Lesson 2 of 9 · 12 min
Implicit and explicit attitudes
Describe explicit attitudes, which we can report, and implicit attitudes, which work automatically, say how each is measured and explain why the two can differ.
What you will be able to do
- Describe explicit and implicit attitudes.
- Identify whether a measure assesses an explicit or an implicit attitude.
- Explain why a person's implicit and explicit attitudes to the same object can differ.
If someone asks how you feel about spiders, you can stop, think and answer. That considered answer reports an explicit attitude. But before you have had time to think, a spider dropping onto your desk produces an instant reaction: a jolt, a pulling back. Fast, automatic evaluations like that are implicit attitudes, and they do not always say the same thing as the considered answer.
Explicit attitudes
- Held consciously: you know you have them.
- Formed and used deliberately, with time to think.
- You can report them, so they are measured directly by self-report: questionnaires, interviews, rating scales.
- Can change quickly, for example after a persuasive argument.
- Best at predicting deliberate behaviour, such as which product you choose after comparing them.
Implicit attitudes
- Automatic: activated without effort or intention.
- May operate outside awareness: a person may not know they hold them.
- Cannot be reported reliably, so they are measured indirectly, usually from reaction times.
- Built up slowly over long experience, so slower to change.
- Better at predicting spontaneous behaviour, such as body language, eye contact or how close you sit.
Definition
Two kinds of attitude
An explicit attitude is an attitude a person is aware of and can deliberately report. An implicit attitude is an automatic evaluation that operates without deliberate thought and may be outside the person's awareness.
Measuring explicit attitudes. Self-report measures ask directly. A Likert scale asks how much you agree with a statement, from strongly disagree (1) to strongly agree (5). A semantic differential asks you to place the attitude object between two opposite adjectives, such as good and bad, on a seven-point scale. These are quick and easy to score, but they only capture what people are willing and able to say.
Measuring implicit attitudes. Indirect measures do not ask about the attitude at all. The best known is the Implicit Association Test (IAT; Greenwald, McGhee & Schwartz 1998). Words or pictures appear one at a time, and you sort them as fast as you can with two keys. In one block, flower words and pleasant words share a key and insect words and unpleasant words share the other. In another block the pairings swap: flower with unpleasant, insect with pleasant. People who implicitly prefer flowers sort faster when flowers share a key with pleasant words. The difference in reaction time is the measure of the implicit attitude.
Mean time to sort each word in the two blocks of a flower–insect IAT. (Illustrative data, in the pattern Greenwald et al. 1998 reported.)
In the graph, sorting was faster when flower shared a key with pleasant. What does this suggest?
Why the two can differ. A person's explicit and implicit attitudes to the same object can point in different directions, for several reasons.
- Social desirability. People may report the attitude they think they should hold, especially on sensitive topics, while their automatic reaction says otherwise.
- Lack of awareness. An implicit attitude may be outside awareness, so the person cannot report it even when they are trying to be honest.
- Different histories. Implicit attitudes build up slowly from years of experience and exposure (including the media); explicit attitudes can be revised quickly by a single argument or a new value. Someone who has deliberately changed their view may keep their old automatic reaction for a long time.
Worked example
Explain a gap between implicit and explicit attitudes
A researcher measures 40 students' attitudes to healthy snacks in two ways.
- Measure 1: students rate the statement "Fruit is a better snack than chips" from 1 (strongly disagree) to 7 (strongly agree). The mean rating is 6.1.
- Measure 2: a reaction-time task in which students sort pictures of fruit and chips together with pleasant and unpleasant words. On average, students sort faster when chips shares a key with pleasant than when fruit does.
(a) Identify which measure assesses an explicit attitude and which an implicit attitude. (b) Explain why the two measures could disagree. (c) Predict which measure would better predict the snack students grab when they are rushed between classes, and explain.
Step 1: (a) Classify the measures
Measure 1 asks students to report their view: a direct, self-report measure of an explicit attitude. Measure 2 infers the attitude from reaction times, without asking about it: an indirect measure of an implicit attitude.
Step 2: (b) Explain the disagreement
Students may report the attitude they think they should hold (social desirability), since "fruit is better" is the expected answer. Their automatic association, built up over years of enjoying chips and seeing them advertised, may still favour chips, and they may not be aware of it.
Implicit attitudes form slowly from long experience and can be outside awareness; explicit attitudes reflect what a person deliberately endorses.
Step 3: (c) Predict spontaneous behaviour
Grabbing a snack while rushed is quick and spontaneous, with little time to think. Implicit attitudes predict spontaneous behaviour better, so measure 2 should predict it better: many students may grab chips.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Measure 1 explicit; measure 2 implicit. (b) Social desirability may inflate the self-report, and an automatic preference built from experience can persist outside awareness. (c) The reaction-time measure, because grabbing a snack in a rush is spontaneous behaviour, which implicit attitudes predict better.
Method
Direct self-report → explicit; indirect (reaction times, spontaneous behaviour) → implicit.
Explain a gap by social desirability, lack of awareness or different histories.
Deliberate behaviour → explicit predicts better; spontaneous behaviour → implicit predicts better.
Watch out for
Saying the students are lying. Their explicit attitude can be sincere while their implicit attitude differs.
Sort each measure or example into explicit or implicit. Ask: does the person report the attitude, or is it inferred from what they do automatically?
Classify each measure as assessing an explicit or an implicit attitude.
Note
How good are implicit measures?
The IAT is widely used in research, but its reliability is modest: the same person can get noticeably different scores on two occasions, and researchers still debate how well an individual's score predicts their behaviour. It is better at describing average differences between groups of people than at saying anything about one person. That is why an online IAT score is not a diagnosis of anyone's attitudes.
Common mistake
Implicit does not mean hidden on purpose
An explicit attitude that a person chooses not to reveal is still explicit: they know they hold it. An implicit attitude is defined by being automatic and possibly outside awareness, not by being kept secret.
Exam tip
Describing implicit and explicit attitudes
Give one feature of each that contrasts with the other (conscious and deliberate against automatic and possibly unconscious), say how each is measured (directly by self-report against indirectly by reaction times), and give an example of a measure for each.
Summary
Explicit attitudes are conscious and deliberate, and are measured directly by self-report (Likert scales, semantic differentials, interviews).
Implicit attitudes are automatic and may be outside awareness, and are measured indirectly, for example by reaction times in the IAT.
They can differ because of social desirability, lack of awareness, and because implicit attitudes change more slowly.
Explicit attitudes predict deliberate behaviour better; implicit attitudes predict spontaneous behaviour better.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.