Lesson 9 of 11 · 22 min
Refraction of light and Snell’s law
Explain refraction with the wave model, use Snell’s law to find angles, speeds, wavelengths and refractive indices, explain apparent depth and total internal reflection, and find a refractive index from experimental data.
What you will be able to do
- Explain refraction of light using the wave model.
- Describe Snell’s law and use to solve problems.
- Explain why objects under water appear closer to the surface than they are.
- Calculate a critical angle and explain total internal reflection and its use in optical fibres.
- Determine a refractive index from the gradient of a graph of experimental data.
A straw in a glass of water looks broken at the surface. A swimming pool looks shallower than it is. A spear fisher has to aim below where the fish appears. All of this is refraction: light changing direction as it crosses from one transparent material into another.
The wave model explains it exactly as it explained water waves entering shallow water. Light travels more slowly in glass or water than in air. When a wavefront meets the surface at an angle, the part that enters first slows down first, while the rest is still travelling at the faster speed. The wavefront pivots, so the light changes direction — towards the normal when it slows down, away from the normal when it speeds up. The frequency does not change, so the wavelength shrinks in the slower medium.
Definition
Refractive index
The refractive index of a material compares the speed of light in a vacuum, , with its speed in the material:
A vacuum has exactly; air is very close, to three significant figures. Water is , perspex about , glass about and diamond . A higher refractive index means slower light. (This definition is not on the formula sheet, but it follows from Snell’s law with for a vacuum.)
Light entering glass slows down and bends towards the normal. Both angles are measured from the normal (dashed). Some light is also reflected.
Key idea
Snell’s law
For light crossing from medium 1 into medium 2, with angle of incidence and angle of refraction (both measured from the normal):
Everything with subscript 1 belongs to the first medium, with ; but notice the refractive indices are flipped. Cross-multiplying gives a form that is easy to remember: .
Change the angle of incidence and the two refractive indices. When does the ray bend towards the normal? What happens when is larger than and the angle is large?
Worked example
Light entering a glass block
Light of wavelength in air strikes a glass block () at to the normal. Take the refractive index of air as .
Calculate (a) the angle of refraction, (b) the speed of light in the glass and (c) the wavelength of the light in the glass.
Step 1: Set up Snell's law
Medium 1 is air (, ) and medium 2 is glass (). From :
Step 2: Calculate the angle of refraction
Reasonableness check: the light slows down entering glass, so it bends towards the normal and .
Step 3: Calculate the speed in glass
Step 4: Calculate the wavelength in glass
From :
The frequency does not change, so the wavelength shrinks in proportion to the speed.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) (b) (c)
Method
Label medium 1 (with ) and medium 2 (with ).
Use for angles.
Use and .
Watch out for
Calculator in radians: in radians gives a wrong angle.
Writing , which is greater than 1 — a sign the ratio is upside down.
A ray of light passes from air () into water () with an angle of incidence of . Calculate the angle of refraction, to three significant figures.
Common mistake
Three ways to lose Snell’s law marks
- Calculator in radian mode: in radians.
- Angles measured from the surface instead of the normal. If a question gives the angle to the surface, use minus it.
- Treating the angles, not their sines, as proportional: .
Apparent depth. Light from a fish travels up through the water and speeds up as it enters the air, bending away from the normal. Your eye and brain assume light travels in straight lines, so they trace the rays straight back — to a point above the fish. The fish, the bottom of the pool and the straw all appear closer to the surface than they really are. Looking from directly above, the depth appears to be the real depth divided by the refractive index of the water: about three quarters of the real depth.
Rays leaving the water bend away from the normal. Traced back (dashed), they appear to come from a point above the real fish.
Total internal reflection. Now send light the other way, from glass into air. It speeds up and bends away from the normal, so the angle of refraction is bigger than the angle of incidence. As you increase , the refracted ray swings closer to the surface. At the critical angle , it skims along the boundary: . For any larger angle there is no refracted ray at all, and all the light reflects back into the glass.
Light going from glass () into air. Left: , the ray refracts out (with a weak reflection). Middle: , it travels along the surface. Right: , total internal reflection.
Key idea
Critical angle
Put in (and ):
Total internal reflection needs both conditions: the light travels towards a lower refractive index (), and the angle of incidence is greater than the critical angle. For glass to air, , so .
Worked example
Total internal reflection in an optical fibre
An optical fibre has a glass core of refractive index surrounded by a cladding of refractive index .
(a) Calculate the critical angle at the boundary between the core and the cladding.
(b) A ray inside the core strikes the boundary at to the normal. Describe what happens to it.
