Lesson 5: Diagnostic manuals in common use
Which manual, and why?
SkillDSM-5-TR and ICD-11
Worked example
For each professional, state whether they would most likely use DSM-5-TR, ICD-11 (or the ICD system) or both, and explain why.
(a) A researcher in Brisbane running a trial of a new therapy for depression, who needs to decide which volunteers have major depressive disorder.
(b) A hospital clinical coder recording why patients were admitted.
(c) A WHO officer comparing rates of depressive disorders in 40 countries.
(d) A clinical psychologist assessing a client.
Step 1: (a) The researcher
DSM-5-TR, usually with a structured interview based on it. Its explicit criteria let researchers select participants the same way as studies elsewhere, so results can be compared.
Step 2: (b) The hospital coder
ICD. Hospitals record diagnoses with ICD codes for records, funding and statistics. (Australian hospitals use the ICD-10-AM, an Australian version of the previous revision.)
Step 3: (c) The WHO officer
ICD-11. It is the WHO's own classification, free in many languages and used by member states to report health statistics in a comparable way.
Step 4: (d) The clinical psychologist
Either or both. Many Australian psychologists use DSM-5-TR criteria to assess and plan treatment, and use ICD codes when reports or referrals need them.
Answer
(a) DSM-5-TR: explicit criteria make research comparable. (b) ICD: the coding system for hospital records and statistics. (c) ICD-11: the WHO's global, free classification. (d) Either or both, depending on the purpose.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Ask what the professional needs the manual for: diagnosing, selecting participants, coding, or counting.
Match: detailed criteria for clinical and research use (DSM-5-TR); codes for records and global statistics (ICD).
Watch out for
Saying ICD-11 cannot be used for mental disorders. Chapter 6 covers them.
Giving the manual without the reason; "discuss the uses" needs the why.