Psychology · Unit 2 · Topic 2

Diagnosis

When does behaviour become a psychological disorder? Adaptive and maladaptive behaviour, six approaches to normality, DSM-5-TR and ICD-11, the main categories of disorder, and how reliable and valid diagnosis is.

  • 8 lessons
  • 2 h 12 min of lessons
  • 12 worked examples
  • 10 hours in the syllabus
0 of 8

Start here

Adaptive and maladaptive behaviour

Lesson 1 of 8 · 12 min

Start the topic

Lessons

8
  1. Adaptive and maladaptive behaviour (up next)

    Tell adaptive behaviour, which helps a person cope and function, from maladaptive behaviour, which gets in their way, using frequency, duration, distress, interference and context.

  2. Six approaches to normality

    Describe the sociocultural, functional, historical, situational, medical and statistical approaches to normality, apply each to a behaviour, and explain why they can disagree.

  3. The statistical approach to normality

    Use the mean, standard deviation, z-scores and the normal curve to decide whether a score is statistically uncommon, then weigh the statistical approach against the other five.

  4. What is a psychological disorder?

    Describe the concept of psychological disorder as a disturbance in thinking, emotion or behaviour that reflects a dysfunction and causes distress or impairment, and tell it apart from expected reactions and simple difference.

  5. Diagnostic manuals in common use

    Compare DSM-5-TR (2022) and ICD-11 (2022), their publishers, scope, structure and approach, and explain how psychiatrists, psychologists, GPs, researchers and health systems use them.

  6. The main categories of psychological disorder

    Describe the four main categories of disorder in the syllabus and the key features of schizophrenia, depression, specific phobias and antisocial personality disorder.

  7. Reliability and validity of diagnosis

    Calculate per cent agreement between clinicians, tell reliability from validity, explain what improves each, and analyse research on diagnosis, including Rosenhan (1973) and an agreement experiment.

  8. Diagnosis in context

    Consider whether diagnostic manuals explain behaviour and predict its course, evaluate how social, cultural and ethical factors shape diagnosis, and weigh the beneficial, harmful and unintended consequences of a diagnosis.

  9. Topic quiz

    Ten questions across the topic, from foundation to complex unfamiliar. Your results feed your mastery.

About this topic

Washing your hands before you cook is sensible. Washing them forty times a day until the skin cracks is not. Somewhere between the two, a behaviour stops helping a person and starts getting in their way, and deciding where that line is, and who gets to draw it, is what this topic is about.

You start with adaptive and maladaptive behaviour, and then six ways of deciding what counts as normal: the sociocultural, functional, historical, situational, medical and statistical approaches. They often disagree about the same behaviour, and seeing why is the core skill. Then you meet the concept of psychological disorder, the two diagnostic manuals in common use, the DSM-5-TR (2022) and the ICD-11 (2022), and the four main categories of disorder the syllabus names.

The last part asks how good diagnosis is. Do two clinicians agree (reliability)? Does the diagnosis describe something real and predict what will happen (validity and prognosis)? And how do social, cultural and ethical factors shape a diagnosis, for better and for worse?

Every person in this topic is fictional. Only a qualified clinician can diagnose a psychological disorder, after a full assessment; nothing here is meant for judging yourself or anyone you know. Units 1 and 2 are assessed by your school: expect short responses on the approaches and the manuals, case studies to analyse, and longer answers that discuss or evaluate.

Before you start

Builds on Intelligence.

  • The normal curve, mean and standard deviation, and the IQ scale (mean 100, standard deviation 15) from Unit 2 Topic 1.
  • Reliability and validity of psychological tests, from Unit 2 Topic 1.
  • Variables, hypotheses and research designs from the science inquiry skills.

What QCAA says you need to know9 dot points

Normality and behaviour

4 hours

Psychological disorder and diagnosis

4 hours
  • Describe the concept of psychological disorder.LessonWhat is a psychological disorder?
  • Compare diagnostic manuals in common use, including the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (5th edition-TR, 2022), and the International Classification of Diseases (11th revision, 2022), discussing the uses that different professions make of these manuals.LessonDiagnostic manuals in common use
  • Describe the main categories of psychological disorders, including the schizophrenia spectrum and other psychotic disorders (e.g. schizophrenia), bipolar and depressive disorders (e.g. depression), anxiety disorders (e.g. phobias) and personality disorders (e.g. antisocial personality disorder).LessonThe main categories of psychological disorder
  • Discuss the reliability and validity of diagnosis.LessonReliability and validity of diagnosis

Science as a human endeavour

2 hours

Subject matter from the Psychology General senior syllabus 2025 v1.3 (opens in a new tab), CC BY 4.0 © State of Queensland (QCAA).

The focus areas you can practise on their own. Each one maps to dot points above.

  • Adaptive and maladaptive behaviour

    Decide whether a behaviour is adaptive or maladaptive from how it affects the person's ability to cope and function, and justify the call.

    Practise
  • Approaches to normality

    Describe the sociocultural, functional, historical, situational, medical and statistical approaches, apply each to a case and say why they disagree.

    Practise
  • Statistical normality

    Use the mean, standard deviation, z-scores and the normal curve to decide whether a score is statistically uncommon, and evaluate the approach.

