Lesson 10 of 10 · 16 min
Efficiency and useable energy
Explain why every real energy transfer loses some energy as heat, calculate efficiencies, and consider what falling useable energy means for the future.
What you will be able to do
- Explain why energy transfers and transformations in mechanical systems always result in some heat loss to the environment.
- Describe efficiency and calculate it as a percentage from energies or powers.
- Combine efficiency with , and the first law.
- Discuss what falling useable energy means for future energy supply, and how better technologies help.
Fill a car's tank with petrol and drive. Only about a quarter to a third of the fuel's chemical energy ends up moving the car. The rest warms the engine, the exhaust gases, the radiator, the tyres and the air. Every machine has a share like this that doesn't do what you want, and physics says it can never be zero.
A Sankey diagram for a car engine. The width of each band shows the amount of energy.
Key idea
Why some energy is always lost as heat
In any real machine, moving parts rub against each other (friction), objects push through air (air resistance), currents flow through wires that have resistance, and vibrations make sound. Each of these passes some energy to the random motion of particles in the machine and its surroundings, where it ends up as thermal energy.
The energy is not destroyed, but it has spread out into the environment at a low temperature, where it can no longer do useful work. So the amount of useable energy is reduced in every real transfer.
Definition
Efficiency
Efficiency () is the percentage of the energy input that becomes useful energy output. A 25 % efficient engine turns a quarter of its fuel energy into useful work; the other 75 % ends up as thermal energy in the surroundings. No real device is 100 % efficient.
Worked example
Efficiency of an electric kettle
A 2.40 kW kettle heats 1.20 kg of water from 20.0 °C to 100 °C in 3.00 min.
(a) Calculate the efficiency of the kettle.
(b) Calculate how much energy is wasted, and state where it goes.
Step 1: Find the useful energy output
The useful output is the energy that ends up in the water. Keep the unrounded value for the next step.
Step 2: Find the energy input
Step 3: Calculate the efficiency
Step 4: Find the wasted energy
. It warms the kettle itself and is transferred to the surrounding air by conduction, convection and radiation (and a little escapes as steam).
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) 92.9 % (b) about is wasted, mostly heating the kettle and the surroundings.
Method
Useful output: for the water.
Input: with power in W and time in s.
Efficiency = useful output ÷ input × 100 %.
Watch out for
Using 3.00 min instead of 180 s.
Using 2.40 instead of 2400 W.
Dividing input by output to get more than 100 %.
An electric motor uses 500 J of electrical energy to lift a load, doing 380 J of useful work. Calculate its efficiency, to three significant figures.
Each transfer keeps % of the useable energy. The curve shows how much of an initial 100 J is still useable after transfers. At 80 % per transfer, how many transfers until less than half is left?
Energy is never destroyed, but every real transfer leaves some of it spread thinly through the surroundings as thermal energy at a temperature only slightly above everything else. In that form it is very hard to collect and use again. The useable energy goes down with every transfer, even though the total stays the same.
Chains of transfers multiply the losses. A coal-fired power station might be 35 % efficient, the transmission lines 95 % and an electric motor 85 %, so only , or 28 %, of the coal's energy ends up as useful motion. Fuel that has been burned cannot be burned again, which is why efficiency and renewable energy sources matter so much for the future.
Electricity is generated at 40 % efficiency, transmitted at 90 % efficiency and used in a motor that is 75 % efficient. What percentage of the fuel's energy becomes useful motion? Give your answer to two significant figures.
Note
Better heating science, less energy wasted
Improving efficiency is often the cheapest way to cut energy use and emissions, and many of the improvements are heating-process physics.
- Heat pumps (reverse-cycle air conditioners and heat-pump hot water systems) use electrical energy to move thermal energy from the cooler outside air into a building or a tank, delivering about 3 to 4 J of heating for each joule of electricity. That does not break energy conservation: most of the energy came from the outside air.
- Cogeneration plants use the waste heat from generating electricity to heat buildings or industrial processes.
- Solar thermal power stations store energy in tanks of molten salt, which can hold a lot of internal energy, so they keep generating after sunset.
- The same drive for efficiency that turned the 1 %-efficient Newcomen steam engine into Watt's engine, and later into the internal combustion engine and modern turbines, still pushes engine and power-station design today.
Worked example
Where a car engine's energy goes
While towing a caravan up a long hill, a car engine burns fuel that releases chemical energy at a rate of 150 kW. The engine delivers 45.0 kW of useful mechanical power to the wheels. The cooling system carries away 55.0 kW, and the rest leaves in the exhaust gases.
(a) Calculate the efficiency of the engine.
(b) Calculate the power carried away by the exhaust.
(c) The coolant warms by 8.00 K as it passes through the engine. Treating it as water, calculate the mass of coolant that must flow through the engine each second.
(d) Explain why a water-based coolant is used.
Step 1: Calculate the efficiency
Step 2: Account for all the energy
Energy is conserved, so input = useful output + cooling + exhaust: , giving .
This is the first law at work. Every joule of fuel energy ends up somewhere; only some of it is useful.
Step 3: Set up the coolant calculation per second
Each second the coolant must absorb while warming by 8.00 K:
Step 4: Solve for the mass per second
each second, a flow rate of .
Step 5: Explain the choice of water
Water has a very high specific heat capacity, so each kilogram absorbs a lot of energy for a small temperature rise and a modest flow can cool the engine. It is liquid over a wide temperature range (wider still with antifreeze added), flows easily, and is cheap, non-toxic and non-flammable.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) 30.0 % (b) 50.0 kW (c) (d) water's high specific heat capacity lets it absorb a lot of energy per kilogram for a small temperature rise; it is also liquid over a wide range, flows easily, and is cheap and safe.
Method
Efficiency from useful power ÷ input power.
Energy conservation accounts for every output.
Per second, gives the mass flow rate.
Watch out for
Treating the cooling system power as the useful output.
Forgetting to convert 55.0 kW to .
Common mistake
Efficiency errors
- Using the total output instead of the useful output.
- Dividing input by output. Any answer over 100 % is a red flag.
- Mixing units, such as kJ on top and J on the bottom.
- Adding the efficiencies in a chain. They multiply.
A heat-pump hot water system delivers 4 J of thermal energy to the water for every 1 J of electrical energy it uses. Which statement is correct?
Exam tip
Name the useful output first
Identify the useful output in words before calculating: for a kettle, the energy gained by the water (); for a motor, the work done lifting the load. If the question gives powers, use them directly: . And state where the wasted energy goes: "transferred to the surroundings as thermal energy".
Summary
Friction, air resistance, electrical resistance and sound mean every real transfer turns some energy into thermal energy in the surroundings.
That energy is not destroyed, but it is spread out at low temperature and is no longer useable.
Efficiency , always below 100 % for real devices.
In a chain of transfers, the efficiencies multiply.
Useable energy falls with every transfer, so efficient technologies (insulation, heat pumps, cogeneration) and renewable sources matter for the future.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.