Lesson 1 of 8 · 12 min
Adaptive and maladaptive behaviour
Tell adaptive behaviour, which helps a person cope and function, from maladaptive behaviour, which gets in their way, using frequency, duration, distress, interference and context.
What you will be able to do
- Define adaptive and maladaptive behaviour.
- Use the effect of a behaviour on coping and functioning to discriminate between the two.
- Explain why the same behaviour can be adaptive in one person or setting and maladaptive in another.
Before a big exam, most students feel nervous. Their heart beats faster, they think about what might go wrong, and they study a bit harder. That worry is unpleasant, but it is doing a job. Now picture a student who is so worried that they cannot sleep for a week, cannot open their notes, and stay home on the day of the exam. The feeling is the same kind of thing. What it does to the person is not.
That difference is the starting point for the whole topic: before anyone talks about disorder or diagnosis, psychologists ask whether a behaviour helps a person live their life or gets in the way.
Note
If this topic brings something up
This topic is about psychological disorders, and reading about them can bring up feelings or worries about yourself or someone close to you. The cases here are fictional, and only a qualified health professional can diagnose a disorder. If you would like to talk to someone, you can call Kids Helpline on 1800 55 1800 (any time, ages 5 to 25) or Lifeline on 13 11 14, visit headspace.org.au, or speak to your GP, a school counsellor or a teacher you trust.
Definition
Adaptive and maladaptive behaviour
Adaptive behaviour helps a person cope with and adjust to the demands of everyday life, meet their goals and function in their environment.
Maladaptive behaviour gets in the way of a person coping with everyday life or reaching their goals. It may cause them distress or harm, or harm other people.
"Behaviour" here means anything a person does, thinks or feels that can be observed or reported: checking, avoiding, worrying, drinking, sleeping, eating, arguing. No behaviour is adaptive or maladaptive on its own. You decide by looking at its effect on the person, and these features usually settle it:
- Frequency and intensity. Checking the stove once before leaving is sensible. Checking it twenty times is not.
- Duration. A few bad nights' sleep after a break-up is expected. Months of it is a different matter.
- Distress. Does the behaviour leave the person upset, exhausted or ashamed?
- Interference with functioning. Does it stop them working, studying, keeping friendships or looking after themselves?
- Harm. Does it put the person or others at risk?
- Context. Is it a sensible response to what is actually happening?
| Behaviour | Adaptive | Maladaptive |
|---|---|---|
| Feeling anxious | Mia feels nervous before her driving test and practises reverse parking twice more. | Mia is so anxious about driving that she has cancelled her test four times and no longer gets in a car. |
| Checking | Tom checks the door is locked once before bed. | Tom checks the lock so many times each night that he gets less than five hours' sleep. |
| Being alone | Priya spends Sunday afternoons alone to recharge after a busy week. | Priya has stopped answering messages and has not left her room for two weeks. |
| Avoiding | Jack avoids walking home through an unlit park at night. | Jack avoids every lift and every crowded place, so he has stopped going to university. |
What mainly decides whether a behaviour is adaptive or maladaptive?
The cards come in pairs. For each one, ask: does this help the person cope and reach their goals, or get in the way?
Worked example
Discriminate between adaptive and maladaptive checking
Two fictional Year 11 students both check their phones often.
- Harper checks her messages at lunch and after school, and turns her phone off in class.
- Theo checks his phone every few minutes in class, feels panicky if it is out of reach, and has stopped finishing his work. His grades have dropped this term.
Discriminate between the two behaviours as adaptive or maladaptive, justifying each.
Step 1: Recall the deciding feature
A behaviour is adaptive if it helps the person cope and reach their goals, and maladaptive if it gets in the way, causes distress or harm.
Step 2: Judge Harper's checking
Harper checks at set times, keeps in touch with friends and still works in class. It does not interfere with her goals: adaptive.
Step 3: Judge Theo's checking
Theo's checking is frequent (every few minutes), causes distress (he feels panicky without his phone) and interferes with his functioning (unfinished work, falling grades): maladaptive.
Frequency, distress and interference are the evidence a marker looks for. Naming them is the "justify" part.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Harper's checking is adaptive: it keeps her connected without getting in the way of school. Theo's is maladaptive: it is frequent, distressing and is stopping him from completing work.
Method
Recall what makes a behaviour adaptive or maladaptive.
Look for frequency, duration, distress, interference and harm in each case.
Classify, and quote the evidence from the case.
Watch out for
Calling Theo's behaviour maladaptive because phones are bad. The judgement is about its effect on him, not the object.
Classifying without justifying: the evidence from the case earns the marks.
Common mistake
Maladaptive is about the effect, not the person
Saying a behaviour is maladaptive is not a judgement of the person. Many maladaptive behaviours began as a way of coping (avoiding something frightening brings relief at first) and become a problem only because they grow, last or spread. In an answer, describe what the behaviour does to the person's functioning.
Classify each fictional behaviour as adaptive or maladaptive.
Why a feeling that hurts can still be adaptive
Fear, anxiety and sadness are unpleasant, but they evolved because they help. Fear speeds the heart and readies the muscles to escape danger. Anxiety focuses attention on a problem that needs solving. Sadness after a loss slows a person down and draws support from others. So "it feels bad" is not the test. These responses become maladaptive when they are out of proportion to the situation, last long after it has passed, or stop the person doing what they need to do.
Exam tip
Discriminate, then justify
"Discriminate" asks you to say which it is and how you can tell. Name the behaviour as adaptive or maladaptive, then point to the evidence in the case: how often it happens, how long it has lasted, the distress it causes and what it stops the person doing. One sentence of evidence usually earns the second mark.
Summary
Adaptive behaviour helps a person cope with everyday life and reach their goals; maladaptive behaviour gets in the way and may cause distress or harm.
Decide by the effect on the person: frequency and intensity, duration, distress, interference with functioning, harm and context.
The same kind of behaviour (anxiety, checking, avoiding, being alone) can be adaptive or maladaptive depending on these features.
Unpleasant feelings can be adaptive. They become maladaptive when they are out of proportion, last too long or stop the person functioning.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.