Lesson 3 of 9 · 18 min
Designing the emotive stimulus experiment
Plan the experiment comparing heart rate during an emotive and an informative clip: variables, operational definitions, hypotheses, a counterbalanced repeated measures design, controls and the ethics of a frightening clip.
What you will be able to do
- Identify and operationalise the independent and dependent variables.
- Write null and alternative hypotheses.
- Choose between repeated measures and independent groups, and counterbalance the order.
- Identify extraneous and confounding variables and the controls that deal with them.
- Apply ethical principles to showing participants a frightening clip.
The first lesson argued about whether emotion comes with arousal. Now you measure it. The syllabus's practical asks: does watching an emotive stimulus (a scary film scene) change heart rate more than watching an informative one (a toothpaste advertisement)? Heart rate is a measure of sympathetic arousal you can take in a classroom, and the toothpaste advertisement is there as a comparison: something to watch that should not frighten anyone.
Definition
The variables
Independent variable (IV): the type of stimulus watched, emotive or informative.
Dependent variable (DV): the emotional response, measured as the change in heart rate in beats per minute (bpm): heart rate while watching minus the resting heart rate before.
Operationalising means saying exactly how each variable is produced or measured, so another researcher could repeat it. "A scary movie" is not enough. A full operational definition reads something like this:
- IV: a 3-minute clip from a suspense film classified M (a character alone in a dark house, with a sudden fright near the end), against a 3-minute toothpaste advertisement, shown on the same screen at the same volume.
- DV: heart rate counted at the wrist for 60 seconds (or read from a pulse oximeter) after 5 minutes of quiet sitting, and again for the last 60 seconds of each clip; the change is the second count minus the first.
Which is the best operational definition of the dependent variable?
Key idea
The hypotheses
Null hypothesis (H₀): there will be no difference in the mean change in heart rate between participants watching the emotive clip and the informative clip.
Alternative hypothesis (H₁): the mean change in heart rate will be greater when watching the emotive clip than when watching the informative clip.
This H₁ predicts a direction (a one-tailed hypothesis). "There will be a difference in the mean change…" is a two-tailed H₁. Name both variables, the population and the operationalised DV.
Classify each variable, choose the operational definitions, then pick the hypotheses.
Repeated measures
Every participant watches both clips.
- Controls participant variables: resting heart rate, fitness, how easily each person is frightened. Each person is compared with themselves.
- Needs half as many participants.
- Risk: order effects. Arousal from the scary clip can carry over into the advertisement, and people who have seen one clip may guess the aim.
- Fix: counterbalancing (half see the emotive clip first, half the informative first) and a rest between clips until heart rate returns to its resting level.
Independent groups
Each participant watches one clip, allocated at random.
- No order effects or carry-over.
- Needs twice the participants.
- Risk: participant variables. If the emotive group happens to include more anxious or less fit people, the difference could be theirs, not the clip's.
- Fix: random allocation spreads these differences across the groups by chance; a larger sample helps.
Tip
Which design?
For a class, repeated measures with counterbalancing is usually the better choice: people differ a lot in resting heart rate and in how they react to horror, and comparing each person with themselves removes that. The design also decides the statistics: repeated measures data are paired (a paired t-test on each person's difference), independent groups are not.
A class runs the experiment as repeated measures. Every student watches the scary clip first and the advertisement second. What is the main problem?
| Extraneous variable | Why it matters | Control |
|---|---|---|
| Caffeine, recent exercise, food | All raise heart rate | Ask participants not to have caffeine or exercise for an hour before; measure at the same time of day |
| Order of the clips | Carry-over arousal, guessing the aim | Counterbalancing; rest until heart rate is back to resting |
| Clip length, volume, screen, room | Louder or longer clips could arouse more whatever their content | Same length (3 minutes), volume, screen, lighting and seat for both clips: standardised procedures |
| What the experimenter says | Suggesting "this will be scary" creates expectations | Standardised instructions read from a script; participants not told the hypothesis (single-blind) |
| Talking or moving | Movement raises heart rate | Participants sit still and silent; one participant at a time or with dividers |
| Seen the film before, horror fans | Less surprise, smaller response | Choose an unfamiliar clip; ask afterwards and note it; random allocation in independent groups |
| Measuring error | Counting the pulse is easy to get wrong | Use the same device or the same trained counter for everyone; count for a full 60 seconds |
Each control removes a threat. Watch the measured effect move towards the true effect.
