Lesson 2 of 10 · 15 min
Polar bonds and polar molecules
Use data-book electronegativities to find polar bonds, then use the molecule's shape and symmetry to decide whether the bond dipoles cancel or the molecule is polar.
What you will be able to do
- Use the data book's electronegativity values to decide whether a bond is polar and which end is .
- Explain why a molecule with polar bonds can be non-polar.
- Determine the polarity of a molecule from its shape, its symmetry and its bond polarities.
Hold a charged plastic ruler near a thin stream of water from a tap and the stream bends towards it. Try the same with a stream of hexane and nothing happens. Water molecules have a positive end and a negative end that the charge can pull on; hexane molecules do not. Water is polar.
Whether a molecule is polar depends on two things: the polarity of its bonds, and its shape.
Definition
Polar bond
A polar bond is a covalent bond between two atoms of different electronegativity. The more electronegative atom pulls the shared electrons closer and becomes slightly negative (); the other atom becomes slightly positive (). The bigger the electronegativity difference, the more polar the bond.
| Element | Electronegativity | Element | Electronegativity | Element | Electronegativity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| H | 2.2 | N | 3.0 | Si | 1.9 |
| B | 2.0 | O | 3.4 | S | 2.6 |
| C | 2.6 | F | 4.0 | Cl | 3.2 |
| P | 2.2 | Br | 3.0 | I | 2.7 |
For an O–H bond the difference is : strongly polar, with O as the end. For C–Cl it is , and for C–H only , with C the end. Bonds between identical atoms, such as Cl–Cl, or between atoms with the same data-book value, such as C and S (both 2.6), have a difference of zero and are non-polar.
C–H bonds are only weakly polar, and in hydrocarbons their small dipoles almost cancel, so hydrocarbons are treated as non-polar molecules. A small difference still counts when the shape cannot cancel it: S–H bonds also differ by 0.4, and bent is polar.
Using the data book's electronegativities, which bond is the most polar?
Each polar bond is a bond dipole, drawn as an arrow pointing towards the end. A molecule's overall polarity is the result of adding all its bond dipoles together, taking their directions into account, like a tug of war. If identical bond dipoles pull equally in opposite or symmetric directions, they cancel.
In the two bond dipoles are equal and opposite, so they cancel: non-polar. In bent they add to an overall dipole towards O: polar.
Key idea
Deciding whether a molecule is polar
- Are any bonds polar? If every bond is non-polar (, or , where C and S have the same electronegativity), the molecule is non-polar.
- Is the shape symmetric, with identical atoms around the centre? Linear , trigonal planar and tetrahedral molecules with identical outer atoms (, , , ) are non-polar: the bond dipoles cancel.
- Otherwise the molecule is polar. Bent and pyramidal molecules with polar bonds are always polar, because the lone pairs make the shape lopsided. So is a symmetric shape with different outer atoms, such as or .
Arrows show each bond dipole and their sum. Work through the chloromethanes: which of them are polar?
Worked example
Why is polar but is not
Both carbon dioxide and water contain polar bonds. Use electronegativity values from the data book and the shapes of the molecules to explain why water is a polar molecule but carbon dioxide is non-polar.
Step 1: Show that the bonds are polar
C=O: , with O . O–H: , with O and H . Both kinds of bond are polar.
Step 2: Determine the shape of
Carbon has two double bonds and no lone pairs, so is linear (180°).
Step 3: Decide whether the dipoles of cancel
The two C=O dipoles are equal in size and point in exactly opposite directions, so they cancel. has no overall dipole: non-polar.
Step 4: Determine the shape of
Oxygen has two bonding pairs and two lone pairs, so is bent (about 104.5°).
Step 5: Decide whether the dipoles of cancel
Both O–H dipoles point towards O, at an angle. Their sideways parts cancel, but their parts towards O add up, so there is an overall dipole with O as the end: polar.
