Lesson 3 of 10 · 15 min
Simultaneity is relative
Explain, with Einstein's train and the flashlights on a train, why two events at different places that are simultaneous for one observer are not simultaneous for an observer moving relative to them.
What you will be able to do
- Explain the concept of simultaneity.
- Use the constant speed of light to decide which of two events happens first in a given frame.
- Explain the flashlights on a train scenario from both frames.
"Two things happened at the same time" seems like a fact everyone should agree on. Einstein realised it isn't. If light travels at for every observer, then observers moving relative to each other will disagree about whether two separated events were simultaneous.
To see why, you need one careful habit: an observer works out when an event happened by allowing for the time its light took to reach them.
Definition
Simultaneous events
An event is something that happens at one place at one instant. Two events are simultaneous in a frame of reference if they happen at the same time as measured by synchronised clocks in that frame.
For an observer exactly halfway between two events, the events are simultaneous if their light arrives at the same moment.
Lightning strikes both ends of the train at the same time in the platform frame. Watch which flash reaches the passenger at the centre of the train first, then change the speed.
Here is Einstein's thought experiment. Lightning strikes the front and back of a moving train, leaving scorch marks on both the train and the platform.
Platform observer, standing halfway between the marks on the platform: the two flashes reach her at the same moment. Light travels at from each mark and she is equidistant from both, so she concludes the strikes were simultaneous.
Train observer, sitting at the centre of the train: while the light is travelling, she moves towards the front flash and away from the back flash, so the front flash reaches her first. In her own frame she is at rest, halfway between the marks on the train, and both flashes travel towards her at . The only way the front flash can arrive first is if it was emitted first. She concludes the front strike happened first.
Key idea
The relativity of simultaneity
Events at different places that are simultaneous in one inertial frame are not simultaneous in a frame moving relative to it (along the line joining them). The event towards the front of the moving observer's motion happens first in their frame.
Both observers are right. There is no absolute "now" shared by all observers. This follows directly from the second postulate.
Worked example
Which lightning strike came first?
A train travels east at high speed past a platform. Lightning strikes the west end (A) and the east end (B) of the train, leaving marks on the train and the platform. An observer on the platform, halfway between the marks on the platform, receives both flashes at the same instant.
Explain which strike happened first according to a passenger seated at the exact centre of the train.
Step 1: Platform frame
The platform observer is equidistant from both marks, and both flashes travel at . They arrive together, so the strikes were simultaneous in the platform frame.
Step 2: Track the passenger in the platform frame
While the light travels, the passenger moves east, towards B's flash and away from A's. So B's flash reaches the passenger first. Every observer agrees on this, because the arrival of a flash at the passenger is a single event at one place.
Step 3: Reason in the passenger's frame
In the train frame, the passenger is at rest, halfway between the marks on the train, and each flash travels towards them at (second postulate). Equal distances at equal speeds take equal times.
The passenger cannot say "I moved towards B", because in their own frame they are at rest.
Step 4: Conclude
Since B's flash arrived first but took the same time to travel, strike B must have happened first in the train frame.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
In the passenger's frame strike B, at the east end (towards the direction of the train's motion), happened before strike A. Events that are simultaneous in the platform frame are not simultaneous in the train frame.
Method
Decide what each observer receives, and when.
In each observer's own frame, light travels at in every direction.
Equal distances at equal speeds: the flash that arrives first was emitted first.
Watch out for
Saying the strikes "only look" non-simultaneous because of the light delay. The passenger has corrected for the delay; the order really is different in their frame.
A rocket flies east past a space station. In the station's frame, two beacons, one east and one west of the station, flash at the same instant. According to an astronaut in the rocket, which beacon flashes first?
Note
Flashlights on a train
A passenger stands at the exact centre of a carriage and switches on two torches at once, one pointing to the front wall and one to the back wall.
Train frame: the walls are at rest and equal distances away, and the light travels at both ways. The light reaches both walls simultaneously.
Platform frame: the light still travels at in both directions (not forwards and backwards). But during the trip, the back wall moves towards the light and the front wall moves away from it. The light reaches the back wall first.
Both descriptions are correct. The two arrivals happen at different places, so the observers need not agree about their order in time.
Platform frame: the back wall (left) closes the gap at while the front wall (right) runs away at , so the backward pulse arrives first.
In the platform frame, a carriage is long and moves at . A lamp at the centre of the carriage sends light towards both ends. In the platform frame, light closes on the back wall at and on the front wall at . Calculate the time between the light reaching the back wall and the light reaching the front wall, as measured in the platform frame. Give your answer in nanoseconds.
Common mistake
It is not about light taking time to reach you
The relativity of simultaneity is not the delay of light reaching a distant observer. Every observer in these examples corrects for the light's travel time. The disagreement that remains is real, because each observer measures light travelling at in their own frame.
Exam tip
Explaining simultaneity
A full-marks explanation usually has three parts: (1) identify the two frames and where the events happen; (2) use the second postulate (light at in both frames) and the motion of the observer or walls relative to the light; (3) conclude which event is first in each frame, and state that events simultaneous in one frame need not be simultaneous in another.
Summary
Events are simultaneous in a frame if they happen at the same time on that frame's synchronised clocks.
Because light travels at in every frame, observers in relative motion disagree about whether separated events are simultaneous.
For a moving observer, the event towards the front of their motion happens first.
Flashlights on a train: simultaneous arrival in the train frame; back wall first in the platform frame.
Events at the same place are simultaneous for every observer; the disagreement is only for separated events.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.