Lesson 4 of 8 · 14 min

What is a psychological disorder?

Describe the concept of psychological disorder as a disturbance in thinking, emotion or behaviour that reflects a dysfunction and causes distress or impairment, and tell it apart from expected reactions and simple difference.

What you will be able to do

  • Describe the features that make a pattern of behaviour a psychological disorder.
  • Explain why expected responses to stress or loss, and behaviour that is simply different, are not disorders.
  • Link the concept of disorder to the approaches to normality.

So far you have asked whether a behaviour helps a person cope (adaptive) and whether it is normal (by six different standards). A psychological disorder brings these ideas together, and adds one more: that something in the way the person's mind is working has gone wrong.

DSM-5-TR and ICD-11 describe the concept in almost the same words. Put simply, a psychological disorder is:

Definition

Psychological disorder

A pattern of clinically significant disturbance in a person's thinking, emotions or behaviour that reflects a dysfunction in the psychological, biological or developmental processes underlying mental functioning, and that is usually associated with significant distress or impairment in social, work, study or other important areas of life.

An expected or culturally approved response to a common stress or loss, such as grief after a death, is not a disorder. Nor is behaviour that is simply different from society's norms, or a conflict between a person and society, unless it comes from a dysfunction in the person.

The parts of the concept, in plain words
FeatureWhat it meansLinked approach
Disturbance in thinking, emotion or behaviourSomething in how the person thinks, feels or acts has changed or is unusual for them.Statistical (unusual)
Clinically significantSerious enough that a clinician would act on it: not a passing mood or a quirk.Medical
DysfunctionA process that normally works (regulating mood, perceiving reality, controlling fear) is not working as it should.Medical
Distress or impairmentThe person is suffering, or it gets in the way of relationships, work, study or self-care.Functional
Not an expected or culturally approved responseIt is more than what most people in that culture would feel in that situation.Sociocultural and situational

Select all the features that are part of the concept of a psychological disorder.

Select all that apply.

What a disorder is not. The exclusions matter as much as the features. Feeling very sad after someone close to you dies is an expected response to loss, so it is not a disorder, however painful. A person who dresses, believes or lives differently from most people does not have a disorder because of it. An activist in conflict with their government does not have a disorder. Each of these could be called abnormal by some approach, and none involves a dysfunction in the person.

Time and degree. Most disorders also need symptoms to last for some time and to reach a level that causes distress or impairment. Low mood for an afternoon is not depression. This is why the same experience can be normal grief at one month and part of a disorder much later.

The parts of the concept, as a chain of questions. Every answer must be yes, and only a qualified clinician makes the judgement.

Worked example

Expected grief or a psychological disorder?

  • Complex familiar

A fictional man, Leo, aged 35, was very close to his father, who died suddenly.

  • Six weeks later, Leo cries often, thinks about his father many times a day and has missed two weeks of work, but he has returned to work, sees his friends and is starting to sleep normally again.
  • Fourteen months later, Leo still feels intense longing for his father nearly every day, thinks of little else, has stopped seeing friends and has been unable to return to work for three months.

Use the concept of psychological disorder to explain why Leo's experience at six weeks is not a disorder, and why a clinician might assess him for one at fourteen months.

4 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. State the three parts of the concept and its exclusions.

  2. Apply each to the case: disturbance, dysfunction, distress or impairment, expected response?

  3. Use duration and degree to separate the two time points.

Watch out for

  • Saying any grief is a disorder because it is distressing. Expected responses to loss are excluded.

  • Diagnosing Leo. Say what the concept suggests, and that a clinician decides.

Common mistake

A disorder is not a weakness or a choice

Describe a disorder as something a person has, not something they are or chose: "a person with depression", not "a depressed person" or "a depressive". A dysfunction in mental processes can have biological, psychological and social causes (you meet these in the next topic), and it says nothing about the person's character.

Which fictional case best fits the concept of a psychological disorder?

Choose one answer
Extension: disorder as harmful dysfunction

The philosopher and psychologist Jerome Wakefield (1992) argued that a disorder has two parts. One is a dysfunction: a mental mechanism failing to do the job it naturally does, such as fear failing to switch off when the danger has passed. That part is, in principle, a fact. The other is harm: the dysfunction causes suffering or loss that the person's society counts as harmful. That part is a value judgement, and it is where culture comes in. The idea explains why grief is not a disorder (no mechanism has failed: grief is what the system is meant to do after a loss) and why the boundaries of disorder have moved over history.

Exam tip

Describe the concept with a case

When asked to describe the concept of psychological disorder, name all three parts (a clinically significant disturbance in thinking, emotion or behaviour; a dysfunction; distress or impairment) and at least one exclusion (an expected response to stress or loss, or simple deviation from social norms). If the question gives a case, point to the evidence for each part.

Summary

  • A psychological disorder is a clinically significant disturbance in thinking, emotion or behaviour that reflects a dysfunction, usually with significant distress or impairment.

  • Expected or culturally approved responses to stress or loss are not disorders, and nor is behaviour that is simply different from social norms.

  • Symptoms usually need to last for some time and reach a level that causes distress or impairment.

  • The concept draws on several approaches to normality: medical (dysfunction), functional (impairment), sociocultural and situational (expected responses) and statistical (unusual).

  • Use person-first language: a person has a disorder; the disorder is not who they are.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 4 of 80% read

Save your progress with a free account