(c) Explain why the core must have a higher refractive index than the cladding.
Step 1: Write the critical angle condition
Light travels from the core () towards the cladding (). At the critical angle, :
Step 2: Calculate the critical angle
Step 3: Compare the angle of incidence with C
, so the ray is totally internally reflected at and stays in the core.
Step 4: Explain the choice of refractive indices
Total internal reflection can only happen when light travels towards a lower refractive index (where it would speed up). If the cladding's refractive index were higher, would be greater than 1 — there would be no critical angle, and light would refract into the cladding and leak out.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) (b) It strikes the boundary at more than the critical angle, so it is totally internally reflected and stays in the core. (c) Total internal reflection only occurs going towards a lower refractive index.
Method
, with the medium the light is in.
If , total internal reflection; if , the light partly refracts out.
Watch out for
Using , which only applies when the second medium is air.
Inverting the ratio to , which is greater than 1.
Calculate the critical angle for light travelling from water () into air (), to three significant figures.
Note
Dispersion
The refractive index of glass is slightly different for each colour: about for red light and for violet in ordinary glass. Violet light slows more, so it bends more. White light entering a prism at an angle spreads into a spectrum. Raindrops do the same to sunlight, which is why a rainbow has red on the outside and violet on the inside.
Measuring a refractive index. A common practical shines a narrow ray from a ray box into the flat side of a semicircular glass or perspex block, aimed at the centre. The ray leaves through the curved side along a radius, so it only refracts once. Measure inside the block for several angles of incidence in air. Since with , a graph of against is a straight line through the origin whose gradient is the refractive index.
Worked example
Refractive index of perspex from experimental data
A student shines a narrow ray from air into the flat face of a semicircular perspex block, aimed at the centre of the flat face, and measures the angle of refraction for six angles of incidence . Each angle is measured to .
| (°) | 10 | 20 | 30 | 40 | 50 | 60 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| (°) | 7.0 | 13.5 | 19.5 | 25.5 | 31.0 | 35.5 |
| 0.174 | 0.342 | 0.500 | 0.643 | 0.766 | 0.866 | |
| 0.122 | 0.233 | 0.334 | 0.431 | 0.515 | 0.581 |
The graph shows against with a line of best fit through the origin.
(a) Determine the refractive index of the perspex from the graph.
(b) The steepest and shallowest lines consistent with the uncertainties have gradients and . State the refractive index with its absolute and percentage uncertainty.
(c) The accepted refractive index of perspex is . Evaluate the student's result and suggest one improvement to the method.
Step 1: Explain why the gradient is the refractive index
Snell's law with air as medium 1: , so . A graph of against is a straight line through the origin with gradient .
Step 2: Read two points far apart on the line
The line passes through and .
Use points on the line, not data points, and choose them far apart to reduce reading error.
Step 3: Calculate the gradient
Step 4: Find the uncertainty
Absolute uncertainty . Percentage uncertainty . So .
Step 5: Evaluate
The accepted value, , lies well within to , and the points lie close to a straight line through the origin, consistent with Snell's law. The result is accurate, with a modest random uncertainty that comes mainly from reading angles to — a large fraction of the small angles.
Step 6: Suggest an improvement
Use a narrower ray and a larger protractor (or a printed polar grid) to read angles more precisely, and repeat each measurement and average, to reduce the random error.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) (b) () (c) The accepted value lies within the uncertainty, so the result is accurate; reading the angles more precisely (narrower ray, larger protractor, repeated trials) would reduce the uncertainty.
Method
Plot (air) against (material): the gradient is .
Read the gradient from two distant points on the line of best fit.
Uncertainty .
Compare with the accepted value and name the main source of error.
Watch out for
Plotting the angles instead of their sines: against is not a straight line.
Plotting against and forgetting the gradient is then .
History
Snellius and the law of refraction
The Dutch astronomer and mathematician Willebrord Snellius (1580–1626) found the sine law of refraction in 1621, though he never published it; René Descartes published it in 1637. The Persian scholar Ibn Sahl had described an equivalent rule for lenses in 984. Snellius also pioneered triangulation for measuring distances on Earth's surface.
Summary
Light slows down in a denser optical medium; the wavefront pivots, so the ray bends towards the normal. Frequency is unchanged, so the wavelength shortens.
Refractive index . Snell’s law: , or , with angles from the normal.
Light leaving water bends away from the normal, so underwater objects appear closer to the surface than they are.
Going towards a lower refractive index, . Beyond the critical angle, all the light is reflected: total internal reflection.
The refractive index varies slightly with colour, which causes dispersion.
The gradient of (air) against (material) is the refractive index of the material.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.