Lesson 6 of 11 · 16 min
Analysing yield and rate data
Read graphs and tables of equilibrium yield and reaction rate against temperature, pressure and catalyst, and use them to justify the conditions an industrial process uses.
What you will be able to do
- Read equilibrium yields from a graph of yield against temperature at several pressures.
- Describe trends in yield data and explain them with Le Châtelier's principle.
- Distinguish yield from rate on a graph of product against time, and explain why the faster condition can make more product per hour.
- Use data as evidence when you justify or evaluate a choice of conditions.
Exam questions in this topic often hand you a graph or a table instead of asking you to recall the conditions. Your job is to read it accurately, describe the trend in words with numbers, and explain the trend with chemistry. The Haber process is the classic data set.
Equilibrium percentage of ammonia in a 1 : 3 mixture of and . Values from the measured equilibrium constants (Gillespie and Beattie, 1930) corrected for real-gas behaviour; they agree within about 1 % with direct measurements (Larson and Dodge, 1923–24).
Describe a trend with numbers from the graph, then explain it:
- Temperature: at 200 atm, the equilibrium percentage of ammonia falls from about 66 % at 300 °C to about 9 % at 600 °C. The forward reaction is exothermic, so a higher temperature shifts the equilibrium to the left (towards the endothermic direction) and decreases.
- Pressure: at 450 °C, it rises from about 16 % at 100 atm to about 36 % at 300 atm. Four moles of gas react to form two, so a higher pressure shifts the equilibrium towards the side with fewer gas particles.
The equilibrium lab in the earlier lessons uses the same values, so its readings agree with this graph to within about 1 %. Treating the gases as ideal would give yields a few percent lower at 200–300 atm: real gases at high pressure favour ammonia slightly more.
Use the graph. Estimate the equilibrium percentage of ammonia at and .
The yield graph only tells you where each mixture ends up. It says nothing about how long that takes. For that you need a graph of product against time.
Percentage of ammonia against time for the same mixture at two temperatures (200 atm, catalyst present). Schematic: real reactors reach equilibrium in seconds.
Use the graph of percentage of ammonia against time. Select all the statements the graph supports.
Key idea
Why a plant accepts a lower yield
A Haber reactor holds the gas for seconds, not minutes, and the ammonia is removed and the gas recycled. So what matters is how much ammonia is made per hour, not the yield the mixture would reach if left forever. At too low a temperature the yield per pass is limited by rate; at too high a temperature it is limited by equilibrium. About 450 °C with an iron catalyst makes the most ammonia per hour.
Worked example
Use yield data to justify the Haber conditions
The table shows the equilibrium percentage of ammonia for a mixture of nitrogen and hydrogen.
| Temperature (°C) | 100 atm | 200 atm | 300 atm |
|---|---|---|---|
| 350 | 38 | 52 | 61 |
| 450 | 16 | 27 | 36 |
| 550 | 7 | 13 | 19 |
A student proposes running a plant at and "because the data show this gives the highest yield". Evaluate the proposal.
Step 1: Confirm what the data show
At the yield rises from 19 % at to 61 % at ; at it rises from 38 % at to 61 % at . The student is right that and gives the highest equilibrium yield in the table.
Step 2: Explain the trends
The forward reaction is exothermic, so a lower temperature shifts the equilibrium to the right. It also forms fewer moles of gas, so a higher pressure shifts it to the right.
Step 3: Identify what the data do not show
The table gives yields at equilibrium. It says nothing about how quickly equilibrium is reached. At the rate is much lower, even with an iron catalyst, so less ammonia would be made per hour in a reactor where the gases stay only seconds.
In a flow reactor with recycling, the mass of ammonia per hour matters more than the equilibrium yield.
Step 4: Consider cost and safety of the pressure
Going from to at raises the yield from 27 % to 36 % per pass. But the plant recycles its unreacted gas, so a higher yield per pass is not essential, while compressing to 50 % more pressure raises the compressor energy, the cost of thicker-walled equipment and the risk of a leak or rupture.
Step 5: Reach a judgement
The proposal maximises the equilibrium yield but ignores rate, cost and safety. A temperature around and about , with unreacted gases recycled, produces more ammonia per hour at an acceptable cost, so it is the better choice.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The proposal gives the highest equilibrium yield (61 %), but the rate at is too low, and adds cost and risk for a gain that recycling makes unnecessary; about and with recycling is the better compromise.
Method
Quote data with numbers to describe both trends.
Explain each trend with Le Châtelier's principle.
Say what the data cannot show (rate, cost, safety).
Make a clear judgement and justify it.
Watch out for
Accepting "highest yield" as "best" without considering rate.
Describing a trend without quoting any data.
Tip
Investigating industrial processes with a simulation
The syllabus lets you investigate the Haber and contact processes with a simulation, such as the equilibrium lab in the earlier lessons. Change one variable at a time (temperature, pressure or catalyst) while keeping the others controlled, record the equilibrium yield and the rate, and repeat for several values so you can plot a trend. In your discussion, separate what the data show about yield from what they show about rate, say what the simulation simplifies (for example, treating the gases as ideal), and say what a real plant must also consider: energy costs, equipment, safety and the value of recycling.
Exam tip
Data questions
Quote values from the graph or table with units ("falls from 66 % at 300 °C to 9 % at 600 °C"), name the trend, then explain it with Le Châtelier's principle (yield) or collision theory (rate). If you're asked to justify conditions, use the data for one side of the compromise and chemistry for the other.
Summary
On a yield graph, compare points along one line for temperature and between lines for pressure.
For the Haber process, yield falls as temperature rises and rises with pressure.
On a product–time graph, steepness is rate and the plateau is the equilibrium yield.
A faster, lower-yield condition can make more product per hour when products are removed and reactants recycled.
Support every claim with a number from the data and a reason from chemistry.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.