Lesson 5 of 10 · 16 min
How chromatography separates a mixture
Explain how paper and thin-layer chromatography separate a mixture by the competing attractions of the mobile and stationary phases, carry out the method well, and see how GC and HPLC extend the idea.
What you will be able to do
- Identify the stationary and mobile phases in paper chromatography, TLC, GC and HPLC.
- Explain how differences in attraction to the two phases separate the components of a mixture.
- Describe how to set up and run paper or thin-layer chromatography, with the reason for each precaution.
- Describe how gas and high-performance liquid chromatography are used to determine composition and purity.
A black felt-tip pen line on wet paper towel blooms into blue, purple and yellow. The "black" ink was a mixture all along, and water carrying it through the paper pulled its dyes apart. That is chromatography, and it is one of the most widely used tools in chemistry: forensic scientists use it to match inks and identify drugs, food chemists to check additives, and anti-doping labs to find banned substances in an athlete's urine.
Definition
Chromatography
Chromatography separates the components of a mixture using two phases: a stationary phase that stays put and a mobile phase that moves through or over it. Each component is carried along by the mobile phase but held back by the stationary phase, by different amounts, so the components travel at different speeds and separate.
| Technique | Stationary phase | Mobile phase | How components are detected |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paper chromatography | cellulose fibres of the paper (polar, with water held on them) | a liquid solvent rising by capillary action | coloured spots; or stain, UV light |
| Thin-layer chromatography (TLC) | a thin layer of silica gel or alumina (polar) on glass, plastic or aluminium | a liquid solvent rising by capillary action | coloured spots; UV light or iodine vapour for colourless ones |
| Gas chromatography (GC) | a high-boiling liquid coating the inside of a long, thin coiled column in an oven | an unreactive carrier gas such as helium or nitrogen | a detector at the end of the column records each component's retention time |
| High-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) | tiny particles packed in a steel column (often with a non-polar coating) | a liquid solvent pumped through at high pressure | a detector (often UV absorbance) records each retention time |
Why components separate. Every molecule of a component spends part of its time adsorbed onto the stationary phase and part of its time dissolved in the mobile phase, moving back and forth between them. The balance depends on intermolecular forces:
- A component attracted strongly to the stationary phase spends more time stuck and moves slowly.
- A component more soluble in the mobile phase (more strongly attracted to it) spends more time moving and travels quickly.
Paper and silica are very polar (covered in O–H groups), so polar components that can hydrogen bond to them are held back. With a non-polar solvent, the least polar components travel furthest. Change the solvent and the separation changes.
Develop the plate in hexane, then in the hexane–propanone mixture, then in propanone. Which pigment is least polar? Why does the more polar solvent carry every spot further?
A mixture of two compounds is run on a silica TLC plate with a non-polar solvent. Compound X is non-polar; compound Y has two O–H groups. Which compound travels further up the plate, and why?
Running paper or thin-layer chromatography
Draw the baseline in pencil
About 1–2 cm from the bottom. Graphite does not dissolve in the solvent, but pen ink would run and add spots of its own.
Spot the samples on the baseline
Use a capillary tube to make small, concentrated spots, letting each dry between applications. Spot the unknown and each standard side by side, well apart.
Stand it in a covered tank of solvent
The solvent level must be below the baseline, or the samples would dissolve into the solvent in the tank instead of being carried up. The lid keeps the tank saturated with solvent vapour, so the solvent does not evaporate from the paper as it rises.
Remove it before the solvent reaches the top
Mark the solvent front in pencil immediately, before the solvent evaporates and the front disappears.
Dry and reveal the spots
Coloured spots are visible; colourless ones can be shown with UV light (TLC plates often contain a fluorescent indicator), iodine vapour, or a spray such as ninhydrin for amino acids.
Switch the technique control to a pen baseline, then to a solvent level above the baseline, and see what each does to the chromatogram. Then try ethanol: why does the permanent marker move in ethanol but stay on the baseline in water?
Worked example
Explaining a paper chromatography separation
A student spots a mixture of two dyes on chromatography paper and develops it with water. Dye A forms many hydrogen bonds; dye B is much less polar but still dissolves in water. After 20 minutes, dye B has moved much further than dye A.
