Lesson 1 of 10 · 13 min
Frames of reference and relative motion
Describe frames of reference and inertial frames, explain why every measurement of motion is relative to an observer, and meet the observations classical physics cannot explain.
What you will be able to do
- Describe a frame of reference and an inertial frame of reference.
- Explain why motion can only be measured relative to an observer.
- Add and subtract velocities in one dimension using classical (Galilean) relativity.
- Describe observations, such as atmospheric muons, that classical physics cannot explain.
You're sitting on a train with a coffee on the table. To you, the cup is perfectly still. To someone waiting on the platform, the cup is moving at . To an astronaut watching from space, it's also swinging around with Earth's rotation at hundreds of metres per second.
Which of these is the cup's real speed? This lesson's answer, and the starting point of relativity, is that the question has no answer. Speed only means something relative to an observer.
Definition
Frame of reference
A frame of reference is the point of view from which an observer measures positions and times: a set of coordinate axes and synchronised clocks that move with the observer.
An inertial frame of reference is one that is not accelerating: it is at rest or moving at constant velocity. In an inertial frame, Newton's first law holds: an object with no net force on it stays at rest or keeps moving in a straight line at constant speed.
The passenger walks at relative to the train. The train moves at relative to the platform. Each observer describes the passenger's motion from their own frame.
The passenger's velocity relative to the train is forward. Relative to the platform, it is forward. Both are correct descriptions, made from different frames.
For everyday speeds, you find the velocity of an object relative to another frame by adding velocities as vectors. This is classical (or Galilean) relativity.
Worked example
Velocities measured from different frames
A train travels east at relative to the platform. A passenger walks east along the aisle at relative to the train. A car drives east beside the track at relative to the ground.
Determine the passenger's velocity relative to (a) the platform and (b) the car.
Step 1: Choose a positive direction
Take east as positive. All three velocities are then positive.
Step 2: Add velocities to change from the train frame to the platform frame
The passenger is carried along by the train and also walks within it, so the two velocities add.
Step 3: Subtract the car's velocity to change to the car's frame
In the car's frame the car is at rest, so subtract its velocity from everything.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) east relative to the platform. (b) west relative to the car: the car's driver sees the passenger drifting backwards.
Method
Choose a positive direction.
To change frame, add the velocity of the old frame relative to the new one.
A negative answer means the opposite direction.
Watch out for
Forgetting that all three answers are correct: each describes the motion from a different frame.
This simple addition only works when every speed is much less than .
Car A travels north at . Car B travels north at on the same road. Calculate the speed of car A as measured by the driver of car B.
Key idea
There is no absolute rest
Galileo noticed that inside a ship's cabin moving smoothly at constant velocity, a dropped ball falls straight down, fish swim equally easily in every direction, and nothing tells you that you are moving. No experiment done entirely inside an inertial frame can detect that frame's constant velocity.
So "at rest" and "moving" are not properties of an object alone. Motion can only be measured relative to an observer, and every inertial observer is equally entitled to say they are the one at rest.
Which of these is the best example of an inertial frame of reference?
Common mistake
Inertial does not mean stationary
A frame moving at a constant velocity is just as inertial as one at rest. A train cruising at a steady on a straight track is an inertial frame (to a good approximation); a train braking at a station is not.
Classical relativity works brilliantly for trains and cars. But at the end of the 1800s, physicists found it clashed with light, and over the next decades they found natural phenomena it could not explain at all.
Note
Observations classical physics cannot explain
- Muons in the atmosphere. Cosmic rays striking the upper atmosphere, about – up, create muons. A muon at rest decays with a mean lifetime of only , so even at nearly classical physics says a typical muon travels only about . Yet muons arrive at sea level in large numbers.
- Particles in accelerators. Push a proton with a constant force and classical physics predicts its speed rises without limit. In real accelerators, the proton's momentum keeps increasing, but its speed creeps closer and closer to and never reaches it.
- The speed of light. Every measurement of the speed of light in a vacuum gives the same value, , however the source or the observer is moving.
You'll explain each of these in this topic.
A muon moves at . Using classical physics, calculate how far it travels during one mean lifetime of .
Summary
A frame of reference is an observer's coordinate system and clocks; an inertial frame is one that is not accelerating.
Constant velocity cannot be detected from inside an inertial frame, so there is no absolute rest: motion is only measured relative to an observer.
At everyday speeds, velocities add: .
Muons reaching sea level, particles that never reach in accelerators, and the constant speed of light cannot be explained by classical physics.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.