    Practise
  • The concept of psychological disorder

    Describe what makes something a psychological disorder (a dysfunction with distress or impairment) and what does not, such as expected grief or simple difference.

    Practise
  • DSM-5-TR and ICD-11

    Compare the two manuals (publisher, scope, structure, access, approach) and explain which professions use each and for what.

    Practise
  • Categories of disorder

    Describe the schizophrenia spectrum, bipolar and depressive, anxiety and personality disorders and the key features of the example disorder in each.

    Practise
  • Reliability and validity of diagnosis

    Calculate per cent agreement, tell reliability from validity, explain what improves each, and judge how well a diagnosis explains and predicts.

    Practise
  • Research on diagnosis

    Apply research methods to studies of diagnosis, including Rosenhan (1973) and agreement studies, with variables, design, statistics and ethics.

    Practise
  • Social, cultural and ethical factors

    Evaluate how culture, social factors, history and ethics shape what is diagnosed and how.

    Practise
  • Consequences of a diagnosis

    Weigh the beneficial, harmful and unintended consequences of giving a person a diagnosis.

    Practise

Worked examples12

All 12

Common mistakes

Treating "abnormal" as meaning "disordered"

A behaviour can be abnormal by one approach and not by another, and abnormal is not the same as a disorder. A score of 145 on an IQ test is statistically abnormal and is not a disorder. A disorder also needs dysfunction with distress or impairment.

Mixing up the sociocultural and situational approaches

Sociocultural asks "what do people in this culture or society expect?" Situational asks "what is appropriate in this setting, at this moment?" Shouting is normal for everyone at a grand final (situation), whatever their culture.

Saying maladaptive behaviour means the person is to blame

Maladaptive describes the effect of a behaviour on the person's ability to function, not their character or intentions. Many maladaptive behaviours began as ways of coping.

Saying statistically uncommon means undesirable

The statistical approach cannot tell desirable rarity (a very high IQ score, exceptional musical ability) from undesirable rarity. It also cannot say whether a common behaviour, such as feeling anxious, is a problem.

Saying DSM-5-TR is Australian or ICD-11 is only for physical illness

The DSM is published by the American Psychiatric Association and covers mental disorders only. The ICD-11 is published by the World Health Organization and covers all diseases and health conditions, with mental disorders in Chapter 6. Both are used in Australia.

Calling reliable diagnosis valid

Two clinicians can agree every time and both be wrong, for example if they share a bias. Reliability (consistency) is needed for validity, but it does not guarantee it.

Counting only "both said yes" in per cent agreement

Agreement includes cases where both clinicians found a disorder and cases where both found none. Add the two, divide by the total and multiply by 100.

Confusing schizophrenia with "split personality"

Schizophrenia is a psychotic disorder: hallucinations, delusions, disorganised thinking and negative symptoms, with a loss of contact with reality. It does not mean having more than one personality.

Describing a person as their disorder

Write "a person with schizophrenia", not "a schizophrenic". Person-first language is expected in QCAA responses and reflects that a diagnosis describes a condition a person has, not who they are.

Exam tips

  1. To discriminate between adaptive and maladaptive behaviour, name the behaviour's effect on the person's ability to cope, function and reach their goals, and point to the evidence in the case (frequency, duration, distress, interference).

  2. When asked to discuss the approaches to normality, give each approach's criterion, apply it to the behaviour in the question, and give at least one strength and one limitation.

  3. For compare questions about the manuals, write sentences that set the two side by side ("whereas", "both"): publisher, scope, access, structure, the professions that use each and why.

  4. Show every step of a calculation: the formula, the numbers substituted and the answer with its unit (%, or z with its sign). Round only at the end, to 2 decimal places unless told otherwise.

  5. In reliability and validity questions, say which one the evidence is about. Agreement between clinicians is reliability; a follow-up that confirms the diagnosis is evidence of validity.

  6. When you evaluate the influence of social, cultural or ethical factors, finish with a judgement ("on balance…") supported by your strongest point.

  7. Use person-first language and the syllabus's terms: DSM-5-TR (2022), ICD-11 (2022), schizophrenia spectrum and other psychotic disorders, bipolar and depressive disorders, anxiety disorders, personality disorders.

Where this shows up

  • In Australia, a GP can prepare a mental health treatment plan for a person with a diagnosed mental disorder, which gives access to Medicare rebates for sessions with a psychologist under the Better Access initiative (from 1 November 2025, through the person's usual GP).

  • Hospitals record every diagnosis with ICD codes (in Australia, the ICD-10-AM, Thirteenth Edition from 1 July 2025), which is how governments count conditions and plan services.

  • Researchers use DSM-5-TR criteria and structured interviews to decide who has a disorder in clinical trials, so results from different studies can be compared.

  • Courts sometimes hear evidence from forensic psychologists and psychiatrists about whether a person had a disorder at the time of an offence.

  • Mental health first aid courses teach people to notice signs that someone is struggling and help them reach professional support, not to diagnose.

  • Clinicians use the Cultural Formulation Interview and, with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander clients, social and emotional wellbeing frameworks, to understand distress in its cultural context.

Save your progress with a free account