(a) Identify the stationary and mobile phases.
(b) Explain why the dyes separated, and why dye B moved further.
(c) Predict how the separation would change if the student used a less polar solvent such as ethanol.
Step 1: Identify the phases (a)
The stationary phase is the paper: cellulose fibres with water held on them. The mobile phase is the solvent, water, which rises up the paper by capillary action.
Step 2: Describe what each dye molecule does
Each dye molecule constantly switches between being adsorbed onto the cellulose and being dissolved in the moving solvent. It only moves up the paper while it is dissolved.
Step 3: Explain the separation (b)
Cellulose is covered in O–H groups. Dye A forms many hydrogen bonds, so it is strongly attracted to the cellulose and spends much of its time adsorbed: it moves slowly. Dye B is less polar, so it is attracted less strongly to the cellulose and spends more of its time dissolved in the mobile phase: it moves further.
The components separate because they divide their time between the two phases differently. If both dyes were attracted equally they would travel together.
Step 4: Predict the effect of ethanol (c)
A less polar solvent dissolves the less polar dye B well, but dissolves the strongly hydrogen-bonding dye A less well, so A would spend even more time on the paper. Dye A would move less (or stay near the baseline) while B still moves, so the spots would end up further apart.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Stationary: cellulose paper; mobile: water. (b) Dye A is held more strongly by hydrogen bonds to the polar cellulose, so it spends more time adsorbed and moves less; dye B is attracted less to the paper and more to the mobile phase, so it moves further. (c) In ethanol, dye A would move even less relative to dye B, so the separation would increase.
Method
Name both phases.
Compare each component's attraction to the stationary phase with its solubility in the mobile phase.
More time in the mobile phase means further travel.
Watch out for
Saying dye B moved further because its molecules are lighter. Separation depends on attractions, not mass.
Forgetting that the paper (cellulose) is the stationary phase, not the solvent.
Gas chromatography (GC). A tiny sample is injected and vaporised, and a stream of helium or nitrogen carries it through a thin coiled column, often 30 m long or more, coated on the inside with a non-volatile liquid. Components that are more volatile (lower boiling point) and less attracted to the coating come out first. The detector records a peak for each component at its retention time; the area under the peak shows how much is present. GC suits volatile substances: blood alcohol, accelerants at a fire scene, pesticide residues, and drugs, often with the column feeding into a mass spectrometer (GC–MS) to identify each peak.
High-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). A liquid mobile phase is pumped at high pressure through a column packed with tiny particles. The small particles give a huge surface area, so separation is fast and sharp. HPLC suits substances that are not volatile or that break down when heated: medicines, caffeine and preservatives in drinks, vitamins, and the steroids and stimulants sought in sports drug tests.
A gas chromatogram. Each peak is one component; its retention time identifies it (by comparison with standards run under the same conditions) and its area measures the amount.
An analyst must measure a heat-sensitive medicine that decomposes below its boiling point. Which technique is most suitable, and why?
Note
Chemistry that identifies materials
Chromatography is one of many chemical processes science relies on to find the identity, nature or source of a material. A forensic chemist can match the ink of a forged cheque to one brand of pen, link petrol residues at a fire to a can in a suspect's car, or show that a "natural" supplement contains a prescription drug. In each case the evidence is a comparison: the unknown and a known standard behave identically under the same conditions.
Common mistake
Common method errors
Drawing the baseline in pen, putting the solvent above the baseline, using large dilute spots that smear, leaving the lid off, or letting the solvent reach the top of the paper (then the front cannot be measured). Each one is a likely "evaluate the method" question.
Summary
Chromatography separates a mixture by how strongly each component is attracted to the stationary phase compared with the mobile phase.
Components held strongly by the stationary phase move slowly; components more soluble in the mobile phase move quickly.
Paper (cellulose) and TLC plates (silica, alumina) are polar stationary phases; the mobile phase is a solvent.
Pencil baseline above the solvent level, small spots, a covered tank, and the front marked at once.
GC (gas mobile phase) suits volatile substances; HPLC (liquid pumped at high pressure) suits non-volatile or heat-sensitive ones. Both identify components by retention time and measure them by peak area.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.