Lesson 6 of 9 · 15 min

Broaden-and-build and mindfulness

Explain how positive emotions broaden thinking and build lasting resources (Fredrickson 2004), and explain mindfulness with reference to attention and acceptance.

What you will be able to do

  • Explain how positive emotions broaden thought–action repertoires and build personal resources.
  • Describe evidence for broadening and for the undo effect.
  • Explain mindfulness in terms of attention and acceptance.
  • Explain how mindfulness can improve wellbeing.

Fear has an obvious use: it narrows your mind to one urge, escape, and readies your body to do it. But what is joy for? Or interest, or contentment? They do not prepare you for any particular action. Barbara Fredrickson's answer is that positive emotions work over a longer time: they open the mind up, and what you do with an open mind builds resources you keep.

Definition

The broaden-and-build theory (Fredrickson 2004)

  • Broaden: positive emotions widen your momentary thought–action repertoire, the range of thoughts and actions that come to mind. Joy sparks the urge to play, interest the urge to explore, contentment the urge to savour and connect. Negative emotions narrow it to specific urges (fear: escape; anger: attack).
  • Build: the play, exploring and connecting that broadened thinking leads to builds lasting personal resources: physical (fitness, health), intellectual (knowledge, problem-solving), social (friendships, support) and psychological (resilience, optimism).
  • Spiral: those resources make future positive emotions more likely, an upward spiral of wellbeing.

Broaden-and-build as an upward spiral.

Evidence. Fredrickson & Branigan (2005) showed participants short film clips that produced amusement, contentment, no emotion, anger or anxiety. After the positive clips, participants listed more things they would like to do right then, and saw the "big picture" in a visual task more often: their thinking and attention had broadened. The undo effect is a second line of evidence: after a frightening clip raised their heart rate, participants who then watched an amusing or contented clip returned to their resting cardiovascular state faster than those who watched a neutral or sad one (Fredrickson et al. 2000).

Classify each part of this story as broadening or building, in the broaden-and-build theory.

Interactive

Build resources

Raise the frequency of positive emotions and watch what is built over time.

Definition

Mindfulness

Mindfulness is paying attention, on purpose, to your experience in the present moment, with acceptance rather than judgement (after Kabat-Zinn 1994). It has two parts (Bishop et al. 2004):

  • Attention: deliberately keeping attention on present experience (the breath, sounds, body sensations, thoughts as they arise), noticing when it wanders, and bringing it back.
  • Acceptance: meeting whatever you notice with openness and curiosity, letting thoughts and feelings come and go without judging them, pushing them away or getting caught up in them.

Why both parts matter. Attention alone can make things worse: someone anxious who pays close attention to their racing heart may become more anxious. Acceptance is what changes the relationship with the experience. A thought like "I'm going to fail" is noticed as a passing mental event rather than a fact, so it is less likely to start a spiral of worry. Lindsay & Creswell (2017) argue that the benefits for stress come from attention and acceptance together.

Regular practice is linked to less rumination and stress and more positive emotion. Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy, an eight-week course, reduces the chance of relapse for people who have had repeated episodes of depression (Kuyken et al. 2016). It is a skill learnt by practice, not a state you are told to be in.

During a mindful breathing exercise, Tom notices he is worrying about tomorrow's test. Which response shows acceptance?

Choose one answer

Worked example

Explain mindfulness with attention and acceptance

  • Simple familiar

Before every exam, Hana's mind races with thoughts that she will fail. Explain how practising mindfulness could help her, with reference to attention and acceptance. (4 marks)

4 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Define, then explain attention, then acceptance, each applied to the person.

  2. Finish with the effect on wellbeing.

Exam tip

The syllabus wording

The dot point says "with reference to attention and acceptance". A full-marks explanation defines mindfulness, explains each part, and says how they work together to improve wellbeing. For broaden-and-build, use the words broaden, thought–action repertoire, build and resources, and give an example of each.

Summary

  • Broaden: positive emotions widen momentary thought–action repertoires; negative emotions narrow them.

  • Build: broadened thinking and action build lasting physical, intellectual, social and psychological resources, an upward spiral.

  • Evidence: film clips that produced positive emotions broadened attention and thinking; positive emotions undo the cardiovascular effects of fear faster.

  • Mindfulness: attention to present experience, on purpose, with acceptance rather than judgement.

  • Attention without acceptance can raise distress; together they reduce rumination and stress.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 6 of 90% read

Save your progress with a free account