Lesson 4 of 12 · 16 min
Why some substances dissolve in water
Compare how ionic and molecular substances dissolve in water, using ion–dipole attractions, hydrogen bonds and dispersion forces to explain which dissolve and which do not.
What you will be able to do
- Describe dissolving as breaking some attractions and forming new ones between solute particles and water.
- Explain how an ionic compound dissociates in water through ion–dipole attractions.
- Explain why polar molecular substances that can hydrogen bond dissolve in water while non-polar ones do not.
- Distinguish the factors that change solubility from those that only change the rate of dissolving.
Salt and sugar vanish into water; cooking oil floats on it in a layer; iodine barely colours it. Whether a substance dissolves depends on a contest between attractions.
To dissolve, the solute particles must be pulled apart from each other, and the water molecules must be pushed apart to make room. Both cost energy. The substance dissolves well only if the new attractions between the solute particles and water are about as strong as the ones broken.
Key idea
Like dissolves like
Polar and ionic solutes tend to dissolve in polar solvents such as water. Non-polar solutes tend to dissolve in non-polar solvents such as hexane. The attractions between the solute and the solvent must be able to replace the attractions within each.
Try sodium chloride, glucose and iodine in water, then iodine and oil in hexane. Which way does each water molecule turn towards a cation, and towards an anion?
Ionic substances
When sodium chloride meets water, the δ− oxygen ends of water molecules are attracted to the ions and the δ+ hydrogen ends to the ions. These ion–dipole attractions pull ions out of the lattice one by one, and each ion ends up surrounded by a shell of water molecules (it is hydrated). The compound dissociates:
Not every ionic compound dissolves. Where the attractions between the ions in the lattice are much stronger than the ion–dipole attractions they could form with water, the compound is insoluble: silver chloride and calcium carbonate are examples. The data book's solubility table records which is which.
Hydrated ions. Water's δ− oxygen faces the cation; its δ+ hydrogens face the anion.
When potassium bromide dissolves, which part of each surrounding water molecule points towards a ion?
Molecular substances
Molecular substances dissolve without breaking their covalent bonds, so the solute particles in the solution are still molecules.
- Polar molecules that can hydrogen bond (with O–H or N–H groups) dissolve well, because they form hydrogen bonds with water that replace the ones broken. Ethanol, glucose and sucrose are examples: .
- Non-polar molecules such as iodine, hexane, oils and oxygen can form only dispersion forces with water. These are too weak to make up for the hydrogen bonds between water molecules that would have to break, so these substances are insoluble or only very slightly soluble. They dissolve well in non-polar solvents.
- A few polar molecules ionise as they dissolve, because they react with water: hydrogen chloride gas forms hydrochloric acid, .
| Alcohol | Formula | Solubility (g per 100 g water) |
|---|---|---|
| methanol | mixes in all proportions | |
| ethanol | mixes in all proportions | |
| propan-1-ol | mixes in all proportions | |
| butan-1-ol | about 7.7 | |
| pentan-1-ol | about 2.2 | |
| hexan-1-ol | about 0.6 |
Worked example
Salt, sugar and iodine in water and hexane
Sodium chloride and glucose both dissolve well in water, but iodine, , hardly dissolves in water. Iodine dissolves readily in hexane, . Explain these observations in terms of the forces between the particles.
Step 1: Sodium chloride in water
Water is polar. Its δ− oxygen atoms are attracted to ions and its δ+ hydrogen atoms to ions. These ion–dipole attractions are strong enough to pull ions from the lattice and surround them, so the salt dissociates: .
Step 2: Glucose in water
Glucose is a polar molecule with five O–H groups. It forms hydrogen bonds with water molecules that replace the hydrogen bonds broken in the solid and in the water, so it dissolves as whole molecules.
Step 3: Iodine in water
Iodine is non-polar, so it can only form dispersion forces with water. Dissolving it would mean breaking strong hydrogen bonds between water molecules and replacing them with much weaker iodine–water attractions, which does not happen to any great extent.
For a substance to dissolve, the new solute–solvent attractions must be comparable to the attractions broken.
Step 4: Iodine in hexane
Hexane is also non-polar, held together by dispersion forces. The dispersion forces between iodine and hexane molecules are similar in strength to those broken in each pure substance, so iodine dissolves. Like dissolves like.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Sodium chloride dissolves in water through ion–dipole attractions; glucose dissolves by hydrogen bonding with water. Non-polar iodine can form only weak dispersion forces with water, which cannot replace the hydrogen bonds between water molecules, so it barely dissolves; in non-polar hexane the dispersion forces formed match those broken, so it dissolves readily.
Method
Identify the forces within the solute and within the solvent.
Identify the attractions the solute could form with the solvent.
Dissolves well when the new attractions are comparable to those broken: like dissolves like.
Watch out for
Saying glucose dissolves by forming ions. It dissolves as molecules.
Explaining only the solute's forces and ignoring the hydrogen bonds in water that must break.
Which substance is least soluble in water?
Select all the aqueous solutions that conduct electricity.
Note
Investigating factors that affect solubility
Solubility (how much dissolves in a saturated solution) depends on the solute and solvent, the temperature, and for gases the pressure. Rate of dissolving (how fast it gets there) depends also on stirring and particle size.
Stirring and crushing the solid make a solid dissolve faster, but they do not let any more of it dissolve. In an investigation, keep the solvent volume and temperature controlled, add solute in small weighed portions until some stays undissolved after thorough stirring, and record the total mass that dissolved.
Common mistake
Dissolving is not melting, and molecules do not dissociate
Sugar dissolving in tea is not melting: the sugar is still well below its melting point. And molecular solutes such as glucose stay as whole molecules in solution, so do not write them as ions. Only ionic compounds dissociate, and only acids (and a few other molecules) ionise.
Summary
Dissolving breaks solute–solute and water–water attractions and forms solute–water attractions.
Ionic compounds dissolve through ion–dipole attractions: water's δ− oxygen faces cations, its δ+ hydrogens face anions.
Ionic compounds with very strong lattice attractions are insoluble; the data book's table tells you which.
Polar molecules with O–H or N–H groups dissolve by hydrogen bonding with water; non-polar molecules form only dispersion forces and are insoluble.
Like dissolves like. Longer hydrocarbon chains make molecules less soluble in water.
Stirring and particle size change the rate of dissolving, not the solubility.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.