Lesson 2 of 8 · 18 min
Six approaches to normality
Describe the sociocultural, functional, historical, situational, medical and statistical approaches to normality, apply each to a behaviour, and explain why they can disagree.
What you will be able to do
- Describe the criterion each of the six approaches uses to judge normality.
- Apply the approaches to a fictional behaviour and say what each concludes.
- Give a strength and a limitation of each approach.
- Explain why the approaches can disagree about the same behaviour.
Is it normal to write with your left hand? Today, about one person in ten does, and nobody notices. In many classrooms in the first half of the twentieth century, in Australia as elsewhere, left-handed children were made to write with their right hand. The behaviour has not changed. The judgement has.
"Normal" sounds like a single idea, but it is a judgement made against some standard, and different standards give different answers. The syllabus names six approaches to normality, each with its own standard. Learn them as six questions you can ask of any behaviour.
| Approach | Normal means… | The question to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Sociocultural | in line with the norms of the person's society or cultural group | Is this what people in this person's culture expect? |
| Functional | allowing the person to function independently in daily life | Can the person still look after themselves, work or study, and keep relationships? |
| Historical | in line with what was accepted at that time in history | Was this accepted at the time it happened? |
| Situational | appropriate to the setting the behaviour happens in | Does it fit this particular situation? |
| Medical | not a symptom of an identifiable disorder | Is it a symptom that meets the criteria for a recognised disorder? |
| Statistical | common in the population; close to the average | How many people do or score this? Is it more than 2 standard deviations from the mean? |
Sociocultural approach. Every group has norms: unwritten rules about how to behave. A behaviour is normal if it fits the norms of the person's own society or cultural group. In some cultures, avoiding eye contact with an older person shows respect; in others it can seem evasive. This approach stops a clinician from judging one culture's behaviour by another's norms. Its limits: norms differ within a culture as well as between cultures, norms can themselves be unfair, and conforming is not the same as being well.
Functional approach. A behaviour is normal if it lets the person function: look after themselves, work or study, keep relationships and get through the day independently. It focuses on what matters to the person's life, and clinicians use it whenever they ask whether symptoms cause "impairment". Its limits: someone must decide what counts as functioning adequately, and some people function well on the outside while struggling a great deal.
Historical approach. A behaviour is judged against the norms of its time, and norms change. Forcing left-handed children to write with their right hand was once normal practice. Homosexuality was listed as a mental disorder by the American Psychiatric Association until 1973, when its board of trustees voted to remove it. The strength of this approach is that it reminds us today's judgements are not fixed either. Its limit: on its own, it does not tell you what is normal now.
History
Norms that changed
Until the mid-twentieth century, many schools, in Australia and elsewhere, made left-handed children write with their right hand. Until 15 December 1973, the American Psychiatric Association's manual listed homosexuality as a mental disorder; that day its board of trustees voted to remove it. In both cases the people had not changed. The standard had.
Situational approach. A behaviour is normal if it fits the situation it happens in. Shouting and leaping out of your seat is normal at a grand final and abnormal in an exam room. Wearing swimmers is normal at the beach and odd at a funeral. This approach recognises that context matters. Its limits: many situations are ambiguous, people disagree about what fits, and a behaviour that fits the setting can still be a problem for the person.
Medical approach. A behaviour is abnormal if it is a symptom of an identifiable disorder that meets the criteria in a diagnostic manual, often with an assumed biological cause, much as a fever is a sign of an infection. It is systematic and can lead to treatment. Its limits: it can overlook social and psychological causes, the categories it relies on change over time, and it is only as good as the reliability of the diagnosis.
Statistical approach. A behaviour or score is abnormal if it is uncommon: in practice, more than 2 standard deviations from the mean of a normal distribution. It is objective and easy to apply to anything that can be measured. Its big limit: rare is not the same as a problem. The next lesson works through it with numbers.
Match each judgement to the approach to normality it uses.
Judge each approach yourself before you see its verdict. Then switch the context.
Worked example
Apply six approaches to talking aloud in a crowd
In 2026, a fictional man, Rob, walks through a busy Brisbane shopping mall talking and laughing aloud with no-one beside him. He is on a phone call through wireless earbuds that are hard to see.
(a) Use each of the six approaches to normality to judge Rob's behaviour.
(b) Explain how a historical approach might have judged the same behaviour in 1990.
Step 1: Sociocultural
In Australian society today, talking on a phone in public is an accepted norm: normal.
Step 2: Functional
The call is part of his daily life and stops him doing nothing: normal.
Step 3: Situational
A shopping mall is a setting where people often take calls: normal. (In a library or a cinema it would not fit.)
Step 4: Medical
There is no sign of a symptom of any disorder; he is talking to a real person: normal.
Step 5: Statistical
Taking calls hands-free in public is common: normal.
Step 6: Historical, now and in 1990
By today's norms the behaviour is normal. In 1990, before mobile phones were common and long before wireless earbuds, a man talking and laughing aloud to no visible person would have been unusual and probably judged abnormal by onlookers, because the norms of the time had no place for it.
The historical approach judges against the norms of a period. The behaviour is identical; the period changes the verdict.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) By all six approaches, Rob's behaviour is normal today: it fits current social norms and the setting, does not impair him, is not a symptom and is common. (b) In 1990 the same behaviour would probably have been judged abnormal, because talking aloud to no visible person did not fit the norms of the time.
Method
State each approach's criterion in a phrase.
Apply it to the details in the case.
Give a verdict (normal or abnormal) with a reason for each.
Watch out for
Confusing situational (the mall, the moment) with sociocultural (the norms of the society).
Listing definitions without applying them to Rob.
Common mistake
Sociocultural or situational?
Both look at context, so students mix them up. Sociocultural is about the person's group: what their culture or society expects of people in general. Situational is about the setting: what fits this place and moment, for anyone in it. If the same behaviour would be normal or abnormal for everyone in that setting, whatever their culture, it is situational.
A person of a religious minority in Australia prays aloud five times a day. Which is the best criticism of judging this behaviour by the statistical approach alone?
Why the approaches disagree, and what clinicians do about it
Each approach measures a different thing: a group's rules, a person's functioning, a moment in history, a setting, a set of diagnostic criteria, or a frequency. A behaviour can be rare but harmless, common but harmful, normal in one culture and odd in another. No single approach is enough.
In practice, clinicians combine them. A diagnostic manual (medical approach) usually requires that symptoms cause distress or impairment (functional), that they are not an expected or culturally approved response (sociocultural and situational), and that they are unusual for the person (statistical). The approaches are not rivals so much as checks on one another.
Exam tip
Discussing the approaches
For a "discuss" question, take each approach in turn: state its criterion, apply it to the behaviour in the stimulus with a reason, and give a strength or limitation. Finish by saying where the approaches agree and where they do not. Answers that only define the approaches miss most of the marks.
Summary
Sociocultural: does it fit the norms of the person's culture or society?
Functional: can the person still function independently in daily life?
Historical: was it accepted at that time? Norms change.
Situational: does it fit the setting it happens in?
Medical: is it a symptom of a disorder with recognised criteria?
Statistical: is it uncommon, more than 2 standard deviations from the mean?
The approaches measure different things, so they can disagree; clinicians combine them.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.