Lesson 8 of 10 · 17 min
Relativistic momentum and the cosmic speed limit
Calculate relativistic momentum with , compare it with classical momentum, and explain why momentum growing without limit makes unreachable for any object with mass.
What you will be able to do
- Describe rest mass and relativistic momentum.
- Solve problems with , including finding a speed from a momentum.
- Explain the implications of momentum increasing without limit as an object approaches the speed of light.
- Explain why the speed of light is the maximum speed for matter and information.
In a particle accelerator, electric fields push protons around a ring, faster and faster. Classically, a steady push gives a steady increase in speed, so the protons should eventually pass . They never do. The protons at the Large Hadron Collider travel at about , and pushing them harder changes only the digits far after the decimal point.
Yet each push still increases the protons' momentum by the expected amount. The resolution is that classical momentum, , is wrong at high speeds.
Definition
Rest mass and relativistic momentum
The rest mass of an object is its mass measured in a frame where it is at rest. It is a property of the object and every observer agrees on it.
The relativistic momentum of an object moving at speed is
This is the quantity that is conserved in collisions in every inertial frame. At everyday speeds and it reduces to .
Momentum against speed, in units of . The curves agree at low speed; near relativistic momentum grows without limit while the speed barely changes.
Worked example
Momentum of a fast electron
An electron (rest mass ) moves at . Calculate its relativistic momentum, and compare it with the classical value.
Step 1: Find the speed and the root
;
Step 2: Classical momentum
Step 3: Relativistic momentum
Step 4: Compare
: the true momentum is more than twice the classical value.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
, times the classical value of .
Method
Calculate .
Divide by .
Watch out for
Forgetting to convert to before multiplying by the mass.
Calculate the relativistic momentum of a proton (rest mass ) moving at .
Key idea
Why nothing with mass reaches c
A force changes momentum: . A steady force adds momentum at a steady rate, whatever the speed.
At low speed, extra momentum means extra speed. Near , climbs so steeply that a large increase in momentum produces only a tiny increase in speed. As , , so reaching would need an infinite momentum, infinite impulse and infinite energy. No object with rest mass can be accelerated to (or beyond) the speed of light. Only massless particles, such as photons, travel at , and they always do.
An electron moves at . An accelerator doubles its momentum. Which statement best describes the new speed?
Worked example
The speed of a proton from its momentum
A proton (rest mass ) in an accelerator has momentum .
(a) Show that classical physics gives an impossible speed.
(b) Calculate the proton's actual speed.
Step 1: Classical speed
, which is about : impossible.
Step 2: Rearrange the relativistic momentum equation
Square : , so and
Step 3: Substitute
, so
Step 4: Evaluate and check
. Check: and ✓
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Classically , which is impossible. (b) ().
Method
Rearrange to .
Substitute back to check.
Watch out for
Using at high speed.
Algebra slips when squaring; check by substituting back.
By what factor is the relativistic momentum of an object moving at greater than the value classical physics predicts?
Could information travel faster than light?
Special relativity forbids it, for two reasons.
- Matter can't. Any signal carried by an object with mass would need infinite momentum and energy to reach .
- Cause would follow effect. Because simultaneity is relative, a signal sent faster than light from event A to event B would, for some inertial observers, arrive before it was sent. Those observers could, in principle, use a reply to prevent the original message being sent. Relativity keeps cause before effect for every observer only if no information travels faster than .
Some things appear to beat light: the spot of a laser swept across the Moon, or the correlation between entangled quantum particles. None of them can carry a message from one place to another faster than . Every experiment so far agrees.
Common mistake
Rest mass does not increase
Some older books say an object's "mass increases" as it speeds up. QCAA uses rest mass , which is the same for all observers, and puts the factor into the momentum. Write "the momentum increases without limit", not "the mass becomes infinite".
Summary
Rest mass is measured in the object's rest frame and is the same for all observers.
Relativistic momentum is conserved in every inertial frame and reduces to at low speed.
As , : more momentum gives less and less extra speed.
Reaching would need infinite momentum and energy, so no object with mass can reach it.
Faster-than-light signals would let effects precede causes for some observers, so information is limited to .
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.