Lesson 4: What is a psychological disorder?
Expected grief or a psychological disorder?
SkillThe concept of psychological disorder
Worked example
A fictional man, Leo, aged 35, was very close to his father, who died suddenly.
- Six weeks later, Leo cries often, thinks about his father many times a day and has missed two weeks of work, but he has returned to work, sees his friends and is starting to sleep normally again.
- Fourteen months later, Leo still feels intense longing for his father nearly every day, thinks of little else, has stopped seeing friends and has been unable to return to work for three months.
Use the concept of psychological disorder to explain why Leo's experience at six weeks is not a disorder, and why a clinician might assess him for one at fourteen months.
Step 1: State the concept
A psychological disorder is a clinically significant disturbance in thinking, emotion or behaviour that reflects a dysfunction, usually with significant distress or impairment, and is not just an expected response to a common loss.
Step 2: Apply it at six weeks
Leo's sadness, crying and thoughts of his father are an expected response to a loss, which the concept explicitly excludes. They are recent, and he is recovering his functioning (work, friends, sleep). No process appears to have failed: grief is doing what it does.
Step 3: Apply it at fourteen months
Now the longing is intense, nearly every day, long after most people's grief has eased, and it is causing serious impairment (no work for three months, withdrawn from friends). The grieving process may no longer be working as it should: a possible dysfunction. DSM-5-TR includes prolonged grief disorder, which for adults can only be considered at least 12 months after the death.
Duration and impairment separate an expected response from a possible disorder. The same feeling, longing, is not the problem; its course is.
Step 4: Keep it to assessment
Whether Leo has a disorder can only be decided by a qualified clinician after a full assessment.
Answer
At six weeks Leo's grief is an expected response to loss, with functioning recovering, so it is not a disorder. At fourteen months his intense longing persists nearly every day with serious impairment, suggesting the grieving process may be dysfunctional, so a clinician might assess him for a disorder such as prolonged grief disorder.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
State the three parts of the concept and its exclusions.
Apply each to the case: disturbance, dysfunction, distress or impairment, expected response?
Use duration and degree to separate the two time points.
Watch out for
Saying any grief is a disorder because it is distressing. Expected responses to loss are excluded.
Diagnosing Leo. Say what the concept suggests, and that a clinician decides.