Lesson 8 of 9 · 18 min
Achievement goal, cognitive evaluation and self-efficacy theories
Explain the achievement goal, cognitive evaluation and self-efficacy theories of motivation, and compare them by applying all three to the same student.
What you will be able to do
- Explain task and ego orientation in achievement goal theory.
- Explain intrinsic and extrinsic motivation, and how rewards and feedback affect them, in cognitive evaluation theory.
- Explain efficacy and outcome expectations in self-efficacy theory.
- Compare the three theories by applying them to one situation.
- Describe how motivation and emotion affect each other.
Two students fail their first chemistry test. One books extra help and tries again; the other quietly drops the subject. Same event, different behaviour. Motivation is what starts, directs and keeps up behaviour towards a goal, and the three theories in this lesson each explain the difference between these students in their own way: by what they count as success, by why they are doing chemistry at all, and by whether they believe they can do it.
Definition
Achievement goal theory
People differ in how they judge success in an achievement task (Nicholls 1984):
- Task orientation: success means improving, learning and trying hard. "I did well because I mastered something new."
- Ego orientation: success means beating others, or doing as well with less effort. "I did well because I came top."
Task-oriented people tend to choose challenging tasks, persist after failure (it is information about what to learn) and enjoy the activity. Ego-oriented people do well while they believe they are better than others, but when they doubt their ability they tend to avoid challenges, give up or blame others, because failing would show low ability. A person can be high or low on each orientation, and a class or team's motivational climate (praising improvement or ranking students) pushes people towards one.
Classify each statement as showing task orientation or ego orientation.
Definition
Cognitive evaluation theory
Intrinsic motivation is doing something for its own sake, for the interest or enjoyment of it. Extrinsic motivation is doing it for a separate outcome: a reward, a grade, praise, or to avoid punishment.
Cognitive evaluation theory (Deci & Ryan 1985) explains how outside events such as rewards and feedback change intrinsic motivation. It depends on how the person interprets them:
- Controlling: an event felt as pressure to behave a certain way reduces your sense of autonomy, so intrinsic motivation falls.
- Informational: an event that tells you that you are competent raises intrinsic motivation.
Evidence. Lepper, Greene & Nisbett (1973) found that preschool children who liked drawing and were promised a certificate for drawing later spent less of their free time drawing than children who got no reward or an unexpected one. The expected reward turned play into work. Across many studies, expected tangible rewards for doing a task tend to reduce intrinsic motivation, while positive feedback ("you solved that cleverly") tends to raise it (Deci, Koestner & Ryan 1999). So a reward is not bad in itself: what matters is whether it is felt as controlling or as information about competence.
Ari loves writing stories in his spare time. His parents start paying him $5 for every story he finishes. According to cognitive evaluation theory, what is most likely to happen once the payments stop?
Definition
Self-efficacy theory
Bandura (1977) separated two beliefs:
- Efficacy expectation: "I can carry out the behaviour this needs." (I can make myself study two hours a night.)
- Outcome expectation: "That behaviour will lead to the outcome." (Studying two hours a night will get me an A.)
Both are needed. High self-efficacy leads people to take on challenges, try harder and persist after setbacks. It comes from four sources: performance accomplishments (past successes, the strongest source), vicarious experience (seeing someone like you succeed), verbal persuasion (being told you can) and emotional arousal (calm suggests you can cope; a pounding heart suggests you cannot).
Efficacy expectations sit between the person and the behaviour; outcome expectations between the behaviour and the outcome (after Bandura 1977).
Mia says: "I know practising past papers would raise my mark, but I just don't think I can get myself to do them." Which belief is low?
