Lesson 7 of 12 · 18 min

Identifying ions in solution

Analyse precipitation and acid–carbonate test results to identify the cations and anions in an unknown solution, and plan tests in an order that gives a clear answer.

What you will be able to do

  • Use the acid–carbonate test and limewater to identify carbonate ions.
  • Use barium and silver ions to identify sulfate and halide ions.
  • Use sodium hydroxide and the colours of hydroxide precipitates to identify cations.
  • Plan a sequence of tests and justify the order and the reagents.
  • Write observation, inference and equation for each test.

A water-testing laboratory receives a bottle of clear groundwater and needs to know what is dissolved in it. Each ion has a reaction that gives it away: a gas, a precipitate of a particular colour, or no change at all. Put several tests together in a sensible order and you can identify the ions with confidence.

Key idea

Observation, inference, equation

An observation is what you see: "a white precipitate formed", "bubbles of a colourless gas turned limewater milky". An inference is what it tells you: "sulfate ions are present". The equation, usually net ionic, shows why. A full answer gives all three.

Testing for anions

Carbonate. Add dilute nitric acid. Fizzing shows a gas; if the gas turns limewater milky it is carbon dioxide, so carbonate ions were present:

COX3X2−(aq)+2 HX+(aq)→HX2O(l)+COX2(g)\ce{CO3^2-(aq) + 2H+(aq) -> H2O(l) + CO2(g)}

Limewater (calcium hydroxide solution) turns milky because insoluble calcium carbonate forms:

Ca(OH)X2(aq)+COX2(g)→CaCOX3(s)+HX2O(l)\ce{Ca(OH)2(aq) + CO2(g) -> CaCO3(s) + H2O(l)}

Sulfate. Acidify with dilute nitric acid, then add barium nitrate (or barium chloride) solution. A white precipitate of barium sulfate shows sulfate ions: BaX2+(aq)+SOX4X2−(aq)→BaSOX4(s)\ce{Ba^2+(aq) + SO4^2-(aq) -> BaSO4(s)}.

Chloride, bromide and iodide. Acidify with dilute nitric acid, then add silver nitrate solution. The colour of the silver halide tells you which halide: white AgCl\ce{AgCl}, cream AgBr\ce{AgBr}, pale yellow AgI\ce{AgI}.

A sequence of anion tests. The carbonate test comes first, because carbonate would also precipitate with barium and silver ions.

Tip

Why nitric acid, and why carbonate first

Carbonate ions also precipitate with barium ions (BaCOX3\ce{BaCO3}) and silver ions (AgX2COX3\ce{Ag2CO3}), so a carbonate could be mistaken for a sulfate or a chloride. Adding dilute nitric acid first destroys any carbonate as carbon dioxide.

Use nitric acid, not hydrochloric or sulfuric acid: those would add the very chloride or sulfate ions you are testing for. Every nitrate is soluble, so nitrate ions never interfere.

Before testing a solution for chloride ions with silver nitrate, a student acidifies it with dilute hydrochloric acid. Why is this a poor choice?

Choose one answer
Tests for cations. Add sodium hydroxide solution a few drops at a time unless another reagent is given.
CationTestObservationNet ionic equation
CuX2+\ce{Cu^2+}NaOH(aq)\ce{NaOH(aq)}pale blue precipitateCuX2+(aq)+2 OHX−(aq)→Cu(OH)X2(s)\ce{Cu^2+(aq) + 2OH-(aq) -> Cu(OH)2(s)}
FeX2+\ce{Fe^2+}NaOH(aq)\ce{NaOH(aq)}green precipitateFeX2+(aq)+2 OHX−(aq)→Fe(OH)X2(s)\ce{Fe^2+(aq) + 2OH-(aq) -> Fe(OH)2(s)}
FeX3+\ce{Fe^3+}NaOH(aq)\ce{NaOH(aq)}red-brown precipitateFeX3+(aq)+3 OHX−(aq)→Fe(OH)X3(s)\ce{Fe^3+(aq) + 3OH-(aq) -> Fe(OH)3(s)}
MgX2+\ce{Mg^2+}NaOH(aq)\ce{NaOH(aq)}white precipitateMgX2+(aq)+2 OHX−(aq)→Mg(OH)X2(s)\ce{Mg^2+(aq) + 2OH-(aq) -> Mg(OH)2(s)}
NHX4X+\ce{NH4+}NaOH(aq)\ce{NaOH(aq)}, warmno precipitate; gas turns damp red litmus blueNHX4X+(aq)+OHX−(aq)→NHX3(g)+HX2O(l)\ce{NH4+(aq) + OH-(aq) -> NH3(g) + H2O(l)}
BaX2+\ce{Ba^2+}NaX2SOX4(aq)\ce{Na2SO4(aq)}white precipitateBaX2+(aq)+SOX4X2−(aq)→BaSOX4(s)\ce{Ba^2+(aq) + SO4^2-(aq) -> BaSO4(s)}
AgX+\ce{Ag+}NaCl(aq)\ce{NaCl(aq)}white precipitateAgX+(aq)+ClX−(aq)→AgCl(s)\ce{Ag+(aq) + Cl-(aq) -> AgCl(s)}
PbX2+\ce{Pb^2+}KI(aq)\ce{KI(aq)}bright yellow precipitatePbX2+(aq)+2 IX−(aq)→PbIX2(s)\ce{Pb^2+(aq) + 2I-(aq) -> PbI2(s)}

