Lesson 6 of 10 · 18 min
Which observer measures what
Decide which observer measures the proper time and the proper length in any scenario, read the Lorentz factor graph, and solve multi-step problems that work backwards to a speed or a proper quantity.
What you will be able to do
- Identify the observer who measures the proper time interval and the proper length, and justify the choice.
- Read and interpret a graph of the Lorentz factor against speed.
- Calculate a speed from a Lorentz factor, a dilated time or a contracted length.
- Solve a problem from both frames and check the answers agree.
The algebra of time dilation and length contraction is short. Nearly every lost mark in this topic comes from one decision made before the algebra: which measurement is the proper one? Get that right and the rest follows.
Here is a reliable way to decide, and a graph that shows how big the effects are.
Choosing the proper quantity
For a time interval, name the two events.
For example, "the muon is created" and "the muon decays", or "the ship leaves Earth" and "the ship reaches the star".
Find the observer who sees both events at the same place.
Usually the observer travelling with the clock, particle or ship. That observer measures the proper time ; everyone else measures the longer .
For a length, name the object or the two end points.
A spacecraft, a tunnel, or the distance between Earth and a star.
Find the observer at rest relative to it.
That observer measures the proper length ; anyone moving relative to it measures the shorter .
Check the direction of your answer.
and , always.
| Scenario | Proper time measured by | Proper length measured by |
|---|---|---|
| A muon falls from the upper atmosphere | the muon (its lifetime) | Earth (the thickness of the atmosphere) |
| A spacecraft flies from Earth to a star | the crew (departure and arrival both happen at the ship) | Earth (the Earth–star distance); the crew (the ship's own length) |
| A train passes through a tunnel | a passenger (time for their seat to pass through, events at their seat) | the passenger (the train's length); a trackside worker (the tunnel's length) |
| A pion decays in a particle accelerator | the pion (its lifetime) | the laboratory (the length of the detector) |
Common mistake
One observer can measure a proper length and a dilated time
An Earth observer watching a spacecraft fly to a star measures the proper length of the trip (Earth and star are at rest relative to them) but not the proper time (the ship leaves from one place and arrives at another). The crew measure the proper time but a contracted length. Decide each quantity separately.
A spacecraft travels at constant speed from Earth to a space station that is at rest relative to Earth. Which observer measures the proper time interval for the journey, and which measures the proper length of the journey?
Move along the curve. Below about , is within 5 % of 1, so relativity barely matters. Above it climbs steeply, and it has no upper limit as .
against . The dashed line is an asymptote.
Worked example
The speed at which
Calculate the speed at which a clock runs at half its normal rate as measured by a stationary observer (). Give the speed as a fraction of and in .
Step 1: Rearrange the Lorentz factor
Step 2: Substitute
Step 3: Take the square root
Step 4: Convert to metres per second
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
.
Method
Watch out for
Forgetting the final square root and answering .
Assuming half the rate means half the speed of light.
Calculate the speed, in , at which .
Worked example
How fast was the pion?
A charged pion at rest has a mean lifetime of . Pions in an accelerator beam are measured in the laboratory to have a mean lifetime of .
(a) Calculate the speed of the pions.
(b) Calculate the average distance a pion travels in the laboratory before decaying.
Step 1: Identify proper and dilated times
The lifetime at rest is the proper time, (creation and decay happen at the pion). The laboratory lifetime is dilated, .
Step 2: Find the Lorentz factor
Step 3: Solve for the speed
, so
Step 4: Find the laboratory distance
In the laboratory frame, use the laboratory speed and the laboratory time:
Distances and times must come from the same frame. Using the rest lifetime would give the classical (wrong) prediction of .
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) (). (b) About .
Method
, then .
Keep every quantity in one frame when using .
Watch out for
Using as .
Mixing frames: multiplying the laboratory speed by the rest lifetime.
Kaons in a beam travel at . Physicists in the laboratory measure their mean lifetime as . Calculate the mean lifetime of a kaon at rest.
Worked example
A trip to Proxima Centauri from both frames
Proxima Centauri is light-years from Earth, measured in Earth's frame. A spacecraft travels there at a constant . Calculate:
(a) the time for the trip measured on Earth
(b) the Earth–star distance measured by the crew
(c) the time for the trip measured by the crew.
Step 1: Earth frame time
A light-year is the distance light travels in a year, so dividing light-years by a fraction of gives years directly.
Step 2: Contract the distance for the crew
Earth and the star are at rest relative to each other, so ly. The crew see it moving: ly
Step 3: Crew time from the crew's distance
Step 4: Check with time dilation
Departure and arrival both happen at the ship, so the crew measure the proper time: years. Both methods agree.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) years. (b) light-years. (c) years.
Method
Earth measures the proper length; the crew measure the proper time.
Within one frame, use time = distance ÷ speed.
Check one frame's answer against the other.
Watch out for
Taking ly as the crew's distance.
Dividing the contracted distance by instead of by .
Exam tip
Show your frame
Begin every relativity calculation with a sentence such as "The muon measures the proper time because it is present at both its creation and its decay." It earns marks for reasoning, and it stops you swapping and (or and ).
Summary
Proper time: the observer who sees both events at the same place. Proper length: the observer at rest relative to the object or the two end points.
The same observer can measure a proper length and a dilated time; decide each quantity separately.
is close to 1 below about and grows without limit as .
To find a speed from , use .
Working a problem in both frames gives the same physical outcome: a check worth doing.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.