Lesson 7 of 9 · 15 min
The flow experience and its consequences
Identify flow from challenge and skill, describe how flow enhances positive affect, life satisfaction, performance and learning (Nakamura & Csikszentmihalyi 2002), and how employers use it.
What you will be able to do
- Describe the conditions and characteristics of flow.
- Identify flow, anxiety, boredom and apathy from challenge and skill ratings.
- Describe how flow enhances positive affect, life satisfaction, performance and learning.
- Consider how research into flow shapes the way employers motivate and engage employees.
A climber halfway up a hard route, a coder chasing a bug, a musician deep in a piece: each loses track of time, forgets to worry about how they look, and feels completely in control of what they are doing. Csikszentmihalyi called this state flow, after the way people described it: "like being carried by a current".
Definition
Flow (Nakamura & Csikszentmihalyi 2002)
Conditions: a challenge that stretches your existing skills (neither too easy nor too hard), clear goals for the next step, and immediate feedback on how you are going.
What it feels like: intense, focused concentration on the present; action and awareness merge; self-consciousness falls away; a sense of control; time passes strangely (usually faster); and the activity is autotelic, rewarding in itself.
Too much challenge for your skill brings anxiety; too little brings boredom. Practice raises skill, so the challenge has to rise to keep you in flow.
Measuring flow. You cannot interrupt a climber to ask if they are in flow without breaking it. Csikszentmihalyi's team used the experience sampling method (ESM): participants carry a device that signals at random times through the day, and at each signal they rate what they are doing, how challenging it is, how skilled they feel, and how they feel. Flow is counted where both challenge and skill are above that person's own average; challenge above and skill below is anxiety; skill above and challenge below is boredom (or relaxation); both below is apathy.
One student's week of signals (made up for practice). The dashed lines are their own mean skill and mean challenge.
In the figure, signal B was during a maths exam on a topic the student had missed. Which state does B show?
| Consequence | How flow enhances it |
|---|---|
| Positive affect | Flow is enjoyable. In ESM studies people in flow report feeling happier, more cheerful and more involved; the enjoyment is often felt most strongly just after the activity, when there is room to reflect. |
| Life satisfaction | People who experience flow often, at work, school or leisure, rate the quality of their lives more highly. A life with regular flow feels engaged and worthwhile. |
| Performance | Total concentration and clear feedback let people perform at their best: flow is linked to better performance in sport, music, study and work. |
| Learning | Flow is self-improving. As skill rises, the same task becomes boring, so to get flow again a person seeks a harder challenge, and skill grows again. Talented teenagers who experienced flow in their talent kept developing it; those who did not tended to drop out. |
Explain why experiencing flow tends to increase a person's skill over time.
Note
Flow at work
Csikszentmihalyi & LeFevre (1989) found people reported flow more often at work than in their free time, yet still said they would rather be doing something else: the "paradox of work". Employers draw on flow research to engage employees:
- set clear goals for each task and give quick, specific feedback (dashboards, regular check-ins)
- match tasks to skill: training when the challenge is too high, new responsibilities when it is too low
- protect blocks of uninterrupted time for focused work
- give employees control over how they do a task, and let them shape their own roles
Engaged employees are more productive and less likely to leave, which is why this research is used.
Worked example
Identify flow from experience sampling data
A Year 11 student rated challenge and skill (0–10) at eight random signals in a week.
| Activity | Challenge | Skill |
|---|---|---|
| Netball game | 8 | 7 |
| Chemistry class | 7 | 3 |
| Watching TV | 1 | 6 |
| Bus ride | 2 | 2 |
| Guitar practice | 7 | 8 |
| Maths homework | 6 | 4 |
| Chatting at lunch | 3 | 7 |
| Tidying room | 2 | 3 |
(a) Calculate the student's mean challenge and mean skill. (b) Identify the activities in flow, using the experience sampling definition. (c) Suggest how their chemistry teacher could help them experience flow in class.
Step 1: Means
Mean challenge ; mean skill .
Step 2: Classify
Flow is challenge and skill above the person's own means (above 4.5 and 5.0). Netball (8, 7) and guitar (7, 8) qualify. Chemistry (7, 3) and maths (6, 4) are high challenge, low skill: anxiety.
Step 3: Chemistry
Raise skill to meet the challenge: break tasks into clear goals with immediate feedback, build skills step by step (worked examples, scaffolded practice), so skill rises above their average while the challenge stays high.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Challenge 4.5, skill 5.0. (b) Netball and guitar practice. (c) Chemistry is anxiety (high challenge, low skill): clear goals, quick feedback and scaffolded skill-building would move it towards flow.
Method
Find the person's own mean challenge and skill.
Flow: both above the means. Anxiety: challenge above, skill below. Boredom: skill above, challenge below. Apathy: both below.
Summary
Flow needs a challenge matched to high skill, clear goals and immediate feedback; it brings deep concentration, loss of self-consciousness, a sense of control, altered time, and is autotelic.
In experience sampling studies, flow is both challenge and skill above the person's average; anxiety, boredom and apathy are the other quadrants.
Flow enhances positive affect, life satisfaction, performance and learning.
Learning: rising skill makes the old challenge boring, so people seek harder ones and keep growing.
Employers use flow research: clear goals, quick feedback, tasks matched to skill, fewer interruptions, autonomy.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.