Lesson 10 of 11 · 16 min

Atom economy and green chemistry

Calculate the atom economy of a synthesis, compare routes to the same product, and apply the principles of green chemistry, including renewable feedstocks and greener solvents.

What you will be able to do

  • Calculate atom economy from a balanced equation: M(desired product)∑M(reactants)×100 %\dfrac{M(\text{desired product})}{\sum M(\text{reactants})} \times 100\,\%.
  • Distinguish atom economy from percentage yield.
  • Use atom economy to compare the economic and environmental impact of two routes to the same product.
  • Describe principles of green chemistry, including renewable raw materials, safer solvents and fewer by-products.

A reaction can have a 95 % yield and still be wasteful. If half the mass of the reactants turns into a by-product nobody wants, that half has to be bought, handled and disposed of. Atom economy measures this kind of waste, and it is one of the main ideas of green chemistry.

Definition

Atom economy

Atom economy is the percentage of the total mass of the reactants that ends up in the desired product, assuming the reaction goes exactly as the balanced equation says:

atom economy=M(desired product)∑M(reactants)×100 %\text{atom economy} = \frac{M(\text{desired product})}{\sum M(\text{reactants})} \times 100\,\%

Multiply each molar mass by its coefficient in the balanced equation.

Look at the two routes to ethanol. The hydration of ethene, CX2HX4(g)+HX2O(g)⇌CX2HX5OH(g)\ce{C2H4(g) + H2O(g) <=> C2H5OH(g)}, has one product, so every atom ends up in ethanol: the atom economy is 100 %. Every addition reaction has an atom economy of 100 %. Fermentation produces carbon dioxide as well:

atom economy=2×46.08180.18×100 %=51.1 %\text{atom economy} = \frac{2 \times 46.08}{180.18} \times 100\,\% = 51.1\,\%

Almost half the mass of the glucose leaves as COX2\ce{CO2}.

Atom economies of processes in this topic, calculated from data-book molar masses. Addition reactions score 100 %; every by-product lowers the bar.

Worked example

Compare the atom economy of two routes to ethanol

  • Complex familiar
  • Technology active

Ethanol can be made by fermentation, CX6HX12OX6(aq)→2 CX2HX5OH(aq)+2 COX2(g)\ce{C6H12O6(aq) -> 2C2H5OH(aq) + 2CO2(g)}, or by hydration of ethene, CX2HX4(g)+HX2O(g)⇌CX2HX5OH(g)\ce{C2H4(g) + H2O(g) <=> C2H5OH(g)}. Calculate the atom economy of each route, and the mass of carbon dioxide produced for every tonne of ethanol made by fermentation. Use the results to comment on the two routes.

5 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Atom economy = M(desired product) × its coefficient ÷ total M of reactants × coefficients × 100 %.

  2. Addition reactions: 100 %.

  3. Weigh atom economy against feedstock, energy and by-product value.

Watch out for

  • Forgetting the coefficient 2 for ethanol (giving 25.6 %).

  • Treating a high atom economy as a high percentage yield.

Quicklime, CaO\ce{CaO}, is made by heating limestone: CaCOX3(s)→CaO(s)+COX2(g)\ce{CaCO3(s) -> CaO(s) + CO2(g)}. Calculate the atom economy for making quicklime, to three significant figures.

in \%

Give 3 significant figures.

Common mistake

Atom economy is not percentage yield

Atom economy is worked out from the balanced equation before anything happens. It tells you the best you could do: how much of the reactants' mass can end up in the product. Percentage yield is measured after the reaction: how much product you actually got compared with the theoretical yield. The Haber process has an atom economy of 100 % but converts only about 15 % per pass. Fermentation has an atom economy of 51 % even if its yield is 95 %.

A chemist makes ethanol by hydrating ethene and collects 80 % of the theoretical yield. Which statement is correct?

Choose one answer

Green chemistry is a set of principles, first written down by Paul Anastas and John Warner in 1998, for designing chemical processes that are safer and produce less waste. The ones this syllabus highlights:

  • Prevent waste rather than treat it afterwards, by choosing reactions with a high atom economy that maximise the desired product and minimise by-products.
  • Use renewable raw materials (plants, waste products, waste gases) instead of fossil fuels.
  • Use safer solvents, or none at all.
  • Use catalysts, including enzymes, rather than reagents that are used up, and run reactions at lower temperatures and pressures to save energy.
  • Simplify the synthesis: fewer steps mean fewer separations, less solvent and less waste.
  • Design products that break down harmlessly after use, such as PLA.

History

Redesigning ibuprofen

The original industrial synthesis of the painkiller ibuprofen took six steps and had an atom economy of about 40 %, so most of the mass of the reactants became waste. In the 1990s a new route used three catalytic steps, with an atom economy of about 77 %, rising close to 100 % when the ethanoic acid by-product is recovered and sold. It won a US Presidential Green Chemistry Challenge Award in 1997, and it is cheaper too: less waste is also less money spent on raw materials and disposal.

Greener solvents. Many reactions and extractions use organic solvents such as dichloromethane, hexane or tetrachloroethene, which are toxic, flammable or persistent, and evaporate into the air. Greener choices include:

  • water, the safest solvent of all, where the reagents allow;
  • supercritical carbon dioxide (above 31 °C and 7.4 MPa it behaves like a liquid solvent). It decaffeinates coffee and dry-cleans clothes, then simply evaporates when the pressure is released, leaving no residue;
  • ethanol and ethyl lactate, made from renewable plant sugars and biodegradable;
  • solvent-free reactions, such as grinding solid reactants together.

Select all the changes that would make a chemical process "greener".

Select all that apply.

Exam tip

Drawing conclusions from atom economy

Say what the number means: "the higher atom economy means a greater proportion of the reactant atoms end up in the desired product, so less waste is produced and less raw material is bought per kilogram of product, so the route is greener and cheaper". Then weigh it against the other factors: yield, rate, energy, renewable feedstock, hazards, and whether the by-product can be sold.

Summary

  • Atom economy =M(desired product)∑M(reactants)×100 %= \dfrac{M(\text{desired product})}{\sum M(\text{reactants})} \times 100\,\%, from the balanced equation.

  • Addition reactions have 100 % atom economy; reactions with by-products have less.

  • Atom economy is the best possible use of atoms; percentage yield is what was actually achieved.

  • Green chemistry: prevent waste, renewable feedstocks, safer solvents, catalysts, low energy, fewer steps, degradable products.

  • Water, supercritical COX2\ce{CO2}, ethanol and ethyl lactate are greener solvents.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 10 of 110% read

Save your progress with a free account