Lesson 6 of 11 · 19 min
Harmonics on strings, natural frequency and resonance
Find the harmonics of a stretched string with , describe the fundamental and natural frequencies, and explain resonance and why it transfers energy so efficiently.
What you will be able to do
- Explain why a string fixed at both ends can only form standing waves with .
- Describe the fundamental (first harmonic), the higher harmonics and natural frequencies.
- Solve problems about the frequency, wavelength and wave speed of harmonics on a string.
- Describe resonance in a mechanical system and explain why energy is transferred efficiently at resonance.
Pluck a guitar string and it sounds one particular note. Press it against a fret and the note rises. Why does a string choose its notes? Because a wave on the string reflects from both fixed ends, and only the standing waves that fit between the ends survive.
Both ends of the string are fixed, so both must be nodes. The simplest pattern has a node at each end and one antinode in the middle: half a wavelength fits on the string. The next has three nodes and two loops: one whole wavelength. Each loop is half a wavelength, so a string of length holds loops when
The first three harmonics of a string of length . Each loop is half a wavelength; dots mark the nodes.
The wave speed on a string depends only on the string's tension and mass per unit length, so it is the same for every harmonic. Combining with gives the frequency of the th harmonic:
Every harmonic is a whole-number multiple of the lowest frequency, .
Definition
Fundamental, harmonics and natural frequencies
- The fundamental, or first harmonic, is the lowest frequency at which the string forms a standing wave: .
- The th harmonic has frequency .
- These are the string's natural frequencies: the frequencies at which it vibrates when it is disturbed (plucked) and left to vibrate freely. A plucked string vibrates at several of them at once, which is why a guitar and a violin playing the same note sound different.
Step through the harmonics. Each new harmonic adds one loop and one node, and its frequency goes up by one more lot of .
Worked example
Harmonics on a guitar string
The A string of a guitar is long between the nut and the bridge, and its fundamental frequency is .
(a) Calculate the wavelength of the fundamental.
(b) Calculate the speed of the waves on the string.
(c) Calculate the frequency and the wavelength of the third harmonic.
Step 1: Wavelength of the fundamental
For , , so .
The fundamental is a single loop, half a wavelength, between the two fixed ends.
Step 2: Wave speed
Step 3: Frequency of the third harmonic
Step 4: Wavelength of the third harmonic
For , , so . Check: , the same speed.
The tension and the string are unchanged, so every harmonic travels at the same speed.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) (b) (c) and
Method
Use to find the wavelength of harmonic .
Use ; the speed is the same for every harmonic.
.
Watch out for
Using for the fundamental. Only half a wavelength fits.
A string long has a fundamental frequency of . What is the frequency of its third harmonic?
Tip
How a musician changes the note
explains every string instrument. Pressing a fret shortens , raising the pitch. Tightening a tuning peg increases the tension and so the wave speed , raising the pitch. The thick bass strings have more mass per metre, so is lower and so is the pitch.
Every object has natural frequencies: a swing, a wine glass, a bridge, a building, the air in a bottle. Now imagine forcing an object to vibrate by pushing it repeatedly at a driving frequency. Push at most frequencies and the object barely responds. Push at one of its natural frequencies and each push arrives at just the right moment to add more energy. The amplitude builds up and up. This is resonance.
Definition
Resonance
Resonance is the large-amplitude vibration of a system when it is driven at (or very near) one of its natural frequencies. At resonance, energy is transferred from the driver to the system most efficiently, because the driving force stays in step with the motion and does positive work on every cycle. The amplitude grows until the energy lost each cycle (to friction and air resistance) equals the energy supplied.
Slowly raise the driving frequency. Watch the amplitude: it peaks sharply when the driving frequency matches the natural frequency.
A stretched string shows resonance beautifully. Attach one end to a vibration generator and slowly raise its frequency. The string barely moves — until the frequency reaches , when a large single loop suddenly appears. Raise it further and the string goes quiet again until , then . The string resonates only at its natural frequencies: its harmonics.
A playground swing has a natural frequency of 0.5 Hz. Which way of pushing it will make it swing highest with small pushes?
Worked example
Why a crowd made a footbridge sway
A new footbridge can sway from side to side with a natural frequency of . People walk at about 2 steps per second, and with each pair of steps (left foot, then right foot) a walker pushes the bridge sideways once each way. On opening day, a large crowd made the bridge sway so much that it was closed.
(a) Explain why the bridge swayed so strongly.
(b) Engineers proposed two fixes: (i) limit the number of people allowed on the bridge, or (ii) fit dampers that absorb energy from the sideways motion. Evaluate the two fixes.
Step 1: Find the driving frequency
Each walker pushes sideways once per pair of steps: push cycle per second. The driving frequency is .
Step 2: Compare with the natural frequency
The driving frequency equals the bridge's natural frequency of sideways sway, , so the bridge resonates.
Step 3: Explain the large amplitude
At resonance, the pushes stay in step with the bridge's motion, so each push does positive work and adds energy every cycle. Energy is transferred to the bridge very efficiently, and the amplitude builds until the energy lost each cycle equals the energy supplied. Worse, people on a swaying bridge instinctively fall into step with the sway, so more of them push in phase.
Away from resonance, pushes are sometimes with the motion and sometimes against it, so the energy put in largely cancels out.
Step 4: Evaluate fix (i)
Fewer people means a smaller total driving force and less energy added per cycle, so the sway is smaller. But the driving frequency still matches the natural frequency, so the bridge still resonates, and the bridge can no longer carry the crowds it was built for. It reduces the problem without removing its cause.
Step 5: Evaluate fix (ii)
Dampers remove energy from the motion every cycle, so the amplitude stays small even when the bridge is driven at resonance, and the bridge stays fully usable. This tackles the problem directly and is the better fix. (Making the bridge stiffer to move its natural frequency well away from would also work.)
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) The walkers' sideways driving frequency, , equals the bridge's natural frequency, so the bridge resonates: energy is transferred efficiently every cycle and the amplitude builds up. (b) Limiting numbers reduces the energy input but leaves the bridge resonating and less useful; dampers remove energy each cycle so the sway stays small at full capacity, which makes them the better fix.
Method
Identify the driving frequency and the natural frequency.
If they match, explain resonance in terms of efficient energy transfer.
Judge each fix by whether it changes the frequency match or the energy balance, and at what cost.
Watch out for
Saying "resonance creates energy". The energy comes from the walkers; resonance transfers it efficiently.
Using the step frequency (2 Hz) as the driving frequency for the sideways sway.
Common mistake
Resonance does not create energy
Resonance does not make energy from nothing, and it is not "a very loud sound". It is the efficient transfer of energy from a driver into a system at its natural frequency. Name both frequencies in your answers: "the driving frequency equals the natural frequency of …".
Summary
A string fixed at both ends has nodes at both ends, so standing waves need with
The fundamental (first harmonic) is the lowest natural frequency, ; the th harmonic is . All harmonics travel at the same speed on a given string.
Natural frequencies are those at which an object vibrates freely after being disturbed.
Resonance is a large-amplitude vibration when the driving frequency equals a natural frequency, because energy is then transferred most efficiently.
Engineers must keep bridges and buildings from resonating with footsteps, wind and earthquakes, by changing their natural frequencies or adding dampers.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.