Lesson 5 of 9 · 16 min
Attributions and the fundamental attribution error
Describe attributions, classify explanations of behaviour as situational or dispositional, recognise the fundamental attribution error, and explain how Ross et al. (1977) showed it.
What you will be able to do
- Describe what an attribution is.
- Classify an explanation of behaviour as situational or dispositional.
- Describe and recognise the fundamental attribution error.
- Describe Ross, Amabile & Steinmetz (1977) and explain how attributions shape our responses to others.
A car cuts in front of you on the highway. In the half-second before you brake, you have already decided why: what an inconsiderate driver. It might be true. Or the driver might have just missed seeing you, or be rushing to a hospital. Whichever explanation you land on decides what you do next: sound the horn, or let it go. Explanations like this are attributions.
Definition
Attribution
An attribution is an explanation of the cause of a person's behaviour, your own or someone else's. Fritz Heider (1958) described people as "naive scientists" who are constantly working out why others act as they do, so that the social world seems predictable.
Dispositional attribution
The cause is inside the person: their personality, ability, effort, mood, attitudes or intentions. Also called an internal attribution.
"She failed the test because she is lazy."
"He donated because he is generous."
Situational attribution
The cause is outside the person: the task, other people, the setting, social pressure, luck or time. Also called an external attribution.
"She failed the test because the questions were on work she had missed while sick."
"He donated because everyone at the table was watching."
Sort each explanation of the same behaviour into situational or dispositional. Notice how different each explanation would make you feel about the person.
Classify each explanation of why Lachlan arrived late to his part-time job.
Attributions shape responses. The attribution you make changes how you treat the person. If a teacher attributes a student's lateness to laziness (dispositional), detention seems fair. If the teacher attributes it to a bus timetable change (situational), the fair response is to help the student find another way to school. The same behaviour can lead to blame or to help, depending only on the explanation chosen.
One behaviour, two attributions, two responses.
Key idea
The fundamental attribution error (FAE)
When we explain other people's behaviour, we tend to overestimate dispositional causes and underestimate situational causes. Lee Ross (1977) named this the fundamental attribution error.
One reason is attention: when we watch someone act, the person is what we see, while the situation (their history, the pressures on them) is often invisible. Judging disposition is also quick and easy, while thinking through the situation takes effort.
Which of these is the clearest example of the fundamental attribution error?
Worked example
Classify attributions and spot the FAE
Mr Tran's Year 12 student, Isla, scored 42% on a chemistry test. Four people explain why.
- Mr Tran: "Isla just isn't very good at chemistry."
- Isla's friend: "She was looking after her younger brother all week while her mum was in hospital."
- Isla's classmate: "She's lazy; she never studies."
- Isla's tutor: "The test covered the two lessons she missed while she was at the regional athletics."
(a) Classify each explanation as situational or dispositional. (b) Mr Tran and the classmate did not know about the week at home or the missed lessons. Explain which explanations could show the fundamental attribution error.
Step 1: (a) Classify each explanation
1 ability, inside Isla: dispositional. 2 caring for her brother, outside her: situational. 3 laziness, a trait: dispositional. 4 missed lessons, outside her: situational.
Step 2: (b) Recall the FAE
The FAE is overestimating dispositional and underestimating situational causes of another person's behaviour.
Step 3: (b) Apply it
Mr Tran and the classmate explain Isla's result by her traits (ability, laziness), while real situational causes (a week as a carer, missed lessons) went unnoticed. Explanations 1 and 3 could show the FAE.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) 1 dispositional, 2 situational, 3 dispositional, 4 situational. (b) Explanations 1 and 3: they explain another person's behaviour by her dispositions while overlooking situational causes, which is the fundamental attribution error.
Method
Inside the person (ability, effort, personality, attitude) → dispositional.
Outside the person (task, events, other people, luck) → situational.
FAE: a dispositional explanation of someone else that ignores a situational cause.
Watch out for
Saying explanation 2 is the FAE. The FAE is the error of ignoring the situation, not of noticing it.