Think of two people pulling on ropes tied to the same point at 104.5° apart. They cannot cancel each other; the knot moves between them.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Both molecules have polar bonds, but is linear and symmetric, so its two equal bond dipoles cancel and it is non-polar. is bent, so its bond dipoles do not cancel and it is polar.
Method
Show the bonds are polar with data-book electronegativities.
Determine the shape with VSEPR.
Decide whether the shape is symmetric enough for the bond dipoles to cancel.
Watch out for
Stopping at "the bonds are polar", which does not decide the polarity of the molecule.
Saying is non-polar because carbon and oxygen have similar electronegativities. They differ by 0.8.
Boron trifluoride, , is trigonal planar. Electronegativities: B 2.0, F 4.0. Is a polar or a non-polar molecule?
Symmetry breaks when you change one outer atom. Methane, , and tetrachloromethane, , are symmetric tetrahedra and non-polar. Swap one, two or three atoms and the bond dipoles no longer balance, so chloromethane, dichloromethane and trichloromethane are all polar, even though they are still roughly tetrahedral.
Worked example
Which chloromethanes are polar?
Methane, , chloromethane, , dichloromethane, , trichloromethane, , and tetrachloromethane, , are all roughly tetrahedral. Determine which of them are polar molecules, and justify your answer.
Step 1: Find the bond polarities
C–H: (weakly polar, C ). C–Cl: (polar, Cl ).
The two kinds of bond have different dipoles, so a molecule containing both cannot have all its bond dipoles equal.
Step 2: Consider and
Four identical bonds at 109.5° in a regular tetrahedron: the four equal bond dipoles cancel. Both are non-polar.
Step 3: Consider the mixed molecules
In , and the outer atoms are not all the same. The C–Cl dipoles pull electron density towards the Cl atoms, and nothing on the other side balances them, so the bond dipoles do not cancel. All three are polar.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
, and are polar; and are non-polar, because only a tetrahedron with four identical outer atoms is symmetric enough for the bond dipoles to cancel.
Method
Find each bond's polarity.
A symmetric shape cancels the dipoles only if the outer atoms are identical.
Any substitution that breaks the symmetry gives a polar molecule.
Watch out for
Calling polar because it has four polar bonds.
Calling non-polar because "the two Cl atoms balance the two H atoms". In 3D, the two Cl atoms are on the same side of the molecule.
Select all the polar molecules.
Two borderline cases: and
Nitrogen trichloride, . On the data book's scale chlorine (3.2) is slightly more electronegative than nitrogen (3.0), so each N–Cl bond is weakly polar with Cl as the end. The molecule is pyramidal, so the three bond dipoles do not cancel: is polar, though only weakly.
Phosphine, . Phosphorus and hydrogen both have electronegativity 2.2, so by the data book the P–H bonds are non-polar. The lone pair on the pyramidal molecule still gives it a small dipole (about 0.6 debye, against 1.5 for ), so phosphine is described as weakly polar, and the forces between its molecules are mainly dispersion forces. In the widget above it shows as weakly polar. In an exam, give the data-book reasoning: non-polar bonds, so at most weakly polar.
Common mistake
Polar bonds do not always make a polar molecule
" has polar C=O bonds, so it is polar" loses the mark. Always finish the argument with the shape: polar bonds and an asymmetric shape (so the dipoles do not cancel) make a polar molecule.
Exam tip
A full-mark polarity answer
Give three things: the electronegativity difference for the bond (with data-book values), the shape (and whether it is symmetric), and the conclusion about cancelling. For example: "N–H bonds are polar (). is pyramidal, so the bond dipoles do not cancel. is polar."
Summary
A bond is polar when its atoms differ in electronegativity; the more electronegative atom is . Use the data book's values.
A molecule is polar only if its bond dipoles do not cancel: you need polar bonds and an asymmetric shape.
Symmetric linear, trigonal planar and tetrahedral molecules with identical outer atoms (, , ) are non-polar.
Bent and pyramidal molecules with polar bonds (, ) are polar.
Changing an outer atom breaks the symmetry: , and are polar.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.