Lesson 11 of 11 · 15 min
Biofuels, industrial enzymes and molecular manufacturing
Explain why biofuels are being developed, how bioethanol and biodiesel are made from algae, oil seeds, wood waste and waste oils, how enzymes make these syntheses viable, and what molecular manufacturing promises.
What you will be able to do
- Explain why dwindling fossil fuels and carbon emissions have driven research into biofuels.
- Describe how bioethanol and biodiesel are made from plant feedstocks and waste materials, and evaluate each source.
- Write the equation for the transesterification of a triglyceride to biodiesel, and explain the advantages of a lipase catalyst.
- Describe molecular manufacturing and its potential products.
Petrol, diesel and natural gas took millions of years to form, and the easily extracted reserves are running down. Burning them also releases carbon that has been locked away underground, adding to the atmosphere. Biofuels, made from recently living material, offer fuels from feedstocks that regrow, and the carbon they release on burning was taken from the air by photosynthesis only months or years earlier.
Definition
Biofuel
A biofuel is a fuel made from biomass (recently living material), such as bioethanol from fermented sugars and biodiesel from plant oils, animal fats or waste cooking oil.
| Feedstock | Fuel and process | Advantages | Drawbacks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sugar cane, grain | Bioethanol by fermentation | Established technology; Queensland already makes it from cane molasses | Competes with food crops for land and water |
| Wood waste, crop stalks | Bioethanol: cellulase enzymes hydrolyse cellulose to glucose, which is then fermented | Uses waste, not food | Cellulose is hard to break down; pre-treatment and enzymes add cost |
| Oil seeds (canola, soybean, palm) | Biodiesel by transesterification | Simple process; runs in standard diesel engines | Needs farmland; palm plantations have caused deforestation |
| Algae | Biodiesel from the oil; the rest can be fermented | Very high oil yield per hectare; grows in salt water or waste water on non-farm land | Growing, harvesting and drying algae is still expensive |
| Waste cooking oil | Biodiesel by transesterification | Cheap; turns a waste into a fuel; needs no extra land | Limited supply; contains water and free fatty acids that cause problems with base catalysts |
Biodiesel is made by transesterification. Fats and oils are triglycerides, esters of glycerol (propane-1,2,3-triol) with three long-chain fatty acids. Reacting a triglyceride with methanol swaps the glycerol part of each ester for a methyl group, giving three molecules of fatty acid methyl ester (biodiesel) and one of glycerol. For glyceryl tripalmitate:
Transesterification: each of the three ester links of the triglyceride swaps glycerol for methanol.
Most biodiesel is made with a base catalyst such as or at about 60 °C. That works well for clean oil, but waste cooking oil contains free fatty acids, which react with the base to form soap, and water, which makes things worse. The soap uses up catalyst and makes the glycerol hard to separate.
Base catalyst (NaOH or KOH)
- Cheap and fast.
- Needs refined oil low in water and free fatty acids.
- Free fatty acids form soap; catalyst is used up.
- Product must be washed; glycerol is impure.
Lipase (an enzyme)
- Works at a lower temperature (about 30–50 °C), saving energy.
- Tolerates the free fatty acids and water in waste oils, and also turns free fatty acids into biodiesel.
- No soap; purer glycerol that can be sold.
- Immobilised on a solid support, it can be reused many times; but it is expensive and slower.
Key idea
Why industry uses enzymes
Enzymes are protein catalysts. They lower the activation energy so much that reactions reach an economically viable rate at mild temperatures and pressures, and they are highly specific, so few by-products form. That is why yeast's enzymes make fermentation practical at about 35 °C, and why lipases are used for biodiesel. Their weakness is the other side of the same coin: above about 40–60 °C, or at the wrong pH, they denature and stop working.
Worked example
Biodiesel: atom economy and catalyst choice
Biodiesel can be made from glyceryl tripalmitate, a fat in palm oil:
(a) Calculate the atom economy for making the methyl ester (biodiesel). (b) Calculate the mass of biodiesel made from of the fat at a 95.0 % yield. (c) The glycerol by-product can be purified and sold. Explain how this, and the choice of an immobilised lipase catalyst, affect how "green" the process is.
Step 1: Molar masses
: . : . : .
Step 2: Atom economy
Step 3: Moles of fat
Step 4: Mass of biodiesel at 95.0 % yield
Step 5: Evaluate the by-product and the catalyst
The other 10.2 % of the reactants' mass is glycerol. Selling it for soaps, cosmetics and food means almost nothing is wasted, so the process is greener than its atom economy suggests. An immobilised lipase works at about 40 °C (less energy), forms no soap with free fatty acids (purer glycerol, no catalyst waste) and can be reused many times; its drawbacks are cost and a slower rate.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) . (b) . (c) Selling the glycerol uses the remaining 10 % of the mass, and lipase saves energy and avoids soap and catalyst waste, so the process is very green, at a higher catalyst cost.
Method
Expand condensed formulas into molecular formulas to find molar masses.
Atom economy uses coefficients for every species.
Judge greenness on atom economy, by-product use, energy, catalyst and feedstock.
Watch out for
Leaving out the coefficient 3 for methanol or the methyl ester.
Treating the sold by-product as waste when evaluating the process.
A company wants to make biodiesel from used cooking oil, which contains free fatty acids. Which is the best reason to choose a lipase catalyst instead of sodium hydroxide?
Are biofuels carbon neutral? Not completely. The released when a biofuel burns was recently absorbed by the plant, but growing, fertilising, harvesting, transporting and processing the feedstock all use energy, mostly from fossil fuels. Clearing forest for crops releases stored carbon too. Biofuels from wastes, such as used cooking oil and wood waste, usually give the biggest real reduction in emissions.
Explain why bioethanol made from sugar cane is described as "renewable", and why it is not completely carbon neutral.
Molecular manufacturing. Today's chemistry mixes enormous numbers of molecules and relies on them colliding the right way. Molecular manufacturing (or molecular assembly) imagines building products to atomic precision instead: robotic mechanisms at the nanoscale would hold molecules in exactly the right position and orientation so that a specific reaction happens at a specific place. Biology already does this. A ribosome positions amino acids one at a time to build a protein in a defined sequence.
The potential products include stronger, lighter materials such as carbon nanotubes, smaller, faster and more energy-efficient computer chips, tailored proteins, and medical devices such as chemical sensors and nanorobots that could deliver drugs to a single type of cell. Because each reaction is placed precisely, there would be almost no by-products, which is the ultimate green synthesis. Much of this is still research, and questions remain about safety, cost and how to scale it up.
Summary
Dwindling fossil fuels and carbon emissions drive research into biofuels from renewable or waste feedstocks.
Bioethanol comes from fermenting sugars (including glucose from wood waste); biodiesel from transesterifying oils from seeds, algae or waste.
Triglyceride + 3 methanol → 3 methyl esters (biodiesel) + glycerol.
Enzymes give economically viable rates under mild conditions; lipase avoids soap formation with waste oils.
Molecular manufacturing positions molecules so each reaction happens exactly where wanted, with potential for new materials, electronics and medicine.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.