Lesson 5 of 10 · 20 min
Measuring specific heat capacity
Analyse a specific heat capacity experiment, find c from the gradient of a graph, record measurements with uncertainties and evaluate the result with percentage error.
What you will be able to do
- Describe a method for measuring the specific heat capacity of a substance with an electric heater.
- Show that energy supplied and temperature change are proportional, and find from the gradient of a graph.
- Record measurements with a symbol, value, absolute and percentage uncertainty and SI unit, and combine uncertainties.
- Compare analogue and digital thermometers, and explain why heat loss makes a measured too high.
Data tables say the specific heat capacity of aluminium is about . How would you check that for yourself? You need a known mass, a known amount of energy, and a temperature change you can measure. This lesson is the practical behind , and the skills you use to analyse it.
A typical set-up. A joulemeter measures the energy supplied directly; otherwise, use .
Method
Measure the mass of the block
Use an electronic balance and record it with its uncertainty, for example .
Set up the heater and thermometer
Put the heater and thermometer in the holes in the block, with a few drops of oil in the thermometer hole for good thermal contact. Wrap the block in insulation.
Record the starting temperature
Wait until the reading is steady, then record with its uncertainty.
Heat and record
Switch on the heater and start the stopwatch. Record the temperature every 60 s, and the energy supplied from the joulemeter (or the power and the time).
Find the highest temperature
Switch off after about 10 minutes but keep reading. The temperature keeps rising briefly while energy spreads from the heater through the block; use the highest reading as .
Repeat
Let the block cool and repeat at least twice more, then average your results.
For a fixed mass of one substance, says that : the temperature rise is directly proportional to the energy supplied. A graph of (dependent variable, -axis) against (independent variable, -axis) should be a straight line through the origin with gradient .
If the heater supplies a constant power , then , and a graph of temperature against time is a straight line with gradient . Either way, the gradient gives you .
Results for 0.200 kg of water heated in an insulated cup. Is the relationship proportional? Drag a point to see how one bad reading changes the gradient.
For the 0.200 kg of water in the graph above, the line of best fit has a gradient of . Determine the specific heat capacity of water from these results, to three significant figures.
Worked example
Finding specific heat capacity from a temperature–time graph
A student heats an insulated 1.00 kg aluminium block with a 50.0 W heater and records its temperature every 60 s. The graph shows the data and the line of best fit, which passes through (0 s, 21.0 °C) and (600 s, 52.2 °C).
(a) Determine the gradient of the line of best fit.
(b) Determine the specific heat capacity of aluminium from the experiment.
(c) The accepted value is . Calculate the percentage error and explain the direction of the error.
Temperature of the aluminium block while the 50.0 W heater is on.
Step 1: Calculate the gradient
Use two points on the line of best fit, not two data points, so that the gradient uses all the data.
Step 2: Connect the gradient to the physics
In time the heater supplies , so and
The gradient equals , so .
Writing the gradient in terms of the formula tells you exactly how to get out of it.
Step 3: Calculate c
Step 4: Calculate the percentage error
Step 5: Explain the direction
Some of the heater's energy escapes to the surroundings, so the block warms less than it would if all the energy stayed in it. A smaller gradient gives a larger calculated . Heat loss is a systematic error: it always pushes the result above the true value, and repeating the experiment does not remove it.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) (b) (c) 6.8 %; the measured value is too high because energy is lost to the surroundings.
Method
Take the gradient from two well-separated points on the line of best fit.
Match the gradient to the formula: for a T–t graph, gradient = P/(mc).
Rearrange for c, then compare with the accepted value.
Watch out for
Using one data point, such as with the temperature instead of the temperature change.
Saying the error is "human error". Name the physical cause: energy lost to the surroundings.
Key idea
Recording and combining uncertainties
Record every measurement with its symbol, value, absolute uncertainty and SI unit, such as or .
- Analogue scale (such as a liquid-in-glass thermometer): usually ± half the smallest division.
