Lesson 7 of 11 · 18 min
Standing sound waves in pipes
Use for pipes open at both ends and for pipes closed at one end, and analyse resonance-tube data to find the speed of sound.
What you will be able to do
- Explain why an open end of a pipe is a displacement antinode and a closed end is a displacement node.
- Solve problems with (open at both ends) and (closed at one end).
- Explain why a pipe closed at one end produces only odd harmonics.
- Use resonance-tube measurements to find the wavelength of sound and the speed of sound in air.
Blow across the top of a bottle and it hums. Pour in some water and the note rises. A flute, a pipe organ and a didgeridoo all work the same way: sound waves reflect from the ends of a column of air, and a standing wave forms when its wavelength fits the column. The air column then resonates at its natural frequencies.
Key idea
What happens at each end
Sound in a pipe is longitudinal: the air molecules vibrate along the pipe.
- At a closed end, the air is stopped by the wall and cannot move: a displacement node.
- At an open end, the air is free to move in and out: a displacement antinode.
(The antinode actually sits slightly beyond the open end. This small "end correction" matters in experiments, and you'll see how to remove it below.)
Pipes open at both ends have an antinode at each end, so the simplest pattern is antinode–node–antinode: half a wavelength. Every whole number of half-wavelengths fits, so the rule is the same as for a string:
Pipe open at both ends. The curves show how the amplitude of the air's (longitudinal) vibration varies along the pipe. A = antinode, N = node.
A pipe open at both ends is long. Calculate its fundamental frequency in air at 25 °C.
Pipes closed at one end have a node at the closed end and an antinode at the open end. The simplest pattern, node to antinode, is only a quarter of a wavelength. The next pattern that fits adds half a wavelength: three quarters. Then five quarters, and so on — always an odd number of quarter-wavelengths:
So a closed pipe has only the odd harmonics: , , , … Its fundamental is half that of an open pipe of the same length, an octave lower.
Pipe closed at one end (right). There is always a node at the closed end and an antinode at the open end, so the harmonics go 1st, 3rd, 5th, …
Switch between open–open and open–closed. Which harmonics can the closed pipe make? Compare the fundamental frequencies of the two pipes.
Common mistake
In the closed-pipe formula, n is not the harmonic number
In , counts the resonances (first, second, third …) and is the harmonic number. The third harmonic of a closed pipe has , so and . There is no second harmonic.
Worked example
Resonant frequencies of a closed pipe
A pipe closed at one end is long. The air is at 25 °C.
(a) Calculate the fundamental frequency.
(b) Calculate the next two resonant frequencies.
(c) Explain why this pipe cannot resonate at .
Step 1: Wavelength of the fundamental
For , , so .
The fundamental runs from a node at the closed end to an antinode at the open end — a quarter of a wavelength.
Step 2: Fundamental frequency
Step 3: Next two resonances
Only odd harmonics exist, so the next two are and . (Using with and gives the same.)
Step 4: Explain the missing frequency
, the second harmonic. It would need an antinode at both ends, but a closed end must be a node, so a closed pipe cannot produce even harmonics.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) (b) and (c) is the second harmonic; a closed pipe only produces odd harmonics.
Method
Closed pipe: and .
Resonances are , , , …
Watch out for
Using , the open-pipe result, which doubles the frequency.
Listing and as the next resonances.
A pipe closed at one end is long. Calculate the frequency of its third harmonic in air at 25 °C, to three significant figures.
Measuring the speed of sound. A classic practical uses a resonance tube: a tube whose lower end is closed by water, with the water level adjustable. Hold a vibrating tuning fork of known frequency over the open top and slowly lengthen the air column. The sound suddenly gets much louder at a length — the first resonance, when — and again at .
Key idea
Why use the difference L₂ − L₁
Because the antinode sits a small distance (the end correction) above the open end, and . Subtracting cancels :
Then . Measure the air temperature too: the speed of sound rises with temperature, and is the value at 25 °C.
Worked example
Speed of sound from a resonance tube
In a resonance-tube experiment at 25 °C, a tuning fork is held over the open end of a tube closed at the bottom by water. The first resonance occurs when the air column is long, and the second when it is long. Each length is measured to .
(a) Determine the wavelength of the sound.
(b) Calculate the speed of sound, with its absolute uncertainty. Treat the fork's frequency as exact.
(c) Estimate the end correction.
(d) Compare your result with the data book value.
First resonance () and second resonance (). The curves show the amplitude of the air's vibration.
Step 1: Use the difference between resonances
Successive resonances are half a wavelength apart: . So and .
Both lengths are short of the true antinode by the same end correction, so subtracting them cancels it.
Step 2: Calculate the speed of sound
Step 3: Propagate the uncertainty
Subtracting adds absolute uncertainties: , so . Multiplying by an exact frequency keeps the percentage uncertainty: , and of is about . So .
Step 4: Estimate the end correction
The first resonance should be a quarter-wavelength: . The measured column is , so the antinode sits about above the top of the tube.
Step 5: Compare with the accepted value
The data book gives at 25 °C, well inside the range to . The percentage error is : excellent agreement.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) (b) (c) about (d) The data book value, , lies within the uncertainty: the result agrees.
Method
removes the end correction.
.
Add absolute uncertainties for a difference; percentage uncertainties for a product.
End correction .
Watch out for
Using , which includes the end-correction error and gives .
Forgetting that the uncertainty of a difference is the sum of the two uncertainties.
A pipe closed at one end has a fundamental frequency of . Which of these frequencies can it also resonate at?
Summary
A closed end is a displacement node; an open end is a displacement antinode.
Open at both ends: and — every harmonic.
Closed at one end: and — only odd harmonics, and the fundamental is half that of an open pipe of the same length.
In a resonance tube, successive resonances are half a wavelength apart: , which removes the end correction. Then .
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.