Lesson 6 of 9 · 14 min
Self-serving and confirmation bias
Describe the self-serving and confirmation biases, tell them apart from each other and from the fundamental attribution error, and explain how bias can have beneficial, harmful and unintended consequences.
What you will be able to do
- Describe the self-serving bias and explain its function.
- Describe confirmation bias.
- Distinguish the self-serving bias, confirmation bias and the fundamental attribution error in a scenario.
- Explain how a bias can have beneficial, harmful and unintended consequences on behaviour.
After a test, listen to how people explain their marks. "I studied really hard" comes from those who did well. "The questions were on stuff we never covered" comes from those who did not. Both groups sat the same test. The pattern is so common that it has a name, and it is one of two biases this lesson is about.
Definition
Self-serving bias
The self-serving bias is the tendency to attribute your own successes to dispositional factors (ability, effort) and your own failures to situational factors (bad luck, an unfair task, other people).
The self-serving bias protects and enhances self-esteem. Taking credit for success makes us feel capable; blaming the situation for failure stops the failure from counting against us. It also helps us present ourselves well to others. It is found in many settings: athletes explaining wins and losses, students explaining marks, managers explaining company results.
Notice how it differs from the fundamental attribution error. The FAE is about explaining other people's behaviour (too much disposition). The self-serving bias is about explaining your own outcomes, and which way it goes depends on whether the outcome was good or bad.
Which statement shows the self-serving bias?
Definition
Confirmation bias
Confirmation bias is the tendency to seek out, interpret, favour and remember information that supports what you already believe, and to overlook or discount information that contradicts it.
The 2-4-6 task. Peter Wason (1960) told participants that the three numbers 2, 4, 6 follow a rule, and asked them to find the rule by proposing other sets of three numbers. After each set, the experimenter said whether it fitted. Most people formed a hypothesis such as "even numbers going up by two" and then tested sets that fitted it: 8, 10, 12; 20, 22, 24. Every one was confirmed, so they announced their rule with confidence, and were wrong. The rule was simply "any three numbers in ascending order". Few people tried a set that could disprove their idea, such as 1, 7, 50.
Confirmation bias works at every step of handling information:
- Seeking: choosing news sources, search terms or friends who agree with you.
- Interpreting: reading an ambiguous event as support ("she didn't reply, so she must be annoyed").
- Remembering: recalling the hits and forgetting the misses (the times a "lucky" shirt worked).
Classify the bias in each scenario.
For each scenario, decide whether it shows the fundamental attribution error, the self-serving bias or confirmation bias.
Worked example
Identify a bias and its consequences
Kai, a Year 12 student, does well on his English essay and says it was because he planned carefully. He does poorly on a maths test and says the teacher set questions that were too hard. Before the next maths test, he spends his study time on English.
(a) Identify the bias and explain how the scenario shows it. (b) Describe one beneficial, one harmful and one unintended consequence of this bias for Kai.
Step 1: (a) Identify the bias
Success (essay) is attributed to a dispositional factor (careful planning); failure (maths) to a situational one (hard questions). This is the self-serving bias.
Step 2: (b) A beneficial consequence
Blaming the test protects Kai's self-esteem and mood after a poor result, so he stays confident.
Step 3: (b) A harmful consequence
Because he does not see his own preparation as the cause, he does not change how he studies maths, so he does not learn from the failure and is likely to do poorly again.
Step 4: (b) An unintended consequence
By moving his study time to English, the subject that makes him feel capable, he unintentionally widens the gap between his subjects, which could lower his overall results.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Self-serving bias: success put down to his planning (dispositional), failure to the test (situational). (b) Beneficial: protects his self-esteem. Harmful: he does not change how he prepares for maths, so he does not improve. Unintended: shifting study to English widens the gap between his subjects.
Method
Check whose outcome is being explained and which way: own success → dispositional, own failure → situational means self-serving bias.
Beneficial: how it helps the person (self-esteem, motivation).
Harmful: what it costs (no learning, blame).
Unintended: an effect nobody meant to cause.
Watch out for
Calling it confirmation bias. Kai is explaining his own outcomes, not selecting information to fit a belief.
Consequences of bias. A bias is a systematic tendency, not a mistake made on purpose, and it can have beneficial, harmful and unintended consequences on behaviour, often all at once.
| Bias | Beneficial | Harmful | Unintended |
|---|---|---|---|
| Self-serving | Protects self-esteem and mood after failure; keeps people motivated to try again. | Stops people learning from mistakes; shifts blame onto others, which damages teams and relationships. | A student who always blames the test may never change the way they study, and keeps getting the same result. |
| Confirmation | Saves time and effort; keeps beliefs stable so decisions are quick. | Keeps false beliefs and stereotypes alive; can lead to wrong medical diagnoses or police focusing on the wrong suspect. | Online feeds that learn what a person clicks show them more of the same, deepening a belief they never meant to strengthen. |
A researcher expects a new reading program to work. When scoring students' written answers, which can be marked in more than one way, she gives the benefit of the doubt more often to students in the program group. Which bias is this, and what is its consequence for the research?
Tip
Reducing bias
You cannot simply decide not to be biased, but procedures help. Research uses double-blind procedures so that expectations cannot affect scoring. Individuals can deliberately look for evidence that would disprove a belief (try 1, 7, 50), ask "what situation might explain this?" before blaming someone, and ask a friend for an honest account of why a failure happened.
Common mistake
Three biases, three questions
- Is the person explaining their own success or failure? → self-serving bias.
- Is the person explaining someone else's behaviour by a trait and ignoring the situation? → fundamental attribution error.
- Is the person seeking, interpreting or remembering information to fit a belief they already hold? → confirmation bias.
Summary
Self-serving bias: own successes to dispositional factors, own failures to situational factors; it protects self-esteem.
Confirmation bias: seeking, interpreting, favouring and remembering information that supports an existing belief.
Wason's 2-4-6 task: people test cases that confirm their hypothesis, not ones that could disprove it.
Bias can be beneficial (self-esteem, quick decisions), harmful (no learning from mistakes, false beliefs kept) and unintended (biased research scoring, narrowing news feeds).
Double-blind procedures and actively looking for disconfirming evidence reduce the effect of bias.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.