Lesson 9 of 9 · 13 min
Goal setting and motivation
Describe how specific, difficult goals raise performance through attention, effort, persistence and strategy, and why commitment and feedback are needed (Locke 1996).
What you will be able to do
- Describe why specific, difficult goals lead to higher performance than vague or easy ones.
- Describe the four ways goals affect performance.
- Explain the roles of commitment and feedback.
- Judge a goal against Locke's findings and improve it.
"Do your best" sounds like good advice. Decades of experiments say it is not. Edwin Locke, with Gary Latham, ran hundreds of studies in laboratories, workplaces and schools, and Locke (1996) summarised what they found: people given a specific, difficult goal perform better than people told to do their best.
Key idea
Locke's (1996) main findings
- Difficulty: the harder the goal, the higher the performance, as long as the person is committed and has the ability.
- Specificity: a specific goal ("raise my mark from 62% to 75%") regulates performance more precisely than a vague one ("do better").
- Specific and difficult goals lead to higher performance than vague "do your best" goals or easy goals.
- Commitment matters most when goals are specific and difficult. It is high when the person sees the goal as important and believes it is attainable (self-efficacy).
- Feedback on progress is needed: a goal without feedback, or feedback without a goal, does little.
| Mechanism | What the goal does | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Direction | Directs attention to goal-relevant activity and away from distractions | A goal of 20 past-paper questions this week focuses revision on practice, not rewriting notes |
| Effort | Mobilises effort in proportion to the goal's difficulty | A harder target gets more intense work per session |
| Persistence | Keeps effort going for longer, especially after setbacks | Still revising on Thursday because 12 of 20 are done |
| Strategy | Prompts people to search for better ways to reach the goal | Switching to timed questions when progress stalls |
According to Locke (1996), which goal is most likely to lead to the highest performance for a swimmer who now swims 50 m in 34.0 seconds?
Change specificity, difficulty, commitment and feedback, and watch the predicted performance.
Common mistake
Hard is not impossible
Difficulty helps only while the person stays committed. A goal so hard that the person does not believe they can reach it lowers commitment, and performance falls. Difficult goals need ability, self-efficacy and feedback to work.
Goal setting at work. In a classic field study, log truck drivers who had been carrying about 60% of the legal maximum load were given a specific, difficult goal of 94%. Within months their loads rose to over 90%, saving the company the cost of extra trucks (Latham & Baldes 1975). Workplaces now use specific targets, regular progress feedback and goals that employees help set (which can raise commitment). Goal setting links to flow, too: clear goals and immediate feedback are two of flow's conditions.
Ella's goal is to run 5 km in under 25 minutes. When her times stop improving, she looks up interval training and changes her sessions. Which way that goals affect performance does this show?
Worked example
Improve a goal using Locke (1996)
Zara's goal for the term is "try harder in English". Using Locke (1996), explain why this goal is unlikely to improve her performance much, and rewrite it.
Step 1: Judge the goal
It is vague (no way to tell when it is reached) and has no stated difficulty, so it works like a "do your best" goal. It has no feedback built in.
Step 2: Rewrite it
"Raise my English essay mark from a C to a B by the end of term by writing one practice paragraph a week and getting my teacher's feedback on it."
Step 3: Why it works
Specific (C to B), difficult but attainable, with feedback each week. It directs her attention to essay writing, raises effort and persistence, and invites better strategies; commitment should be high if she values English and believes the goal is reachable.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The goal is vague and has no feedback. Better: "Raise my essay mark from a C to a B this term, with a weekly practice paragraph marked by my teacher." It is specific, difficult and has feedback.
Method
Check: specific? difficult? committed? feedback?
Rewrite with a measurable target, a stretch, and a way of tracking progress.
Summary
Specific, difficult goals lead to higher performance than vague "do your best" goals or easy goals (Locke 1996).
Goals work through direction (attention), effort, persistence and strategy.
Commitment is essential, and is high when the goal is important and believed attainable (self-efficacy).
Feedback on progress is needed for goals to work.
Employers use specific targets and feedback; clear goals and feedback are also conditions for flow.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.