Lesson 2: Six approaches to normality
Apply six approaches to talking aloud in a crowd
SkillApproaches to normality
Worked example
In 2026, a fictional man, Rob, walks through a busy Brisbane shopping mall talking and laughing aloud with no-one beside him. He is on a phone call through wireless earbuds that are hard to see.
(a) Use each of the six approaches to normality to judge Rob's behaviour.
(b) Explain how a historical approach might have judged the same behaviour in 1990.
Step 1: Sociocultural
In Australian society today, talking on a phone in public is an accepted norm: normal.
Step 2: Functional
The call is part of his daily life and stops him doing nothing: normal.
Step 3: Situational
A shopping mall is a setting where people often take calls: normal. (In a library or a cinema it would not fit.)
Step 4: Medical
There is no sign of a symptom of any disorder; he is talking to a real person: normal.
Step 5: Statistical
Taking calls hands-free in public is common: normal.
Step 6: Historical, now and in 1990
By today's norms the behaviour is normal. In 1990, before mobile phones were common and long before wireless earbuds, a man talking and laughing aloud to no visible person would have been unusual and probably judged abnormal by onlookers, because the norms of the time had no place for it.
The historical approach judges against the norms of a period. The behaviour is identical; the period changes the verdict.
Answer
(a) By all six approaches, Rob's behaviour is normal today: it fits current social norms and the setting, does not impair him, is not a symptom and is common. (b) In 1990 the same behaviour would probably have been judged abnormal, because talking aloud to no visible person did not fit the norms of the time.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
State each approach's criterion in a phrase.
Apply it to the details in the case.
Give a verdict (normal or abnormal) with a reason for each.
Watch out for
Confusing situational (the mall, the moment) with sociocultural (the norms of the society).
Listing definitions without applying them to Rob.