Lesson 7 of 10 · 18 min
The evidence for time dilation and length contraction
Describe and analyse the experimental evidence for relativity — atmospheric muons, particle lifetimes in accelerators, atomic clocks on aircraft and GPS satellites — and how navigation technologies depend on it.
What you will be able to do
- Explain the arrival of atmospheric muons at sea level using time dilation (Earth frame) and length contraction (muon frame).
- Describe the Hafele–Keating experiment and particle-lifetime measurements as evidence for time dilation.
- Explain why GPS needs relativistic corrections, and how ring laser gyroscopes use the constant speed of light.
- Consider the benefits and ethical issues of satellite navigation and satellite datasets.
A theory that says time runs differently for different observers needs strong evidence. Special relativity has some of the best-tested predictions in science, from particles that live 10 times longer than they should to the navigation app on your phone.
Key idea
The muon puzzle
Cosmic rays striking the upper atmosphere produce muons about up, travelling at about . At rest, muons have a mean lifetime of . Classically, a typical muon travels only before decaying, and almost none should survive a trip. Yet detectors at sea level record large numbers of them.
Switch between the Earth frame and the muon frame. Earth sees a slow-running muon clock; the muon sees a thin, fast-moving atmosphere. Both predict the same number of survivors. The widget counts survivors with the muon's half-life, (the time for half of them to decay, ); the estimate above uses the mean lifetime, .
Earth frame — time dilation
The atmosphere is at rest: its thickness, , is a proper length.
The muon's clock runs slow. Its mean lifetime, measured from Earth, is
In that time it travels about on average, ten times the classical distance, so a large fraction reach the ground.
Muon frame — length contraction
The muon is at rest: its lifetime, , is a proper time.
The atmosphere rushes past at , contracted to
A thin layer of air takes very little time to pass, so a large fraction of muons are still alive when the ground arrives.
Worked example
Atmospheric muons in two frames
A muon is created above the ground and travels straight down at . Muons at rest have a mean lifetime of .
Show that the Earth frame and the muon frame agree on how many mean lifetimes pass during the trip, and compare with the classical prediction.
Step 1: Find the Lorentz factor
, and
Step 2: Earth frame: the trip time
The height is a proper length for Earth.
Step 3: Earth frame: the dilated lifetime
The muon's clock runs slow: . Number of lifetimes:
Step 4: Muon frame: the contracted atmosphere
The muon's is a proper time. The atmosphere moves, so . Time for the ground to arrive: , which is lifetimes.
Step 5: Compare with classical physics
Classically, lifetimes pass. The surviving fraction after mean lifetimes is : about with relativity, but only classically.
Detectors at sea level find large numbers of muons, matching the relativistic prediction.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Both frames give mean lifetimes for the trip, so about of muons reach the ground. Classical physics predicts lifetimes and almost no survivors, contradicting observation.
Method
Earth frame: proper length, dilated lifetime .
Muon frame: proper lifetime, contracted distance .
Both frames must agree on what happens to the muon.
Watch out for
Using time dilation and length contraction together in the same frame (double counting).
Treating the muon's lifetime as dilated.
Muons at rest have a mean lifetime of . Calculate the mean lifetime measured by an Earth observer for muons moving at . Give your answer in microseconds.
In the muon's own frame, its lifetime is only . How does an observer travelling with the muon explain why it reaches the ground?
A Frisch–Smith-style comparison (1963): muons counted at altitude and at sea level, with predictions for muons at (half-life ).
History
Clocks on aircraft and particles in accelerators
- Hafele–Keating (1971). Joseph Hafele and Richard Keating flew caesium atomic clocks around the world on commercial jets, eastward and then westward, and compared them with clocks at the US Naval Observatory. The flown clocks differed from the ground clocks by tens to hundreds of nanoseconds, matching the combined predictions of special relativity (speed) and general relativity (altitude) within the experimental uncertainty.
- Particle lifetimes. Unstable particles such as pions and muons in accelerator beams live longer, by exactly the factor for their speed. In the 1970s, muons circulating at in a storage ring at CERN () lived 29 times longer than muons at rest, agreeing with time dilation to about 0.1 %.
Key idea
GPS needs relativity
A GPS receiver finds its position from the times signals take to arrive from several satellites, so the satellite clocks must agree with each other and with Earth to within nanoseconds.
- The satellites orbit at about , so special relativity makes their clocks run slow by about per day.
- They are up, where gravity is weaker, so general relativity makes them run fast by about per day.
The net effect is about fast per day. Light travels about in , so without corrections GPS positions would drift by kilometres every day. The satellite clocks are deliberately set to tick slightly slow before launch to cancel the effect.
If GPS satellite clocks gained per day relative to ground clocks, the calculated distances to the satellites would be wrong by the distance light travels in that time. Calculate this distance, in kilometres.
Ring laser gyroscopes, satellite data and ethics
Ring laser gyroscopes (RLGs). Two laser beams travel in opposite directions around a closed loop of mirrors. Because light travels at in both directions, when the gyroscope rotates one beam has slightly further to go than the other (the Sagnac effect). The resulting frequency difference measures the rotation rate. Aircraft, ships and submarines use RLGs for inertial navigation that works even where GPS signals are blocked or jammed.
Satellites and data. Satellites with precise clocks and positions record data across the whole globe, continuously, for decades: sea-level heights to centimetres, ice-sheet thickness, gravity variations, atmospheric temperature profiles. Datasets that once came from scattered ships and weather stations are now vastly larger, more accurate and longer-running.
Ethics. GPS was built by the US military, and access can be degraded or denied by its owner. The same signals guide ambulances, aircraft and farm machinery, but also weapons and surveillance. Location tracking of phones raises questions of privacy and consent, and societies that depend on satellite timing (for banking and power grids as well as navigation) are vulnerable to jamming, spoofing and outages. Independent systems (Galileo, GLONASS, BeiDou) and backup technologies such as RLGs reduce, but don't remove, these risks.
Exam tip
Describing evidence
For a "describe the evidence" question: name the experiment or phenomenon, state what was measured, state what classical physics predicts, and state how the relativistic prediction matches the measurement. For muons, use one frame consistently: time dilation in the Earth frame or length contraction in the muon frame.
Summary
Muons created about up reach the ground because, from Earth, their lifetime is dilated by .
In the muon's frame its lifetime is normal but the atmosphere is length-contracted: both frames predict the same survival.
Atomic clocks on aircraft (Hafele–Keating) and fast particles in accelerators confirm time dilation quantitatively.
GPS satellite clocks must be corrected by about per day (special plus general relativity) to keep positions accurate.
Ring laser gyroscopes use the constant speed of light to measure rotation; satellite navigation brings real benefits and real ethical questions.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.