Note

Supporting evidence

A white hydroxide precipitate narrows the choice but does not identify the ion: magnesium, zinc, aluminium and lead(II) ions all give white hydroxides, and calcium ions a faint white one (calcium hydroxide is only partially soluble). Use a second test to decide, such as a flame test or a precipitate with a different anion.

Some solutions are coloured before you test them: copper(II) solutions are blue, iron(II) pale green and iron(III) yellow-brown. Flame tests from Unit 1 can confirm a metal ion (sodium yellow-orange, potassium lilac, calcium orange-red, copper blue-green). Neither is enough on its own, but each supports a precipitate test.

Interactive

Identify the unknown

Run the flame, precipitate and acid tests on the mystery solution, then name it. Plan the order before you start.

Worked example

Identifying an unknown salt

  • Complex unfamiliar
  • Technology free

A pale green solution contains a single dissolved salt. Separate samples are tested:

  1. Dilute nitric acid is added: no bubbles.
  2. After acidifying with nitric acid, barium nitrate solution is added: a white precipitate forms.
  3. After acidifying with nitric acid, silver nitrate solution is added: no precipitate.
  4. Sodium hydroxide solution is added: a green precipitate forms.

Identify the salt, explaining each inference, and write net ionic equations for the precipitates.

5 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Work through each test as observation → inference.

  2. Use negative results to rule ions out.

  3. Combine one cation and one anion into a formula with balanced charges.

Watch out for

  • Concluding iron(III): its hydroxide is red-brown, not green.

  • Ignoring test 1, which is what makes test 2 conclusive for sulfate.

A few drops of sodium hydroxide solution are added to a yellow-brown solution, and a red-brown precipitate forms. Write the formula of the cation that is present.

Reads asYour answer shows here as chemistry.

Two unlabelled bottles hold sodium chloride solution and sodium carbonate solution. Which single test tells them apart most simply?

Choose one answer

Common mistake

Precise observations

  • Write "a white precipitate formed", not "it went white" or "it turned cloudy". Precipitate, colour, and which reagent caused it.
  • "Bubbles" alone does not identify carbon dioxide: hydrogen also bubbles. The limewater test identifies COX2\ce{CO2}.
  • A test that gives no change is evidence too: "no precipitate with barium nitrate, so sulfate is absent".

Exam tip

Planning a sequence of tests

When asked to design tests, give for each: the reagent (and why that one), the expected observation if the ion is present, and how you will know it is absent. Order the tests so that an earlier test removes any ion that would interfere with a later one, as nitric acid removes carbonate before the barium and silver tests.

Summary

  • Carbonate: fizzes with dilute acid; the COX2\ce{CO2} turns limewater milky.

  • Sulfate: white BaSOX4\ce{BaSO4} with barium ions, after acidifying with nitric acid.

  • Halides: white AgCl\ce{AgCl}, cream AgBr\ce{AgBr} or pale yellow AgI\ce{AgI} with silver nitrate, after acidifying with nitric acid.

  • Cations: hydroxide precipitates of characteristic colour; ammonium gives ammonia gas when warmed with NaOH\ce{NaOH}.

  • Test for carbonate first and acidify with nitric acid, so no ion interferes with later tests.

  • Report observation, inference and equation.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 7 of 120% read

Save your progress with a free account