Lesson 8 of 9 · 14 min

How prejudice forms

Describe four routes by which prejudice forms (scapegoating, direct experience and personal prejudice, group prejudice and the prejudiced personality) and identify each in a scenario.

What you will be able to do

  • Describe scapegoating and explain why the target is usually a less powerful group.
  • Describe how direct experience can lead to personal prejudice.
  • Describe group prejudice as conformity to the norms of a group.
  • Describe the prejudiced (authoritarian) personality and evaluate it as an explanation.
  • Identify the route by which prejudice has formed in a scenario.

Nobody is born prejudiced. Prejudice is an attitude, and like every attitude it is learned. The syllabus names four routes by which it can form. One begins with frustration, one with a single bad experience, one with the wish to belong, and one with a type of personality. In real life, a person's prejudice usually comes from more than one route at once.

Definition

Scapegoating

Scapegoating is blaming an innocent, usually less powerful group for problems or frustrations that it did not cause.

Scapegoating grows out of frustration. When people are frustrated (by unemployment, rising prices, a lost game), they may feel aggression. The real cause is often powerful, vague or out of reach: the economy, a government, bad luck. So the hostility is displaced onto a target that is visible, easy to blame and unable to fight back: a minority or less powerful group. Blaming the group gives the frustration an outlet and a simple explanation, and it often draws on stereotypes that already exist.

History has many examples of minority groups being blamed for economic hard times they did not cause. Scapegoating is most likely when times are hard: the economic context from the last lesson.

Definition

Direct experience and personal prejudice

Direct experience: a prejudice formed from a person's own experience with one or a few members of a group, usually a negative one, which is then generalised to the whole group.

Personal prejudice: prejudice a person holds for their own reasons, because of their own experience or because they see members of the group as a threat to their own interests (their job, their status, their safety), rather than because their group holds it.

Suppose a student is pushed over at a skate park by two teenagers wearing Harlow Bay Rovers jerseys, and from then on distrusts every Rovers supporter. One unpleasant experience with two people has become an attitude towards thousands. The generalisation is a stereotype doing its usual work: ignoring how much individuals in a group differ. Because the experience was the person's own, the prejudice that results is personal, and it is often strong, since it is tied to a vivid memory.

Definition

Group prejudice

Group prejudice is prejudice acquired by adopting the attitudes and norms of a group a person belongs to or wants to belong to, such as their family, friends or workplace.

Group prejudice is conformity (Unit 4, Topic 1) applied to attitudes. A new member of a friendship group who hears constant jokes about students from a rival school starts repeating them, and in time comes to believe them, without ever having met anyone from that school. The person may hold the prejudice to be accepted, to avoid being left out, or simply because the group is the only source of information they have about the out-group. Children learn many prejudices this way from parents, through observational learning (Unit 3, Topic 4), well before they have any experience of their own.

Hamish has never met anyone from Westbrook, but his whole family describes Westbrook people as "snobs", so Hamish does too. Which route best explains how his prejudice formed?

Choose one answer

Definition

The prejudiced personality

The prejudiced personality is a set of personality traits thought to make a person prone to prejudice against many out-groups. The best known account is the authoritarian personality described by Adorno, Frenkel-Brunswik, Levinson and Sanford (1950).

Adorno and colleagues, writing after the Second World War, wanted to know why some people seemed ready to accept prejudice against any out-group. From questionnaires and interviews they described the authoritarian personality:

  • rigid thinking and intolerance of ambiguity: seeing the world in black and white
  • strong attachment to conventional values
  • submission to authority figures, and hostility towards people who break convention
  • prejudice against many out-groups at once, not just one.

They traced it to a strict, harsh upbringing, with conditional affection and severe punishment. The child cannot express hostility towards the powerful parents, so it is displaced onto weaker out-groups, much as in scapegoating. They measured it with the F-scale (F for fascism), on which people rated agreement with statements about obedience, discipline and convention.

Note

Evaluating the prejudiced personality

  • Strengths. It explains why some people are prejudiced against many groups at once, and why prejudice can be intense in some individuals and not others in the same setting.
  • Limitations. Every F-scale item was worded so that agreeing scored as authoritarian, so people who tend to agree with any statement (acquiescence) scored high: a threat to the validity of the measure. The evidence was largely correlational, so it cannot show that harsh parenting caused the personality. And a personality explanation cannot explain why prejudice across a whole society can rise or fall within a few years, far faster than personalities change; social norms and economic conditions explain that better.
Four routes to prejudice
RouteWhere the prejudice comes fromKey word to look for
ScapegoatingFrustration displaced onto an innocent, less powerful groupBlaming a group for a problem it did not cause
Direct experience and personal prejudiceThe person's own experience with a few members, generalised; or a perceived threat to their own interestsOne bad experience, now applied to everyone
Group prejudiceConforming to the norms of a family, friendship or work groupAdopting what others in the group think
Prejudiced personalityPersonality traits (the authoritarian personality) from a harsh upbringingRigid, conventional, deferential, prejudiced towards many groups

Identify the route by which each prejudice formed.

Interactive

Trace how a prejudice formed

Read each scenario and decide which route formed the prejudice: scapegoating, direct experience, group prejudice or the prejudiced personality.

Worked example

Explain how a prejudice formed

  • Complex familiar

In the fictional town of Morrow, a drought has left many farmers in debt. Some residents start saying that the drought relief money is being "wasted" on people who moved to Morrow from the coast in the last few years, though the newcomers receive none of it. Liam, aged 15, has never spoken to any of the newcomers, but his friends at the skate park joke about them constantly, and he joins in.

Identify and explain two routes by which prejudice towards the newcomers has formed.

3 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Look for a frustration displaced onto an innocent group (scapegoating).

  2. Look for a personal experience generalised to a group (direct experience).

  3. Look for an attitude adopted from a group (group prejudice).

  4. Look for traits such as rigidity and deference to authority (prejudiced personality).

Watch out for

  • Calling Liam's prejudice direct experience. He has never met a newcomer; his prejudice comes from his group.

Common mistake

Scapegoat or personal experience?

Scapegoating needs a frustration whose real cause lies elsewhere and an innocent target. If the person had a bad experience with members of the group themselves, the route is direct experience, even if they are angry.

Exam tip

Describing a route

Name the route, define it, and apply it: say which detail in the scenario matches the definition (the frustration and the innocent target; the single experience and the generalisation; the group norm and the wish to belong; the personality traits). One sentence on how the prejudice is learned earns the "describe" marks.

Summary

  • Scapegoating: frustration displaced onto an innocent, less powerful group, most likely in hard economic times.

  • Direct experience and personal prejudice: one's own experience with a few members, generalised to the group, or a perceived threat to one's own interests.

  • Group prejudice: conforming to the attitudes and norms of a group one belongs to or wants to join.

  • Prejudiced personality: the authoritarian personality (Adorno et al. 1950): rigid, conventional, submissive to authority, hostile to many out-groups, traced to a harsh upbringing; measured by the F-scale, which has validity problems.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 8 of 90% read

Save your progress with a free account