Exam tip
Ethics of a frightening clip
Showing someone a frightening clip risks distress, so the ethics need real thought, not a list:
- Informed consent: written consent from each participant, with written permission from a parent or carer for anyone under 16, as QCAA's guidelines require. Tell them that they will watch two short clips, one of which some people find frightening, and that their heart rate will be measured. You need not reveal the hypothesis.
- Protection from harm: choose a clip suitable for the age group (no graphic violence; M rather than MA15+ for a Year 11 class), and exclude anyone with a heart condition, an anxiety disorder or a strong fear of horror.
- Voluntary participation and withdrawal: anyone may look away, stop the clip or withdraw their data at any time, with no penalty.
- Confidentiality: record heart rates against participant codes, not names, and keep the data secure.
- Debriefing: afterwards, explain the aim, show the data are not about any individual, and check everyone is all right; a calm activity helps.
Worked example
Design the emotive stimulus experiment
A teacher plans to test whether watching a scary film clip raises heart rate more than watching a toothpaste advertisement, using the 24 students in a Year 11 class.
(a) State the IV and the operationalised DV. (b) Write a two-tailed alternative hypothesis. (c) Recommend a design, with the control it needs. (d) Identify two ethical considerations and how to meet them.
Step 1: Variables
IV: the type of clip, a 3-minute scary film scene (emotive) or a 3-minute toothpaste advertisement (informative). DV: change in heart rate (bpm), the beats counted in the last 60 s of the clip minus the beats counted in 60 s after 5 minutes of quiet rest.
Step 2: Hypothesis
There will be a difference in the mean change in heart rate of Year 11 students when watching the scary clip compared with the toothpaste advertisement.
Two-tailed: a difference, with no direction. It names the population, both conditions and the operationalised DV.
Step 3: Design
Repeated measures: every student watches both clips, so differences in resting heart rate, fitness and sensitivity to horror are controlled. Counterbalance (12 students see the scary clip first, 12 the advertisement first) and rest until heart rate returns to resting between clips, to control order effects.
Step 4: Ethics
Informed consent: students (and, for those under 16, a parent or carer) are told in writing that one clip may be frightening and that heart rate is measured. Protection from harm: an age-appropriate clip with no graphic violence, and students with heart conditions, anxiety or a dislike of horror excluded or allowed to opt out; any student can look away or withdraw (withdrawal rights), and everyone is debriefed.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
IV: type of clip (emotive or informative). DV: change in heart rate (bpm) from 60 s at rest to the last 60 s of the clip. H₁: there will be a difference in the mean change in heart rate between the two clips. Repeated measures, counterbalanced, with rest between clips. Ethics: informed (and parental) consent; protection from harm with an age-appropriate clip, exclusions, withdrawal rights and debriefing.
Method
Operationalise: what exactly is shown, and what exactly is measured, how and when.
Match the design to the main threat: participant variables (repeated measures) or order effects (counterbalancing).
Make each ethical point specific to this study.
Match each step of a class's procedure to the ethical principle it puts into practice.
Summary
IV: emotive or informative clip. DV: change in heart rate (bpm) from rest to the last minute of the clip.
Operationalise both: the exact clips, their length and volume; how, when and for how long heart rate is measured.
H₀: no difference in the mean change; H₁: a greater mean change for the emotive clip (one-tailed) or a difference (two-tailed).
Repeated measures controls participant variables; counterbalance and rest between clips to deal with order effects. Independent groups needs random allocation.
Standardise clips, room, instructions and measurement; ask about caffeine and exercise.
Ethics: informed (and parental) consent, protection from harm, withdrawal, confidentiality and debriefing.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.