Lesson 3 of 9 · 18 min
Cognitive dissonance
Explain how inconsistent attitudes, cognitions and behaviours cause discomfort and a drive to reduce it, predict how people reduce it, and explain why Festinger and Carlsmith's (1959) result challenged learning theory.
What you will be able to do
- Describe cognitive dissonance and the drive to reduce it.
- Identify the inconsistent cognitions in a scenario and the strategy used to reduce the dissonance.
- Describe the procedure and results of Festinger & Carlsmith (1959).
- Explain how these findings challenged the predictions of learning theory.
A student believes that sleep matters for exam performance. It is 1 am, the night before an exam, and they are still scrolling their phone. If you have been that student, you know the uneasy feeling that comes with it, and you probably know the thoughts that follow: "one more video won't hurt", "I study better tired anyway". That uneasy feeling, and the effort to make it go away, is what cognitive dissonance theory explains.
Definition
Cognitive dissonance
Cognitive dissonance is the psychological discomfort a person feels when they hold two inconsistent cognitions (beliefs, attitudes, values or knowledge, including knowledge of their own behaviour), and which motivates them to reduce the inconsistency (Festinger 1957).
Leon Festinger proposed the theory in A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance (1957). Its three steps:
- Inconsistency. Two cognitions conflict, or a behaviour conflicts with an attitude. "Sleep matters before an exam" conflicts with "I am awake at 1 am".
- Discomfort. The inconsistency produces an unpleasant state of tension, dissonance, much like hunger or anxiety.
- A drive to reduce it. Because the state is unpleasant, the person is motivated to restore consistency, and the more dissonance, the stronger the drive.
Cognitive dissonance theory in four steps.
How big is the dissonance? It is greater when the cognitions involved are more important to the person, and when there are more dissonant cognitions compared with consonant (consistent) ones. Ignoring the speed limit on an empty road may cause little dissonance; doing something that clashes with a value at the centre of who you are causes a lot.
| Strategy | What the person does | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Change the behaviour | Act consistently with the attitude | Puts the phone away and goes to sleep. |
| Change a cognition | Change the attitude or belief so it fits the behaviour | "Sleep doesn't really affect how I do in exams." |
| Add consonant cognitions | Add new thoughts that justify the behaviour | "I'm winding down, which will help me sleep better later." |
| Reduce the importance | Trivialise the conflict | "It's only a practice exam, so it doesn't matter." |
Key idea
The easiest change wins
People usually reduce dissonance by changing whichever cognition is least resistant to change. Behaviour that has already happened cannot be undone, so after acting against an attitude, people very often change the attitude to fit what they did.
Sam believes that buying fast fashion harms the environment, but has just bought five cheap T-shirts online. Sam tells a friend, "One person's shopping makes no real difference to the planet." Which strategy is Sam using to reduce dissonance?
Worked example
Identify dissonance and how it is reduced
Noah is captain of his school's environment club and believes that flying is bad for the climate. His family has booked an overseas holiday by plane.
(a) Identify the two inconsistent cognitions. (b) Describe what cognitive dissonance theory predicts Noah will experience. (c) For each response, name the strategy Noah is using to reduce dissonance:
- "Planes fly whether I'm on them or not."
- "I'll plant 20 trees when we get back to make up for it."
- Noah asks to stay with his grandparents instead.
Step 1: (a) The two cognitions
"Flying is bad for the climate" (an attitude) and "I am going to fly overseas" (knowledge of his own behaviour). They are inconsistent.
Step 2: (b) The prediction
The inconsistency causes dissonance, an unpleasant psychological discomfort, and a drive to reduce it. Because the environment matters a lot to Noah (he is the club captain), the dissonance will be strong.
Step 3: (c1) "Planes fly whether I'm on them or not"
He keeps his belief but makes his own part seem unimportant: reducing the importance of the conflict.
Step 4: (c2) Planting trees
A new thought that justifies the behaviour: adding a consonant cognition.
Step 5: (c3) Staying with his grandparents
He brings his behaviour into line with his attitude: changing the behaviour.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) "Flying is bad for the climate" and "I am going to fly". (b) Psychological discomfort (dissonance), strong because the belief is important to him, and a drive to reduce it. (c) 1 reducing the importance; 2 adding a consonant cognition; 3 changing the behaviour.
Method
Name the attitude and the behaviour (or the two beliefs) that conflict.
State that the inconsistency causes discomfort and a drive to reduce it.
Match each response to a strategy: change behaviour, change a cognition, add consonant cognitions, reduce importance.
Watch out for
Calling response 1 "changing his attitude". He still believes flying is bad for the climate; he has only made his own part seem small.
Festinger & Carlsmith (1959). Festinger and his student James Carlsmith tested a surprising prediction of the theory: that a smaller reward for acting against your attitude produces more attitude change.
Male students at Stanford University spent an hour on deliberately boring tasks: loading spools onto a tray and emptying it, again and again, then turning square pegs on a board a quarter turn at a time. At the end, each was told the study was about how expectations affect performance. Participants in two conditions were then asked to help out by telling the next participant, who was waiting outside (in fact a confederate), that the tasks had been enjoyable and interesting. They were paid either $1 or $20 to do it. A control group did the tasks but were not asked to tell anyone anything. Afterwards, in what looked like an unrelated departmental survey, every participant rated how enjoyable the tasks had been, from (extremely dull) to (extremely enjoyable).
