Lesson 5 of 8 · 16 min

Diagnostic manuals in common use

Compare DSM-5-TR (2022) and ICD-11 (2022), their publishers, scope, structure and approach, and explain how psychiatrists, psychologists, GPs, researchers and health systems use them.

What you will be able to do

  • Describe the purpose of a diagnostic manual.
  • Compare DSM-5-TR and ICD-11 on publisher, scope, structure, approach and access.
  • Discuss how different professions use each manual.

If two clinicians in different cities each assessed the same person, how would they know they meant the same thing by "depression"? A diagnostic manual solves that problem. It lists recognised disorders, gives each a name and a code, and sets out what must be present for a diagnosis: which symptoms, how many, for how long, and what must be ruled out. That gives clinicians, researchers and health systems a common language.

Two manuals are in common use, and the syllabus names both: the DSM-5-TR (2022) and the ICD-11 (2022).

DSM-5-TR (2022)

Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, fifth edition, text revision.

  • Published by the American Psychiatric Association (APA), released in March 2022; a revision of the text of DSM-5 (2013).
  • Covers mental disorders only.
  • Each disorder has explicit diagnostic criteria (for example, at least five of nine symptoms over the same two weeks), plus text on features, prevalence, development and course, risk and prognostic factors, culture and differential diagnosis.
  • Mainly categorical, with severity specifiers.
  • A book you buy.

ICD-11 (2022)

International Classification of Diseases, 11th revision.

  • Published by the World Health Organization (WHO); endorsed in 2019 and in effect from 1 January 2022.
  • Covers all diseases and health conditions; mental, behavioural or neurodevelopmental disorders are Chapter 6.
  • Gives each condition a code and a description; the WHO's companion clinical manual (2024) sets out diagnostic requirements, written to leave more room for clinical judgement and culture.
  • More dimensional in places: personality disorder is one diagnosis rated mild, moderate or severe.
  • Free online, in many languages.

What they share. Both define a psychological disorder in almost the same words, both use broad groups of related disorders, and DSM-5-TR's codes are themselves ICD codes (from the version of the ICD used in the United States), so the two can be used together. DSM-5-TR added a new disorder, prolonged grief disorder, which ICD-11 also includes. Both are revised as research changes what is known.

Where they differ. The DSM is an American manual of mental disorders with detailed criteria, built mainly for clinicians and researchers. The ICD is a global classification of every health condition, built for recording and counting health problems in every country, including those with few specialists. Their groupings also differ in places: DSM-5-TR has separate chapters for bipolar and related disorders and depressive disorders, while ICD-11 puts them together under mood disorders. DSM-5-TR lists ten specific personality disorders (including antisocial personality disorder) in three clusters; ICD-11 has a single personality disorder graded by severity, with trait qualifiers such as dissociality describing its pattern.

Interactive

DSM-5-TR, ICD-11 or both?

Sort each statement, then compare the manuals side by side.

Is each statement true of DSM-5-TR, ICD-11 or both?

How different professions use the manuals
ProfessionWhat they doHow they use the manuals
PsychiatristA medical doctor who specialises in mental health; can prescribe medication.Diagnoses disorders with DSM-5-TR or ICD-11 criteria to plan treatment, including medication, and to communicate with other doctors.
Clinical psychologistAssesses, diagnoses and treats disorders with psychological therapies; does not prescribe.Uses diagnostic criteria (often DSM-5-TR in Australia) and structured interviews to assess, plan therapy and write reports.
General practitioner (GP)Usually the first health professional a person sees.Recognises common disorders, records them with ICD-based codes, starts treatment and refers to a psychologist or psychiatrist.
ResearcherStudies causes and treatments of disorders.Uses DSM-5-TR criteria (and structured interviews) to decide who has a disorder, so studies around the world compare like with like.
Health statistician and hospital coderRecords and counts health conditions for governments.Uses ICD codes for hospital records, death and illness statistics, funding and planning. Australian hospitals use the ICD-10-AM (Thirteenth Edition from July 2025).
Social worker, mental health nurse, counsellorSupports people and families day to day.Uses a diagnosis to understand a person's needs and plan support; the WHO wrote its 2024 clinical manual for these professions too.

A health department wants to compare the number of hospital admissions for depression in Queensland with those in other countries. Which manual's system is it most likely to rely on, and why?

Choose one answer

Worked example

Which manual, and why?

  • Simple familiar

For each professional, state whether they would most likely use DSM-5-TR, ICD-11 (or the ICD system) or both, and explain why.

(a) A researcher in Brisbane running a trial of a new therapy for depression, who needs to decide which volunteers have major depressive disorder.

(b) A hospital clinical coder recording why patients were admitted.

(c) A WHO officer comparing rates of depressive disorders in 40 countries.

(d) A clinical psychologist assessing a client.

4 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Ask what the professional needs the manual for: diagnosing, selecting participants, coding, or counting.

  2. Match: detailed criteria for clinical and research use (DSM-5-TR); codes for records and global statistics (ICD).

Watch out for

  • Saying ICD-11 cannot be used for mental disorders. Chapter 6 covers them.

  • Giving the manual without the reason; "discuss the uses" needs the why.

Common mistake

Two common slips

The DSM is published by the American Psychiatric Association, not the Australian Psychological Society or the American Psychological Association. And the ICD is not "for physical illness only": mental, behavioural or neurodevelopmental disorders are its Chapter 6.

Do the manuals explain behaviour?

Mostly, the manuals describe. A diagnosis says which pattern of symptoms a person has; it does not, by itself, say why. Someone who says "he avoids people because he has social anxiety disorder" has given a name, not an explanation. The manuals' text does summarise what is known about risk factors, course and outcome, which helps with prognosis, but explanations of cause come from research and from a full assessment of the person. You weigh this in the last lesson of the topic.

Exam tip

Comparing the manuals

"Compare" means similarities and differences, side by side. Use sentence frames: "Both DSM-5-TR and ICD-11 …"; "DSM-5-TR is …, whereas ICD-11 is …". Cover the publisher, the scope, the structure and approach, access, and the professions that use each, with a reason for each use.

Summary

  • A diagnostic manual names and codes disorders and sets out what is needed for a diagnosis, giving professionals a common language.

  • DSM-5-TR (2022): American Psychiatric Association; mental disorders only; detailed criteria; mainly categorical; bought.

  • ICD-11 (2022): World Health Organization; all health conditions, mental disorders in Chapter 6; diagnostic requirements; more dimensional in places; free.

  • Both define a disorder the same way and are revised as research changes.

  • Psychiatrists and psychologists diagnose with them, researchers select participants with them, and GPs, hospitals and governments code and count with the ICD.

  • The manuals mostly describe disorders; they do not by themselves explain why a person has one.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 5 of 80% read

Save your progress with a free account