triple bond counts as one region.

  • 2 regions: linear, 180°. 3 regions: trigonal planar, 120°. 4 regions: tetrahedral arrangement.

  • Name the shape from the atoms only: 4 regions with 1 lone pair is pyramidal (about 107°); with 2 lone pairs, bent (about 104.5°). 3 regions with 1 lone pair is bent (just under 120°).

  • Lone pairs repel more strongly than bonding pairs, so they close the bond angles.

  • Wedge-and-dash drawings, ball-and-stick and space-filling models each show the 3D shape in a different way.

  • VSEPR predicts shapes well for small molecules, but not exact angles, bonding or transition metal compounds.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 1 of 100% read

Save your progress with a free account