Before you read on, predict how each group rated the tasks. Did you predict what learning theory predicts, or what dissonance theory predicts?
| Condition | Mean enjoyment rating |
|---|---|
| Control (no lie) | −0.45 |
| Paid $1 to lie | +1.35 |
| Paid $20 to lie | −0.05 |
Which group rated the tasks as most enjoyable, and why does dissonance theory predict this?
Insufficient justification. The $20 participants had a good external reason for their behaviour: twenty dollars was a lot of money in 1959. The $1 participants did not. With too little justification, the only way to make "I told someone it was fun" fit with "it was boring" was to change the second cognition. The theory calls this insufficient justification: when the reward for acting against an attitude is too small to explain the behaviour, the attitude shifts towards the behaviour.
History
A challenge to learning theory
In the 1950s, behaviourist learning theory dominated psychology. Its principle of reinforcement (Unit 3, Topic 4) predicts that a bigger reward strengthens a response more. Applied here, the $20 group, rewarded more for saying the task was enjoyable, should have come to believe it most.
The result was the opposite: the smaller reward produced more attitude change. Festinger's theory explained it by a cognitive process inside the person, the drive to keep cognitions consistent, which a stimulus–response account could not. The study is one reason cognitive explanations of behaviour gained ground in the 1960s. It also shows how science works: a theory makes a prediction that conflicts with an established theory, and an experiment decides between them.
Worked example
Explain why $1 changed attitudes more than $20
In Festinger & Carlsmith (1959), students did an hour of boring tasks, then were paid either $1 or $20 to tell the next participant that the tasks were enjoyable. A control group told no one anything. All then rated how enjoyable the tasks were, from −5 to +5.
| Condition | Mean rating |
|---|---|
| Control | −0.45 |
| $1 | +1.35 |
| $20 | −0.05 |
(a) Describe the pattern in the results. (b) Explain the results using cognitive dissonance theory. (c) Explain how the results challenged the predictions of learning theory.
Step 1: (a) Describe the pattern
The $1 group rated the tasks as most enjoyable (+1.35), well above the control group (−0.45). The $20 group (−0.05) was close to the control group.
Step 2: (b) Identify the dissonance
Participants who told the next person the tasks were enjoyable held two inconsistent cognitions: "the tasks were boring" and "I told someone they were fun". This caused dissonance.
Step 3: (b) Explain the difference between $1 and $20
$20 was a large reward in 1959, enough external justification for the lie ("I did it for the money"), so little dissonance remained. $1 was insufficient justification, so the dissonance stayed. The behaviour could not be undone, so the $1 group changed the cognition easiest to change: they came to rate the tasks as more enjoyable.
People reduce dissonance by changing whichever cognition is least resistant to change.
Step 4: (c) Learning theory's prediction
Learning theory, through reinforcement, predicts that a larger reward strengthens a response more, so the $20 group should have come to believe the tasks were enjoyable most.
Step 5: (c) The challenge
The opposite happened: the smaller reward produced more attitude change. A cognitive process, the drive to reduce dissonance, explained the result where a stimulus–response account could not.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) $1 group most positive (+1.35); $20 group (−0.05) close to control (−0.45). (b) Lying caused dissonance; $20 justified it but $1 did not, so the $1 group reduced dissonance by changing their attitude to the tasks. (c) Reinforcement predicts more change with a bigger reward; the result was the reverse, supporting a cognitive explanation.
Method
Describe the data with the numbers.
Name the two inconsistent cognitions.
Explain justification (sufficient or insufficient) and which cognition changed.
State learning theory's prediction and show the data contradict it.
Watch out for
Saying the $20 group enjoyed it more because they were paid more: that is learning theory's prediction, and it was wrong.
Note
Ethics and evaluation
The study used deception twice: the cover story about expectations, and the confederate posing as the next participant. Participants were debriefed afterwards. Today an ethics committee would also ask whether paying people to lie to a peer was justified.
The sample was small (20 per condition) and narrow (male Stanford students), which limits how far the results generalise. Later studies have replicated the core effect many times, with different tasks and rewards, which strengthens confidence that it is reliable.
Common mistake
Bigger reward, bigger change? No
The most common error is to say the $20 group changed their attitude more. They did not: their rating (−0.05) was close to the control group's (−0.45). The $1 group (+1.35) changed most.
Summary
Cognitive dissonance is the discomfort of holding inconsistent cognitions, or acting against an attitude; it creates a drive to reduce the inconsistency (Festinger 1957).
Dissonance is reduced by changing the behaviour, changing a cognition, adding consonant cognitions or reducing the importance of the conflict.
In Festinger & Carlsmith (1959), participants paid $1 to call a boring task enjoyable later rated it more enjoyable (+1.35) than those paid $20 (−0.05) or the control group (−0.45).
Insufficient justification: a small reward cannot explain the behaviour, so the attitude changes to fit it.
Learning theory predicted that the larger reward would produce more attitude change; the result challenged it.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.