- Digital readout: usually ± one unit in the last digit.
- Repeated trials: .
- Percentage uncertainty .
When you add or subtract measurements (such as ), add their absolute uncertainties. When you multiply or divide (such as ), add their percentage uncertainties.
Analogue thermometer
- Liquid-in-glass, marked every 1 °C, so read to ±0.5 °C.
- The reading depends on your eye: parallax error if you don't read at eye level.
- Slow to respond when the temperature changes quickly.
Digital thermometer
- Displays 0.1 °C, so ±0.1 °C: more precise.
- No parallax, and it can log data automatically.
- Responds quickly. But extra decimal places do not guarantee accuracy: a poorly calibrated probe can be precisely wrong.
Definition
Precision, accuracy and two kinds of error
- Precision: how close repeated measurements are to each other.
- Accuracy: how close a measurement is to the true value. Check a thermometer's accuracy against fixed points such as melting ice (0 °C) and boiling water (close to 100 °C at sea level).
- Random error scatters readings both ways. Repeating and averaging reduces its effect.
- Systematic error shifts every reading the same way, such as energy lost to the surroundings or a thermometer that reads 0.8 °C high. Repeating does not help; you must improve the method or calibrate the instrument.
Worked example
Mean and uncertainty from repeated trials
Five trials of the same heating experiment gave these temperature rises: 12.4 K, 12.9 K, 12.6 K, 13.0 K and 12.6 K.
(a) Calculate the mean temperature rise.
(b) Calculate the absolute uncertainty of the mean.
(c) Calculate the percentage uncertainty, and record the result.
Step 1: Calculate the mean
Step 2: Use the formula for the absolute uncertainty of the mean
Half the range of the trials is the spread either side of the mean that the data actually show. It is on the formula and data book.
Step 3: Calculate the percentage uncertainty
Step 4: Record the result
, a percentage uncertainty of 2.4 %. The mean is given to the same decimal place as the uncertainty.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(2.4 %).
Method
Mean = sum of trials ÷ number of trials.
Absolute uncertainty of the mean = ± (max − min)/2.
Percentage uncertainty = absolute uncertainty ÷ mean × 100 %.
Record value ± uncertainty with the unit, to matching decimal places.
Watch out for
Using the full range (0.6 K) as the uncertainty instead of half of it.
Giving the mean to more decimal places than the uncertainty, such as 12.70 ± 0.3 K.
An experiment records and . Calculate the percentage uncertainty in the temperature change, to two significant figures.
Common mistake
Which way does heat loss push the answer?
If you calculate using the energy supplied, energy lost to the surroundings makes smaller than it should be, so your comes out too high.
Don't write "human error". Name the cause and its direction: "energy transferred to the surroundings by conduction and convection, which makes the calculated larger than the true value". Insulating the block (and putting a lid on a liquid) reduces this systematic error; repeating the experiment does not.
In a specific heat capacity experiment, which change would most reduce the systematic error caused by energy loss to the surroundings?
Exam tip
Data-test habits
QCAA questions often give a graph from an experiment. Say what the gradient represents before you use it: for a – graph with constant power, gradient ; for against , gradient . Take the gradient from the line of best fit, not two data points.
Keep percentage uncertainty (the spread of your own measurements) separate from percentage error (how far your result is from the accepted value).
Summary
Measure , the energy supplied ( or a joulemeter) and ; insulate, stir or use good thermal contact, and take the highest temperature.
For a fixed mass, . The gradient of against is ; of against is .
Record measurements as value ± absolute uncertainty with unit. Add absolute uncertainties when adding or subtracting; add percentage uncertainties when multiplying or dividing.
A digital thermometer is more precise than an analogue one, but either can be inaccurate if it is not calibrated.
Energy loss to the surroundings is a systematic error that makes a measured too high; repeating does not remove it.
Percentage error compares your result with the accepted value.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.