Lesson 4 of 9 · 14 min
Social identity theory
Explain social identity theory through social categorisation, social identification and social comparison, and use it to explain in-group favouritism and the minimal group studies.
What you will be able to do
- Define social identity, in-groups and out-groups.
- Explain social categorisation, social identification and social comparison, in that order.
- Apply social identity theory to explain in-group favouritism in a new scenario.
- Describe the minimal group studies and what they show.
On State of Origin night, people who would never speak to each other on the train are suddenly on the same side, and people who sit together at work all year are suddenly rivals. Nothing about the people has changed, only which group they feel part of. Social identity theory explains how belonging to a group changes the way we think about ourselves and about other people.
Definition
Social identity
Your social identity is the part of your self-concept that comes from the groups you belong to: your school, your family, your sports team, your cultural group, your year level. An in-group is a group you belong to and identify with; an out-group is one you do not belong to.
Social identity theory was developed by Henri Tajfel and John Turner (1979). Its central idea is that people want a positive self-concept, and because part of who we are comes from our groups, we are motivated to see our groups positively. The theory describes three processes that happen one after the other.
The three processes of social identity theory.
The three processes
Social categorisation
We sort people, ourselves included, into social groups on the basis of shared characteristics, such as school, team, age or occupation. Categorising simplifies a complicated social world, and it also tells us which groups we belong to. It tends to exaggerate the differences between groups and the similarities within them.
Social identification
We take on the identity of the groups we have categorised ourselves into. We adopt their norms, values and ways of behaving (wearing the colours, using the chants), and our self-esteem becomes tied to the group: when the group does well, we feel good about ourselves.
Social comparison
Once our self-esteem is bound up with the group, we compare our in-group with out-groups. To keep our self-esteem high, we tend to make comparisons that favour our own group (positive distinctiveness): our school is friendlier, our team plays fairer. This produces in-group favouritism, and when groups compete, it can lead to hostility and prejudice towards out-groups.
Follow a person who joins a group, and sort what they think and do into the three processes. Then try the other scenarios.
Mia has just started at Ridgeview High. Classify each moment as social categorisation, social identification or social comparison.
Minimal groups. How little does it take to make people favour their own group? Tajfel and colleagues (Tajfel 1970) found out with schoolboys aged 14 and 15 in Bristol, England. In one study, the boys were shown paintings by two artists, Paul Klee and Wassily Kandinsky, and told they had been put into a "Klee group" or a "Kandinsky group" according to which they preferred (in fact, the allocation was random). Each boy then worked alone in a cubicle, dividing points worth money between two other boys, known only by a code number and their group. They never met their group, never competed with the other group, and gained nothing themselves from their choices.
Even so, the boys consistently gave more to members of their own group. Strikingly, many chose options that maximised the difference between the groups, even when another option would have given their own group more in total. Tajfel called these minimal groups: groups with no history, no contact and no conflict, formed on a trivial basis.
Key idea
What the minimal group studies show
Simply being categorised into a group is enough to produce in-group favouritism. Competition over resources is not needed, which is why social identity theory explains favouritism by self-esteem and identity rather than by conflict.
Why did the boys in Tajfel's minimal group studies favour their in-group?
Evaluating the theory. Social identity theory explains a wide range of everyday behaviour, from sports rivalries to school pride, and it is supported by the minimal group studies, which have been repeated many times in different countries. It also has limits. The minimal group studies are artificial: allocating points to strangers is not the same as real conflict between groups with histories, so their ecological validity is limited. And the theory does not predict well when comparison turns into hostility rather than friendly rivalry; that depends on context, such as whether groups compete for scarce resources and whether their status differences seem fair.
Common mistake
Getting the order wrong
The three processes have an order: you have to categorise before you can identify with a group, and you have to identify with it before comparison matters to your self-esteem. In an "explain" answer, use all three terms in that order and link the last to self-esteem.
Exam tip
Explaining social identity theory
A full answer defines each of the three processes, applies each to the scenario in the question (quote it), and ends with the consequence: a positive social identity raises self-esteem, and in-group favouritism (and possibly prejudice) follows from favourable comparisons.
Summary
Social identity is the part of the self-concept that comes from group memberships (Tajfel & Turner 1979).
Social categorisation: sorting people, including yourself, into groups.
Social identification: adopting the group's identity and norms, so self-esteem is tied to the group.
Social comparison: comparing the in-group favourably with out-groups to keep self-esteem high, which produces in-group favouritism.
Minimal group studies (Tajfel 1970): categorisation on a trivial basis is enough for in-group favouritism, without competition.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.