Change the student's situation and see what each theory predicts for their persistence.
| Feature | Achievement goal | Cognitive evaluation | Self-efficacy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Key question | How does the person define success? | Why is the person doing it, and do outside events support or undermine that? | Does the person believe they can do it, and that it will work? |
| Key concepts | Task and ego orientation | Intrinsic and extrinsic motivation; controlling and informational events | Efficacy and outcome expectations |
| Where motivation comes from | The goal the person holds | Needs for autonomy and competence | Beliefs about capability and results |
| Predicts persistence after failure when… | Task orientation (failure is information) | Intrinsic motivation is intact | Efficacy expectations are high |
| Practical advice | Praise improvement and effort, not rank | Use informational feedback; avoid controlling rewards | Build small successes, models and encouragement |
Key idea
How to compare
Similarities: all three are cognitive (motivation depends on the person's beliefs and interpretations, not just the situation); all predict who persists after setbacks; and competence matters in all three (judged against others or yourself, felt as informational, or believed in as self-efficacy).
Differences: they focus on different beliefs: what success means (achievement goal), why you act and whether outside events feel controlling (cognitive evaluation), and whether you can act and it will work (self-efficacy). Only cognitive evaluation theory explains why a reward can lower motivation; only self-efficacy separates believing in the method from believing in yourself.
Worked example
Compare three theories of motivation for one student
Lucas took up chess because he enjoyed it. His school then started a ladder that ranks players and gives $20 vouchers to the top three each term. After losing several games to higher-ranked players, Lucas says, "I'm just not good enough to beat them," and has stopped going to chess club.
Compare how the achievement goal, cognitive evaluation and self-efficacy theories explain why Lucas stopped. (6 marks)
Step 1: Achievement goal theory
The ranked ladder creates a performance climate that pushes Lucas towards ego orientation: success means beating others. Losing to higher-ranked players then signals low ability, so, as the theory predicts for ego-oriented people who doubt their ability, he withdraws.
Step 2: Cognitive evaluation theory
Lucas was intrinsically motivated. The vouchers, expected and tied to rank, are likely felt as controlling, shifting his reason for playing to an extrinsic one; losing also gives negative competence information. Both lower intrinsic motivation.
Step 3: Self-efficacy theory
His efficacy expectation is low ("I'm not good enough to beat them"): his recent performance accomplishments were failures, the strongest source of low self-efficacy. His outcome expectation (practice leads to wins) may be fine, but without efficacy he does not act.
Step 4: Similarity
All three are cognitive and all link his quitting to how he interprets his losses and his competence.
Step 5: Differences
They focus on different beliefs: how he defines success (achievement goal), why he plays and whether the rewards feel controlling (cognitive evaluation), and whether he believes he can win (self-efficacy). Only cognitive evaluation theory explains why the vouchers themselves could lower his motivation.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Achievement goal: the ladder made him ego-oriented, so losing meant low ability and he withdrew. Cognitive evaluation: controlling, expected rewards and negative feedback lowered intrinsic motivation. Self-efficacy: repeated failure lowered his efficacy expectation. All are cognitive and concern competence, but they focus on different beliefs, and only cognitive evaluation explains the effect of the vouchers.
Method
Apply each theory with its own terms and the scenario's details.
State at least one similarity and two differences.
Motivation and emotion. The two are closely linked. Emotions motivate: fear motivates escape, interest motivates exploring. Motivation shapes emotion: progress towards a goal brings pride and enjoyment, a blocked goal brings frustration or anxiety, and an ego-oriented student who doubts their ability feels anxious before a test that a task-oriented student may find exciting. Because both are internal states, the only way to sort out which causes which is with research methods: operationalise each (a self-efficacy scale, heart rate, persistence in minutes), manipulate one in an experiment, and measure the other.
Summary
Achievement goal theory: task orientation (success = improving) supports persistence; ego orientation (success = beating others) is fragile when ability is in doubt.
Cognitive evaluation theory: intrinsic motivation falls when events feel controlling (expected tangible rewards) and rises when they are informational about competence.
Self-efficacy theory: efficacy expectations (I can do it) and outcome expectations (it will work); built by performance accomplishments, vicarious experience, verbal persuasion and emotional arousal.
Compare: all cognitive and all about persistence, but they focus on what success means, why you act, and whether you can.
Emotion and motivation influence each other; experiments are needed to untangle cause and effect.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.