Lesson 1 of 9 · 16 min
The two-factor and appraisal theories of emotion
Explain how Schachter & Singer's two-factor theory and Lazarus's appraisal theory account for an emotion, and compare them by applying both to the same event.
What you will be able to do
- Describe an emotion as a feeling, physiological arousal and behaviour.
- Explain the two-factor theory and the Schachter & Singer (1962) experiment that tested it.
- Explain the appraisal theory, with primary and secondary appraisal.
- Compare the two theories by applying both to a new situation.
You are backstage, about to give a speech to the whole year level. Your heart pounds, your palms sweat and your mouth is dry. A friend beside you, waiting to go on too, says they can't wait. Same situation, same pounding heart, different emotion. Why?
An emotion has three parts: a subjective feeling (fear, excitement), physiological arousal (heart rate, breathing, sweating) and behaviour (a facial expression, running, freezing). Theories of emotion disagree about how these fit together, and especially about where thinking comes in. This lesson compares two theories that both give thinking the decisive role, but put it at different points.
Definition
The two-factor theory
The two-factor theory of Schachter & Singer (1962) says an emotion needs two things: physiological arousal and a cognitive label that explains it. Arousal on its own is much the same for many emotions; the label, taken from cues in the situation, decides which emotion you feel.
The two-factor theory: arousal first, then a label from the situation.
Testing it. Schachter & Singer told 184 male university students they were testing a vitamin, "Suproxin", on vision. Most were injected with adrenaline (epinephrine), which raises heart rate and causes trembling and flushing; a placebo group got a saline injection, which does nothing. The adrenaline groups were told different things about side effects:
- informed: told the true effects (pounding heart, shaking hands, a warm face)
- ignorant: told nothing
- misinformed: told false effects (numb feet, itching, a headache)
Each participant then waited with a confederate, an actor posing as another participant, who behaved either euphorically (flying paper planes, shooting screwed-up paper at a bin) or angrily (complaining about an insulting questionnaire both had to fill in). Observers rated the participant's behaviour through a one-way mirror, and the participant rated their own mood.
Results. Participants who were aroused but had no explanation for it (ignorant and misinformed) caught the confederate's mood more: more euphoric with the euphoric confederate, angrier with the angry one. The informed participants already had a label ("it's the injection"), so they were least affected. Schachter & Singer concluded that unexplained arousal is labelled from the situation, and the label decides the emotion.
In Schachter & Singer's (1962) experiment, why did the informed participants show the least euphoria with the euphoric confederate?
Common mistake
The ethics and the evidence
The experiment deceived participants about the drug and the study's aim, injected them without true informed consent, and insulted them with the questionnaire in the anger condition. Its results were also weaker than often told: several differences were small or not significant, and later replications (Marshall & Zimbardo 1979; Maslach 1979) found unexplained arousal tended to feel unpleasant whatever the confederate did. Mention both kinds of problem when you evaluate it.
Definition
The appraisal theory
The appraisal theory of Lazarus (1982) says an emotion follows from cognitive appraisal: your evaluation of what an event means for your wellbeing. Appraisal comes first, and the emotion and its arousal follow from it. Two people who appraise the same event differently feel different emotions.
| Appraisal | Question you ask | Possible judgements |
|---|---|---|
| Primary appraisal | Does this matter to me, and how? | Irrelevant; benign-positive; stressful, as harm or loss (damage already done), threat (harm expected) or challenge (a chance to gain or grow) |
| Secondary appraisal | What can I do about it? | Your coping options and resources: skills, time, support, control over the outcome |
| Reappraisal | Has anything changed? | New information changes the appraisal, and so the emotion |
The appraisal theory: appraisal first, then the emotion with its arousal.
Change the cues in the two-factor view, then the appraisals in the other. What changes the emotion in each?
Evidence for appraisal. Speisman, Lazarus and colleagues (1964) showed students a distressing film of a painful initiation ceremony with one of several soundtracks. A soundtrack that stressed the pain gave the highest arousal (skin conductance and heart rate); soundtracks that denied the pain or described it in a detached, academic way gave less. The film was the same; how it was appraised changed the arousal. That is what the appraisal theory predicts: appraisal comes before the arousal and shapes it.
Jaz notices her heart racing after three coffees. She is at a party where everyone is laughing, and decides she must be having a great time. Which theory fits this best, and why?
Two-factor theory
- Order: stimulus → arousal → cognitive label → emotion.
- Arousal is general: much the same for fear, anger and joy.
- Cognition explains arousal that is already there, from cues in the situation.
- Evidence: Schachter & Singer (1962), adrenaline and a confederate.
