Lesson 7 of 9 · 15 min
Stereotypes, prejudice and discrimination
Describe stereotypes and their advantages and disadvantages, contrast prejudice with discrimination, and consider how social, economic, cultural and ethical contexts shape them.
What you will be able to do
- Describe a stereotype and identify its advantages and disadvantages.
- Define prejudice and discrimination.
- Contrast prejudice and discrimination, with examples of each occurring without the other.
- Consider how social, economic, cultural and ethical contexts influence stereotypes, prejudice and discrimination.
Stereotypes, prejudice and discrimination are three different things that are easy to blur together. A useful way to hold them apart is the tri-component model from the first lesson: a stereotype is a belief, prejudice is an attitude, and discrimination is behaviour.
The examples in this lesson use invented towns, schools and clubs. That is deliberate: the mechanisms are the same for every group, and you can learn them without repeating a stereotype about a real one.
Definition
Stereotype
A stereotype is a widely held, oversimplified belief about the characteristics of the members of a group, which is applied to an individual because they belong to that group.
Stereotypes follow from social categorisation (the social identity lesson). Once we have sorted people into groups, it is a short step to believing that everyone in a group shares the same traits: "people from Kellbrook are unfriendly", "Northvale students are all into sport". Stereotypes can be negative or positive, but even positive ones ignore the person in front of you.
Advantages of stereotypes
- Cognitive economy: they are mental shortcuts that let us process a complicated social world quickly, without assessing every person from scratch.
- They let us make fast predictions about what to expect in unfamiliar situations, which can guide behaviour when there is no time to gather information.
- They help us organise information about groups and remember it.
Disadvantages of stereotypes
- They overgeneralise: they ignore the large differences between individuals within a group.
- They are often inaccurate, and frequently negative.
- They resist change: confirmation bias means we notice cases that fit and dismiss those that do not ("the exception that proves the rule").
- They can become self-fulfilling: people treated according to a stereotype may come to act in line with it.
- They can produce stereotype threat: worrying about confirming a negative stereotype about your own group can lower performance (Steele & Aronson 1995).
- They can lead to prejudice and discrimination.
Which statement describes an advantage of stereotypes?
Definition
Prejudice and discrimination
Prejudice is a negative (or occasionally positive) attitude towards a person based on their membership of a group, formed without adequate evidence about the individual. Literally, a "pre-judgement".
Discrimination is behaviour that treats a person unfairly or differently because of their membership of a group.
Because prejudice is an attitude, it has all three components of the tri-component model. A stereotype often forms its cognitive component ("Kellbrook people are unfriendly"); dislike or unease towards the group is the affective component ("I feel uncomfortable around them"); and the behavioural component is the tendency to act on it ("I would rather not work with them"). When that behavioural tendency is acted on, the result is discrimination.
| Feature | Prejudice | Discrimination |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | An attitude: thoughts and feelings | Behaviour: actions |
| Can it be seen? | Not directly; it is inferred from what people say or do | Yes: it can be observed and measured |
| Example | Believing that applicants from Kellbrook are less reliable | Not shortlisting an applicant because her address is in Kellbrook |
| Can the law regulate it? | No: holding an attitude is not illegal | Yes: many kinds of discrimination are unlawful, for example under the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) and the Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth) |
Key idea
Each can occur without the other
- Prejudice without discrimination. A person may hold a prejudice but not act on it, because of the law, social norms, fear of disapproval or their own values. A manager who dislikes Kellbrook people may still hire one because discriminating would be unlawful.
- Discrimination without prejudice. A person may discriminate without holding a prejudice, because they are following a rule, conforming to others or not noticing the effect of a policy. A receptionist who turns away customers without a local address because of a company policy discriminates whether or not they hold any prejudice. Rules like this, built into how an organisation works, are called institutional discrimination.
Classify each as a stereotype, prejudice or discrimination.
Sort each example, then switch to the stereotypes view to sort the advantages and disadvantages of stereotyping.
Worked example
Contrast prejudice and discrimination
Contrast prejudice and discrimination, using an example in which each occurs without the other.
Step 1: Define both
Prejudice is an attitude, usually negative, towards a person because of their membership of a group. Discrimination is behaviour that treats a person unfairly or differently because of their membership of a group.
Step 2: State the difference
Prejudice is an attitude (thoughts and feelings), whereas discrimination is behaviour (actions). Prejudice cannot be observed directly, whereas discrimination can.
"Contrast" asks for differences, so a sentence that sets the two side by side earns the mark.
Step 3: Prejudice without discrimination
A shop owner dislikes people from the town of Kellbrook but serves Kellbrook customers exactly like everyone else, because refusing them would cost business and break the shop's policy.
Step 4: Discrimination without prejudice
A casual worker with no opinion about Kellbrook people turns away a Kellbrook applicant because the manager told him to hire only local residents.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Prejudice is an attitude towards a person based on group membership, whereas discrimination is behaviour that treats them unfairly because of it. Each can occur without the other: a shop owner may dislike Kellbrook people yet serve them fairly (prejudice without discrimination), and a worker following an instruction may turn away a Kellbrook applicant without any prejudice (discrimination without prejudice).
Method
Define each term.
Write the difference with "whereas".
Give an example of each without the other.
Watch out for
Defining both but never stating a difference. Contrast needs a comparison.
Context shapes all three. Stereotypical, prejudiced and discriminatory attitudes do not arise in a vacuum. The syllabus asks you to consider four kinds of context.
- Social: the norms of family, friends and the media. Where a group's norms accept a prejudice, members adopt it to fit in; where norms reject it, it fades.
- Economic: competition for jobs, housing and resources. Prejudice towards out-groups tends to rise when resources are scarce, for example during a recession, as groups come to see each other as threats.
- Cultural: a culture's values, history and portrayals of groups. The stereotypes a culture repeats in stories and humour are learned by each new generation.
- Ethical: what a society judges right and wrong, and builds into laws and codes of conduct. When discrimination becomes unlawful and is called out, behaviour changes first; over time, attitudes often follow.
After a large factory in a regional town closes, residents begin to express more hostility towards workers who have moved to the town from elsewhere. Which context best explains the change?
Common mistake
Contrast means both sides
For "contrast prejudice and discrimination", one definition is not enough. Write a sentence that states the difference with whereas ("prejudice is an attitude, whereas discrimination is behaviour"), then show that each can occur without the other, with an example of each.
Note
Coming up in Topic 4
Racism, one of the most serious forms of prejudice and discrimination, and the ways prejudice can be reduced through intergroup contact, are taught in the next topic, Cross-cultural psychology.
Summary
A stereotype is an oversimplified, widely held belief about the members of a group.
Advantages: cognitive economy, fast predictions, organising information. Disadvantages: overgeneralising, inaccuracy, resistance to change, self-fulfilling effects, stereotype threat, and leading to prejudice and discrimination.
Prejudice is an attitude towards a person based on group membership; discrimination is behaviour that treats them unfairly because of it.
Prejudice can exist without discrimination (law, norms) and discrimination without prejudice (rules, conformity, institutional discrimination).
Social, economic, cultural and ethical contexts all influence stereotypes, prejudice and discrimination.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.