Lesson 5 of 9 · 16 min
Happiness, subjective wellbeing and psychological wellbeing
Describe the factors that affect happiness, and explain subjective wellbeing (Diener 1984) and psychological wellbeing (Ryff & Keyes 1995) and how the two differ.
What you will be able to do
- Describe factors that affect happiness, with evidence.
- Explain subjective wellbeing and its three components.
- Explain psychological wellbeing and its six dimensions.
- Distinguish feeling good (hedonic) from functioning well (eudaimonic).
Ask a hundred people what would make them happier and most will say more money. Ask psychologists what actually predicts happiness and the answer is different: close relationships come first, money matters less than people expect, and people get used to most changes faster than they think. This lesson looks at what affects happiness, and at two ways psychologists measure it.
| Factor | What the research shows |
|---|---|
| Relationships | The strongest single predictor. In Diener & Seligman's (2002) study of 222 students, the happiest 10% had stronger friendships and romantic relationships and spent less time alone than the rest; good relationships seemed necessary for high happiness, though not enough on their own. |
| Genes and personality | Twin studies suggest about half the differences between people in wellbeing are inherited (Lykken & Tellegen 1996). Extraverted, emotionally stable people tend to be happier. |
| Income | Matters a lot where basic needs (food, housing, safety) are not met, then less and less as income rises: diminishing returns. |
| Adaptation | People adapt to many changes. Lottery winners interviewed months after their win were not significantly happier than people who had not won (Brickman et al. 1978). Some changes, such as long-term unemployment, leave a lasting drop (Lucas et al. 2004). |
| Health | How healthy people feel predicts happiness more than measured health, though chronic pain and serious illness lower it. |
| Meaningful activity and work | Having work, study or roles that matter to you, and goals you are making progress on, raises wellbeing. |
| Culture | What counts as happiness differs: individualist cultures stress personal achievement and excitement, collectivist ones harmony and calm. |
| Intentional activities | Gratitude, kindness, exercise and sleep are things people can change, and each is linked to modest gains. |
Two years after winning $2 million in a lottery, Priya reports about the same life satisfaction she had before. Which factor best explains this?
Definition
Subjective wellbeing (Diener 1984)
Subjective wellbeing (SWB) is a person's own evaluation of their life. It has three components:
- Life satisfaction: a thoughtful (cognitive) judgement of your life as a whole.
- Positive affect: experiencing pleasant emotions often (joy, interest, contentment).
- Negative affect that is low: experiencing unpleasant emotions rarely (sadness, anxiety, anger).
High SWB means high satisfaction, frequent positive affect and infrequent negative affect.
Subjective is the key word: SWB is what the person thinks and feels about their own life, not what an observer thinks of it. That is why it is measured by self-report. Life satisfaction is often measured with the Satisfaction With Life Scale (Diener et al. 1985): five statements such as "In most ways my life is close to my ideal", each rated from 1 (strongly disagree) to 7 (strongly agree), for a total from 5 to 35. Positive and negative affect are measured separately, for example by asking how often in the last month you felt each of a list of emotions.
Classify each survey item by the component of subjective wellbeing it measures.
Definition
Psychological wellbeing (Ryff & Keyes 1995)
Psychological wellbeing (PWB) is functioning well and realising your potential, not just feeling good. Ryff's model has six dimensions:
- Self-acceptance: a positive attitude to yourself and your past, good and bad.
- Positive relations with others: warm, trusting relationships; empathy and care.
- Autonomy: thinking and acting independently; judging yourself by your own standards, not others' approval.
- Environmental mastery: managing your everyday life and making use of opportunities.
- Purpose in life: having goals and a sense that your life has direction and meaning.
- Personal growth: continuing to develop, open to new experiences.
Ryff & Keyes (1995) tested whether these six really are separate. A national telephone survey of 1,108 US adults aged 25 and over answered short scales for each dimension. Statistical analysis (confirmatory factor analysis) showed six related but distinct dimensions fitted the data better than a single general factor. PWB scores correlated only moderately with life satisfaction and affect, so the two models measure overlapping but different things. Some dimensions differed with age: environmental mastery and autonomy tended to be higher in older adults, purpose in life and personal growth lower.
Subjective wellbeing (Diener 1984)
- Hedonic: feeling good, pleasure and satisfaction.
- Three components: life satisfaction, high positive affect, low negative affect.
- The person decides what counts as a good life.
- Measured by self-report scales of satisfaction and emotion.
Psychological wellbeing (Ryff & Keyes 1995)
- Eudaimonic: functioning well, meaning and growth.
- Six dimensions: self-acceptance, positive relations, autonomy, environmental mastery, purpose, personal growth.
- The theory defines what functioning well involves.
- Also measured by self-report, on a scale for each dimension.
Set a person's satisfaction and emotions, then look at the same person through Ryff's six dimensions.
Worked example
Apply subjective and psychological wellbeing to one person
Daniel, 19, says he is very satisfied with his life and feels cheerful most days. He spends his time gaming and partying, has dropped out of university, lets his parents make his decisions, and says he has "no real plans". Explain how Daniel would be rated on subjective wellbeing (Diener 1984) and on psychological wellbeing (Ryff & Keyes 1995), and why the two differ. (5 marks)
Step 1: Subjective wellbeing
SWB is his own evaluation: high life satisfaction ("very satisfied"), frequent positive affect ("cheerful most days") and, as far as we know, little negative affect. So his SWB is high.
Step 2: Psychological wellbeing
Several of Ryff's dimensions look low: purpose in life ("no real plans"), autonomy (his parents make his decisions), personal growth (dropped out, little new learning). Others are unclear (positive relations, self-acceptance).
Step 3: Why they differ
SWB is hedonic, about feeling good as judged by the person; PWB is eudaimonic, about functioning well against the theory's dimensions. Daniel feels good without functioning well on several dimensions, so the two models rate him differently.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
High SWB (high satisfaction and positive affect, his own evaluation) but lower PWB (low purpose in life, autonomy and personal growth), because SWB measures feeling good while PWB measures functioning well.
Method
Score each model's components from the evidence given.
Explain the difference with hedonic versus eudaimonic.
Exam tip
Explaining a model
"Explain" wants the model and how it works or why. For SWB, name the three components and say it is the person's own evaluation (so self-report). For PWB, name the six dimensions and say it is about functioning well rather than feeling good. Applying either to a person in the question earns the top marks.
Summary
Happiness is affected by relationships (most strongly), genes and personality, income (diminishing returns), adaptation, health, meaningful activity, culture and intentional activities.
Subjective wellbeing (Diener 1984): life satisfaction, frequent positive affect, infrequent negative affect, as the person judges it.
Psychological wellbeing (Ryff & Keyes 1995): self-acceptance, positive relations, autonomy, environmental mastery, purpose in life, personal growth.
SWB is hedonic (feeling good); PWB is eudaimonic (functioning well). They overlap but are distinct.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.