- Problems: deception and harm; weak, poorly replicated results.
Appraisal theory
- Order: stimulus → appraisal (primary, secondary) → emotion and arousal.
- Each emotion comes from a different pattern of appraisal (threat → fear, loss → sadness).
- Cognition evaluates the event for its meaning to you, and causes the arousal.
- Evidence: Speisman et al. (1964), the same film with different soundtracks.
- Problems: appraisal is hard to measure except by self-report; very fast emotions (a sudden noise) seem to come before deliberate thought.
Key idea
How to compare
Similarity: both are cognitive theories; both say thinking decides which emotion you feel, so two people in one situation can feel different emotions.
Differences: the order (two-factor: arousal then cognition; appraisal: cognition then arousal); what the cognition is about (two-factor: explaining your arousal from situational cues; appraisal: the event's meaning for your wellbeing and your ability to cope); and arousal (general in two-factor; part of the emotion that the appraisal produces in appraisal theory).
Worked example
Compare the two-factor and appraisal theories for a near miss
Sam is riding his bike when a car pulls out in front of him and he brakes hard, just missing it. A second later he is shaking, his heart is pounding, and he sees the driver laughing. Sam feels furious.
Compare how the two-factor theory (Schachter & Singer 1962) and the appraisal theory (Lazarus 1982) explain Sam's anger. (5 marks)
Step 1: Apply the two-factor theory to Sam
The near miss produces physiological arousal first: shaking and a pounding heart. Sam looks to the situation to explain it; the laughing driver is the cue, so he labels his arousal as anger.
Use the theory's terms (arousal, cognitive label, situational cue) and point to the detail in the scenario that fits each.
Step 2: Apply the appraisal theory to Sam
Sam's primary appraisal judges the event as harm to his wellbeing (he was nearly hit, and the driver is mocking him); his secondary appraisal judges he can do something (confront the driver). This pattern of appraisal (another person to blame for a harm) produces anger, and the anger comes with arousal.
Step 3: State a similarity
Both theories say cognition decides which emotion Sam feels: without thinking about the situation, his arousal would not be anger in particular.
Step 4: State the differences
In the two-factor theory the arousal comes first and the cognition labels it; in the appraisal theory the appraisal comes first and the arousal follows from it. The two-factor cognition is an explanation of his arousal from cues; the appraisal is an evaluation of what the event means for him and how he can cope.
Each difference is stated for both theories in one sentence, with a comparative word ("whereas", "while").
Step 5: Add an evaluative point
Sam's fright began within a fraction of a second, before he could have appraised anything, which fits the arousal-first order better; but the anger only appeared once he saw the driver laughing, a cue both theories can use.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Both theories say cognition decides the emotion. In the two-factor theory, Sam's arousal (shaking, pounding heart) comes first and he labels it anger from the cue of the laughing driver, whereas in the appraisal theory he first appraises the event as harm caused by someone to blame (primary) that he can confront (secondary), and the anger and its arousal follow. The two-factor cognition explains arousal already present; the appraisal evaluates the event's meaning for his wellbeing.
Method
Apply each theory to the scenario, naming its terms.
State one similarity.
State the differences: the order of arousal and cognition, and what the cognition is about.
Use comparative words and the scenario's details throughout.
Watch out for
Describing each theory in general terms without Sam's details.
Writing two separate paragraphs with no "whereas" or "both".
Exam tip
Use the scenario
A compare question gives you a situation. Apply each theory to it, using the details given: "Under the two-factor theory, Sam's racing heart comes first, and he labels it as anger because the driver is shouting." Then state the similarity and the differences. A comparison that never mentions the scenario earns little.
Why research methods matter here. These theories can only be told apart by evidence. Schachter & Singer manipulated arousal and the explanation for it, and measured the emotion; Speisman and colleagues manipulated the appraisal and measured arousal. Each manipulated one variable and measured another, so the order of cause and effect could be tested rather than argued. You will design an experiment of your own on emotion in the third lesson.
Summary
An emotion has a feeling, physiological arousal and behaviour.
Two-factor theory (Schachter & Singer 1962): arousal first, then a cognitive label from situational cues; the label decides the emotion.
In their experiment, aroused participants with no explanation (ignorant, misinformed) caught the confederate's mood; informed participants did not. The study had serious ethical problems and weak results.
Appraisal theory (Lazarus 1982): primary appraisal (irrelevant, benign-positive, harm or loss, threat, challenge) and secondary appraisal (coping) come first; the emotion and arousal follow.
Both are cognitive. They differ in the order of arousal and cognition, and in what the cognition is about.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.