Ross, Amabile & Steinmetz (1977): the quizmaster study. Pairs of Stanford University students took part in a quiz game. In each pair, one was made the questioner and the other the contestant, by drawing cards in front of both of them, so both knew the roles were decided by chance. The questioner wrote ten challenging but answerable general knowledge questions from their own areas of knowledge (for example, a hobby or a book they had read), and the contestant tried to answer them aloud. Many of the questions stumped the contestants.
Afterwards, both rated the general knowledge of the questioner and of the contestant. Contestants rated the questioners as more knowledgeable than themselves, and so, in a second experiment, did observers who watched the game. The bias was much weaker in the questioners themselves.
Key idea
Why the quizmaster study shows the FAE
The questioner had a huge situational advantage: they chose questions from their own knowledge, so they could look clever and the contestant could not. Both participants knew the roles were random. Yet contestants and observers explained the questioner's apparent brilliance by a disposition (being knowledgeable) and failed to allow for the situation, the role itself. The questioners, who knew how carefully they had picked the questions, were much less fooled.
Worked example
Explain the quizmaster study with the FAE
In Ross, Amabile & Steinmetz (1977), pairs of students were randomly assigned, in front of each other, to be the questioner or the contestant in a quiz. Questioners wrote ten difficult questions from their own knowledge. Afterwards, contestants rated the questioners' general knowledge as much higher than their own.
(a) Explain the contestants' ratings using the fundamental attribution error. (b) Explain how this kind of attribution could influence how people respond to others in everyday life.
Step 1: (a) Identify the situational cause
The questioner's role gave a large advantage: they chose questions from their own areas of knowledge, which the contestant was unlikely to know. The roles were decided by chance, and both knew it.
Step 2: (a) Identify the dispositional attribution
Contestants explained the questioners' apparent brilliance by a disposition: being more knowledgeable.
Step 3: (a) Name the error
They underestimated the situational cause (the role) and overestimated the dispositional one (knowledge). That is the fundamental attribution error.
Step 4: (b) Link attributions to responses
We respond to people according to the cause we attribute. Someone who seems knowledgeable only because of their role (a host, an interviewer, a teacher setting questions) may be trusted, promoted or deferred to more than they deserve, while a person put on the spot may be judged less capable than they are.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Contestants attributed the questioners' performance to greater knowledge (dispositional) and failed to allow for the advantage of the randomly assigned role (situational): the fundamental attribution error. (b) Because attributions shape responses, people in advantaged roles may be judged more capable and treated with more respect, and people at a disadvantage judged less capable, than they deserve.
Method
Identify the situational factor that explains the behaviour.
Identify the dispositional explanation that was made instead.
Name the FAE and link the attribution to how people respond.
Watch out for
Saying the questioners really were more knowledgeable. The roles were random, so the two groups did not differ in knowledge on average.
Note
Attributions and how we treat people
Ross et al. (1977) shows that attributions influence how we interpret other people's behaviour, and so how we respond to them. The same error appears in classrooms, workplaces and courts: the person who speaks confidently in a meeting may be judged more capable than one who was given less time to prepare, and a person who is struggling may be judged as lacking effort when their situation is the cause. Asking "what about the situation might explain this?" before judging is a simple way to reduce the error.
Common mistake
Situational does not mean "the situation was bad"
A situational attribution can explain good behaviour too: "he helped because his boss was watching" is situational. Classify by where the cause is (in the person or outside them), not by whether the outcome was good or bad.
Exam tip
Classifying attributions
Quote the part of the scenario that names the cause, say whether it lies inside the person or outside them, and name the attribution. For the FAE, say whose behaviour is being explained (someone else's) and which situational cause has been overlooked.
Summary
An attribution is an explanation of the cause of behaviour.
Dispositional (internal): the cause is in the person, such as personality, ability, effort or attitude.
Situational (external): the cause is outside the person, such as the task, other people, luck or social pressure.
The fundamental attribution error: overestimating dispositional and underestimating situational causes of other people's behaviour.
Ross et al. (1977): contestants and observers judged randomly chosen questioners as more knowledgeable, ignoring the advantage the questioner's role gave them.
Attributions shape how we respond to people: blame for a dispositional cause, help or allowance for a situational one.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.